Our promise. We provide a buying advantage with verified reviews and unbiased editorial research.
About Prudential Disability Insurance
This profile has not been claimed by the company. See reviews below to learn more or submit your own review.
Prudential Disability Insurance Reviews
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,246,788 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
I called them weeks in advance of my surgery to set things up. I have had 2 surgeries now, and have been off work for a month. I’ve received $288 in that time. Who lives off $288/mo? Their website is garbage, and that is deliberate.
I lost the use of left and right hands due to broken wrist. After losing strength in my physical being and mental depression I turned to them in writing to please assess me into a new livelihood. No help at all was received. I always worked with my hands and that was my forte'. Never was a desk job employee. Always excelled in the workplace field. On my own to become more proactive I found a job to try to help myself and others. I did not excel and spending my benefits to invest in myself I contacted Prudential Disability about my losses. I was told that nothing would be reimbursed.
I had ~ 5 case managers. The last manager Gisela ** denied benefits even showing monthly income from a commission job. Not one representative has ever taken a call to help me out. Years later now I am considered poverty level with mental and physical disability. It now is extremely hard to cope with society and and pain riddles my body. I feel like this company has failed me inside and out. I have truly been disgraced.
Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
Injured back, my doctor's have me off work, My work has no problem with me following doctors orders. I seen two different doctors. Prudential spent almost 2 months "investigating" then, said their medical staff who never seen me, examined me, talked to me or met me, decided the two doctors who did examine me were wrong and denied my claim forcing me to get an lawyer... Their staff talks to you like you're stupid. I pay out of my checks for this disability safety net insurance, just to go 7 weeks now without a pay check of any kind, and they have an excuse every week. I skipped the appeal process and just got a lawyer... Their entire purpose is to take your money for a benefit, that they will fight tooth and nail to deny you for, they will call your doctor's liars based on the opinion of people you never met or talked to. Just bad people to do business with if you care about your employees even a little.
Literally the worst, most infuriating company I've dealt with by far. Accident was the 18th of July, 2 months later still no payments even though claim was approved. Payment date just keeps changing and I just keep getting lied to. Impossible to get ahold of someone who can or will actually help. This whole fiasco has been one big joke.
This has got to be one of the worst company I ever dealt with. They give you the runaround. By the time you get your money it might take two months. Nobody knows what they’re doing. You get more sick dealing with them than your sickness itself having to deal with these people on a daily basis. It’s horrible. I filed a claim for a mental issue and I’m getting worse dealing with Prudential than when I started the claim. This company should be fined for all the mistreatment they do to older people because all they do is take your money.
The worst company ever for short term disability. They kept messing up my paperwork. Staff is very incompetent including claims manager. Nobody follows through. For example: If they receive a blank fax from a DR's office, they don't reach back out to them or to me so that I can reach out. Claims manager never calls you back. Anyone who’s on maternity/medical leave shouldn’t have to go through all this trouble to get paid. I have tried to speak to a manager or someone in charge and they won't let you, I can't get a phone number to the claims manager that is supposed to be working my claim. It has been over 14 business days since they received the last bit of paperwork they needed and my claim is still pending but nobody can tell me why.
Ran into severe mental health issues. Prudential paid out both the STD and the LTD. They did apply some soft pressure disguised as help in the beginning to help me get back to work. Then they wanted another opinion besides my psychiatrist so they had me go to an 'independent' medical doctor. In my case he was a fair-minded person who came to the same diagnosis as my doctor. Prudential paid without issue. All in all they paid out in total about $400K. I don't know if I ever was under video surveillance but since the symptoms were real it would not have been an issue.
I started my claim with Prudential on 1/13/2021 for a scheduled procedure that was to happen on 1/20/2021, due to COVID 19 my surgery was rescheduled for 2/10/2021. All my information from my employer, myself and doctor's office is all in order. I called on the 2/4/2021 to verify that all my documents were in order and my claim was good to go and that call confirmed that all was in order.
I have plenty of approved time and I have been with my job for two years so I am eligible for STD and FMLA through Prudential. I had my surgery and when I at the beginning of recovering I log in to the online portal to see that my claim is still pending. This sets me on my journey of calling from 2/22 – 3/1/2021 to which no one has been able to resolve my issue. When I called on 2/22/2021 I was told that there was an internal error and there was nothing that could be done on my part to fix it but it had to be fixed with IT. Today is 3/1/2021 and I was told that my claim is now under QA and the only person that can look into it is my case worker. This is the same case worker that called me late on 2/26/2021 to tell me that IT has been in touch with her and that issue would be cleared up that day and that she would call me back.
At this point, I see that no on intends to call me or even care to resolve my issue. I have followed up with my employer and now I am filing a complaint here. I am not sure why only person in this multi-million dollar company is the only one that can speak to me or why a new claim could have not been restarted in the place of this ‘bad apple’ claim. You have the dates that I have been out of work and my bank is account is negative and I am unable to go to the grocery store. This is an absolute nightmare while I am trying to recover from my surgery, through a snowstorm, and a pandemic. Please know that people rely on the funds to supplement our income while we are out of work and you receive your money from the employer so why are your consumers left out in the cold?
I was approved for LTD, on it about 3-4 months. I got approved for SSD. I’m 56 and have a Neuroimmune disease. They got their back pay back. I was only due like 20% of what I was getting due to SSD benefit. They sent my case to a really bad doctor to review. They disregarded my complete team of doctors and denied. I am in the process of hiring an Attorney to file appeal and then Lawsuit. I was a very competent Healthcare professional and if I could work part or fulltime I certainly would. This company is really a scam! My employers and myself had paid into this company 25+ years. No Ethics at all.
The worst company ever for short term disability. They keep messing up my paperwork. Staff is very incompetent including claims manager. Will never pick this company for any kind of financial needs. Claims manager never calls you back. Anyone who’s on maternity/medical leave shouldn’t have to go through all this trouble to get paid.
Prudential author review by Matthew Brodsky
Prudential has been offering insurance for over 140 years. It currently has offices in Asia and Europe as well as in both North and South America.
Offers group insurance: Users can purchase insurance through their employers.
Offers rehabilitation services: Users can get assistance with healing and getting back to work.
Offers partial benefits: People who can do some work but can't return to their full job duties may be able to get partial benefits while back on the job.
Can help employers with site modifications: Users can get assistance with getting modifications at work so that they can continue to perform jobs following the onset of a disability.
Paycheck deductions: Employees can have premiums deducted automatically from each paycheck prior to getting paid.

Matthew Brodsky is an established expert on insurance, having written hundreds of articles and other pieces of content on the subject, interviewed countless practitioners, and attended dozens of conferences and events. He served as an editor at industry magazine Risk & Insurance for six years.
Prudential Disability Insurance Company Information
- Company Name:
- Prudential
- Year Founded:
- 1875
- City:
- Newark
- State/Province:
- NJ
- Country:
- United States
- Website:
- www.prudential.com
You’re signed up
We’ll start sending you the news you need delivered straight to you. We value your privacy. Unsubscribe easily.