How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

3x Buyer's Choice Award Winner

Choice Home Warranty Reviews

4.2
80,198 reviewsRating Calculation
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.

Our editorial standards

  • Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
  • We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
  • All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.

Our review standards

  • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
  • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
  • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
+2 more
Author picture
Edited by: Liz Bingler
Author picture
Fact-checked by: Jon Bortin

About Choice Home Warranty

Choice Home Warranty is a home warranty company that offers basic and comprehensive coverage for home systems and appliances, with costs typically ranging from $49.17 to $57.50 per month. On our site, customers have had mixed experiences with Choice. Some have found its representatives helpful and informative, while others have faced challenges with claim denials, service delays and communication issues.

Visit www.choicehomewarranty.com
Pros
  • Optional coverage for roof leaks
  • No transfer fee
  • 24/7 customer service
  • No home inspection required
Cons
  • $500 roof repair cap
  • Some customer service complaints
  • Not available in Washington

Choice Home Warranty Reviews

Over 50k reviews since 2012

Filter by Rating

  • (49,460)
  • (8,291)
  • (4,950)
  • (3,985)
  • (13,453)

Popular Mentions

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
    Top reviews
    • Top reviews
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    2 featured reviews

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
    Page 537 Reviews 80175 - 80325

    Reviewed Dec. 16, 2009

    Choice Home Warranty is a scam. People, be careful when you sign with them. My sincere advice for all of you out there is not to do business with them. They are totally illegitimate business. They will find any/every reason to decline your claims. They come up with so many reasons and frustrate their customers so that the customers stop calling them. Choice Home Warranty screwed me big time. The guy who sold me this policy was so nice, promising everything until he gets my business. His name is Brad **. He said that they will fix any problem that we report with no questions asked. Here is what happened to me:

    On October 19, 2009, I signed up with these guys. As of last week, my heating furnace started making some noise when I turn it on, which I reported to Choice Home Warranty. I never had any problems before with any of my appliances. Then a technician came to my home and saw the heating furnace (in fact, he told me that I should pay him first before he even touches my furnace; that is what has been told to him by Choice home Warranty, which is fine). He immediately said that the inducer motor has gone bad. This is due to normal wear and tear in the bearings of the motor, then he left. After 2 days, I got a call from Choice Home Warranty saying that they will not process my claim unless I provide them the maintenance records (they never mentioned about this when you sign up for the warranty. This is the first scam).

    I faxed all my maintenance records for the furnace and a couple of days later, they contacted me saying that they will not pay for the claim. That means they will not fix my furnace. The reason stated is that they will not fix any noise coming from the furnace. That means basically they will not pay any for any of your complaints/claims. I spent a couple of hours on the phone with their customer service department, authorization department, etc., arguing that when some moving/rotating part in a motor goes bad, it does make noise. If it had not made any noise, I guess I wouldn't have come to know the problem itself. What kind of a company which denies the claim on this ground? Hence I filed a complaint with the BBB (Better Business Bureau) on how they are cheating people. Hence guys, please be careful when you sign up for something like this.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Dec. 9, 2009

    We filed a claim on 12-5-2009 because our heater went out. Long story short, they denied our claim because they said the unit was not properly maintained because we did not have any documentation to send them showing that the system had been serviced every season since we owned the house. The system is 25 years old! Obviously, it has been maintained or else it would not have lasted this long. I am an MBA and my husband is a PhD, we keep excellent records/receipts for everything in our home, but never once have we heard of seasonal maintenance for a heating system. We are tired of insurance/warranty companies taking our money and not performing the service when we need it.

    We have paid $500 in premiums/service fees during the 4 months we have had this warranty and they told us that since we do not have a long enough history with them, they need all of our maintenance records for the heating system (which is just their way of finding a reason to deny the claim). We sent them 2 years' worth of service receipts to show the repairs that had been made to the system and they said that was not enough, and that we only sent them documentation for when the system broke, not documentation for how we maintained the system. What is the point of buying a warranty if they are not going to fix items when they break?

    To add insult to injury, the weather is 20 degrees which constitutes emergency service, but after 4 days we still have no heat! We have only had this warranty 4 months and Choice Home Warranty has already breached the contract by not performing emergency service. We filed a complaint with the BBB requesting our heat be fixed or our $500 premium/service fees refunded and this warranty cancelled so we can find a reputable company that will actually perform the service we are paying for!

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Dec. 4, 2009

    I was outraged with the phone call I received this morning from your supervisor, Jim **. He was quite rude and arrogant on the phone. I put a claim in on my washing machine on Saturday, November 28th, 31 days after my contract was purchased. I was doing my laundry, as I do every week, and noticed water leaking on the laundry room floor. I pulled out my contract and was relieved that the 30-day waiting period was over. I didn't appreciate the intent from Mr. ** that my claim was fraudulent and that my washer could not have broken one day after the waiting period. He stated that there were numerous things wrong with the machine that were preexisting prior to me getting the contract. It may seem odd, but things do break down with no warning from normal wear and tear.

    I have had other home warranty policies in the past and have never been questioned on a claim. I cancelled my plan with another home warranty which I purchased in August to go with Choice per my brother's recommendation. He purchased a two-year warranty, as well as a two-year warranty for my father. The contract states that the covered items will be repaired or replaced 30 days after acceptance of application by CHW. It doesn't say 31 or 37 days of purchasing the plan. I bought this warranty in good faith. When Mr. ** refused to do anything regarding this matter, I instructed him to cancel my warranty and I would go back to my previous plan. He said he would not allow me to do that. When I asked why, he said, "Because I said so and I won't let you." He then offered to give me $180 to do whatever I wanted with. What I want is to have my washer repaired or replaced as stated in the contract.

    My husband and I have left several messages for the manager, Mr. **, and have not received a call back. If you cannot make good on this claim, then I want to cancel the warranty at both of my properties. The contract clearly states that a contract can be cancelled after 30 days for a pro rata refund. I expect a full refund. I will contact the BBB and anyone else I need to, to get this resolved.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Nov. 19, 2009

    Brad sold me the contract, and he was persistent and kept lowering the fees. One thing that I had failed to call and ask about was the contract. I called a week or so later, and they sent me the Contract Agreement that said very little and a Choice Home Warranty.

    My galvanized pipe broke this past week, and they would not repair it, because it was galvanized. I kept asking where in the warranty did it say that, and the young lady on the phone kept saying that I needed to look at the contract that was online, plumbing and paragraph 8. This was never given to me. I was so mad. I told them not to renew my contract when it comes due in May 2010. Their company sucks big time. Things that I have read about them are so true of their character. Also, when I called, I was given a plumbing company that was 70 miles or more away from my house. The lady on the phone insisted they were a few miles away. I called the plumber two times, and they finally called me and confirmed what I had been telling the Choice rep. I should have stayed with American Home Shield. In other words, you get what you pay for - sucky service!

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Nov. 4, 2009

    Do not deal with this company. They will find any reason necessary to decline a repair bill. If it's too high, they will just tell you it's a pre-existing condition. Deal with Choice Home Warranty at your own risk.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Nov. 4, 2009

    I called up this company on 08/19/09 to inquire about home warranty plans & price & spoke to a representative named Kevin. He initially told me $380 for the Total Plan & I told him I needed to discuss it with my family. Then he kept decreasing the price & finally he could make it $330 if I sign up & pay right away. Plus, he assured me I have 30 days to decide whether I want to keep it or cancel it. He was rushing me to enroll for a contract as if they will be providing the best service for it. The company would refund my full money if I cancel before 09/19/09.

    On 08/28/09, when I called up to cancel this contract since we were planning to move to a different school district because of better school choices, I spoke to Mr. Robert **. Unfortunately, I will have to say that he was very rude & highly unprofessional after I told him that I wanted to cancel this contract. Then he said, "There is a $50 penalty for cancelling it." I told him that previously I had been told by your person only (Kevin) that there would be no deduction if I cancel before the starting date of contract which is Sept.19, 2009. Then he said that there would be an investigation for it . But after several phone calls, the company has refunded only $280 to me whereas I cancelled 3 weeks before the contract was about to start. In these recession times, I don't expect that companies should start snatching money from the public like this & fool them.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Oct. 30, 2009

    We have been servicing appliances for 19 years. We warn every one of our customers. Do not do business with Choice Home Warranty. They will not pay your bill when it comes down to it. We told them we did not want their business anymore after they refused to pay us for services on their customers. We ended up billing the customers. Do not do business with this company.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Oct. 29, 2009

    After listening to the sales pitch from Troy ** and asking numerous questions about repair services, service turnaround time, preexisting conditions, etc., I was assured a level of efficiency and coverage that my husband & I would be happy with as we would have a 30-day grace before the effective date of the policies to make a decision. Not once did Troy mention that I could read their terms and conditions online nor did he tell me that upon cancellation each policy charges a $50 cancellation fee. I told Troy that I would call back after discussing Home Choice with my husband. He was persistent that if I sign-up for the coverage, there would be no problem if I/we changed our minds, to call back & cancel. When I called back to cancel, I was told that Home Choice charges $50 per policy (we have 2 rental properties) to cancel even though I had not received a policy. It took them less than an hour to charge my credit card. However, I never received a policy or terms and conditions stating the $50 charge to cancel. Customer Service and Management were rude, screaming and yelling throughout our conversations on 10/19 and 10/30.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Oct. 9, 2009

    I made the contract with Choice Home Warranty for Total Plan on my appliances and systems on 08/10/09. The term started 09/10/09. Before, I was a customer for 15 years of American Home Shield Warranty. The only reason I decided to switch to Choice was increasing service call fee from $35 to $60. Otherwise, I was very happy with AHS. I thought that all home warranty companies are the same reliable. But it happened that Choice just charges money for the service and full year payment, but doesn't bother to do the service. On 09/11/09, my refrigerator stopped working. I called Choice and they send the technician to find out what is the problem.

    The technician told me that it is the compressor. I told him that the compressor was replaced by AHS a year and 9 months ago. He told me that compressor went out of order because the person improperly turned the valve, the oil from compressor was spilled out and freon leaked, and the compressor needs to be replaced again. Then Choice refuses to fix the problem, considering it as "pre-existing condition". But it worked good for 1 year and 9 months. The warranty on any compressor and labor to install it is only 90 days.

    When I made the contract with Choice, everything worked fine. I was not asked if the compressor was replaced or something in my house was wrong. The compressor did not have any pre-existing condition and it is not my fault that the companies hire people who do not do the work properly. I am the victim of bad service. When I made the contract, I asked Kevin (Choice representative) to e-mail me the copy of the contract as well as to mail a paper copy. I also asked him to include the counter top microwave instead of a built-in microwave which I don't have. I never received anything till I called back after 3 weeks. He promised that he will do it.

    Finally, I received a paper copy of the contract, but the counter top microwave was not included again. Then I called Choice to make a complaint to the supervisor. It was Mr. **. He fixed the mistakes on the contract. I was suspicious about the reputation of their company after even doing the contract I had so much trouble with them. Mr. ** said that they are "highly reputable company". Unfortunately, my feelings were right. They charge money without any intention to do the service.

    I am devastated about this situation. I am on disability retirement. I bought the plan hoping to avoid problems, but the problems only multiplied. The money that I paid for the contract for the whole year in advance ($450.00), as well as the $45.00 that I paid partially to the technician to fix it - I would rather spend it toward the new refrigerator. But why? I have "service" of the company that should take care of it.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Sept. 12, 2009

    If you want a reliable home warranty, do not use Choice Home Warranty! They will find anyway and everyway to get out of granting your claim. My brief description is “no AC.” The customer service didn't care that it was over 100 degrees in our house. It was so hot in our house it melted the butter that was left out. It took them 3 days to finally tell my family that we were denied. I asked why it took 3 days when we had no air. They stated they were busy. They never had any intention to grant us our claim. Buyers beware: they look for reason and any every reason to not to grant your claim. Don’t waste your money!

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed July 15, 2009

    Mom and I signed up together for Choice Home Warranty service. It seemed like a good idea, being Mom's handyman (husband) had recently passed away.

    The sales representative assured us that it did not matter, the age of the home or the appliances, and after 30 days of sign up, everything would be covered, no questions asked! He made it clear that unlike the other companies, Choice will honor all repairs or replacements.

    Three months after signing up, Mom's central air conditioner went out. She lives in a mobile home and the temperature gauge was reading over 100 degrees. Mom is a 3-time cancer survivor and had just lost the love of her life, and she did not need to hear that Choice would not honor their agreement and cover her A/C unit.

    I wrote them a letter, hoping to get some remedy and resolve. They never did reply to my letter. Mom ended up buying a new A/C unit. Because the loophole they used is written in the contract: if the appliance has not had yearly professional maintenance check ups, then they do not have to repair or replace. Tell me who has all their appliances professionally checked every year? That is a ridiculous expectation. Well, we have learned the hard way to look for this loophole in any other home warranty service company we might consider.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed July 3, 2009

    I had an AC problem and it was determined that the compressor needed to be replaced. They said I had to provide exhaustive maintenance records. I provided receipts of all past AC maintenance done on the unit, many were from my own maintenance like changing filters, etc. After faxing to them, they said I need all the receipts. Who in the world is going to get receipts of every filter replaced? After I provided them as many receipts as possible, they said the records were not what they expected so they denied the claim. I had to fix the AC problem myself! What's the point of a home warranty service! Watch out for these guys and their super, super tiny fine print which they mail you is not even the complete picture.

    When I called them, they said they had the right to change the terms anytime and I had to go to their website instead which has different clauses which allows them a way to bail out of a claim. They had to direct me to their website that had additional fine print, which indicated they can ask for maintenance records of all kinds and that gives them reason to deny claims! Plus, if you decide to cancel, there is further fine print that says they could deny the cancellation and if it's not to their benefit, they will charge you for everything they ever did for you during your time with them.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed June 16, 2009

    Choice Home Warranty used to be National Home Protection. Prior to that, they were something else. And before that, they were also something else and so on for the last 14 or 15 years. They go around scamming people and they change their names after enough complaints keeps them from doing business and they decide to just close their doors and keep the warranty money. I had also a problem with a heating unit where I had religiously kept my twice a year maintenance required by American Home Shield.

    I provided them with proof of coverage with American Home Shield and the invoices for my maintenance. They still denied my claim, stating that it was a pre-existing condition. He yelled and screamed at me and then laughed at my face, telling me he was simply not going to fix my unit. The tech they sent to my house was so shocked by their behavior that he cancelled his contract with them. The tech fixed my unit on his own and charged me a very low price because he felt so bad. I tried going to Dateline, but my complaint alone will not do it. Please, all of us that have been scammed by this company, go to the Dateline’s website and complain about them. If enough people do it, maybe they'll take us seriously and get someone to take them out of business for good. The emotional distress this has caused was way more damaging than the money they took.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed April 2, 2009

    Why is a Choice Home Warranty a bad mistake? Because the only way you can even hope they will honor what they profess to cover is to spend several hundred dollars each year on maintenance in addition to their contract price of $450-$500. Like so many others, I recently learned the hard way. They glibly refer you to section 9.1.2 in their contract, and this is their catch all loophole in which they are able to legally deny claims. Legal, yes. Ethical? Fair? Reasonable? Not in the least.

    Briefly, you are required to have professional service people come in yearly to perform maintenance for each appliance or system in your home, and you have to keep the records for 5 years. Even the IRS only asks for 3 years. The homeowner is not allowed to perform this maintenance. So assuming a home has a heating system, AC, a hot water heater, appliances, etc., you are being forced to spend money on each of these yearly or they will refuse to honor the warranty. In order to cover these items, this requires you to spend $500, $600, $700 per year. Add that to their contract price and you are now talking about an insurance policy that really costs between $950 and $1150 each year. In two years time, if you just put this money in a savings account, you would have enough to pay for almost any system that broke.

    So, bottom line, how does a Choice Home Warranty make economic sense? It doesn't.

    Oh, one other item. My problem was a hot water heater. I had been with American Home Shield for three years, as was my neighbor. He had a similar problem last year and they replaced his water heater for the $55 service fee. Foolishly, I had decided to switch to Choice and they refused to honor the contract due to section 9.1.2 even though I could prove that I'd had continuous coverage. Incredibly, they even have an out there. If you don't show them proof of an existing contract within 15 days of signing up with Choice, they act as if an existing contract never existed! Duh! So, I had to spend $1900 today and I can't get out of the Choice contract, but I will never get another one of these contracts again.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Jan. 21, 2009

    I have a consumer purchased home warranty with Choice Home Warranty. My dishwasher recently broke and was deemed unrepairable. I was given two options for replacement: I could wait 8-12 weeks for a new dishwasher or could buy out for $113.00, which was the wholesale purchase price of the replacement dishwasher that was on backorder.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Dec. 16, 2008

    I started the contract with Choice Home Warranty (Choicehomewarranty.com ) on 10/27/2008 covering HVAC and making one-time payment of $344 for the contract lasting one year. On 12/02/2008 2 units (furnaces) stopped working. I contacted Choice with repair request. The technician was sent on 12/03/2008 to do the diagnosis. Control boards needed to be replaced. Choice refused a repair without additional documentation. The following documents were submitted: home inspection report done upon purchasing the property, diagnosis/checkup of the HVAC systems done on 07/27/2007, repair and checkup of the HVAC systems done on 06/26/2008.

    After many phone calls and 14 days with no heat, the customer representative from Choice, Ron **, stated that the repair could not be cover because: it is odd that two of the systems fail in the same time? There is no date on the document from 6/26/2008 (?) even though it is printed. There is no signatures on the receipt from 06/26/2008 (?) even though it states on the receipt that it is a electronic invoice and the authenticity can be proven by contacting the company that did the repair/checkup service on 6/26/2008. Ron ** stated that no company will be contacted? There are many inconsistencies in provided documentation (?) with no additional comments provided.

    I need to add that dealing with this guy (company) was the worst customer service experience. Imagine rep. screaming, inventing stories that do not add up. The management needs to review your files (?) and than 5 sec. later (?) "Oh, it just popped up on my screen that your claim was denied"? I asked for the manager many times but never - no one was available. He was accusing me of taking long time sending the documentation where in fact they (or he) were not replying to my faxes, emails and phone calls. The faxes were being lost and I had to resend the documentation. I felt like it was really immature, irresponsible, unprofessional, ripoff one person shop.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Loading more reviews...

    Choice Home Warranty Company Information

    Social media:
    Company Name:
    Choice Home Warranty
    Company Type:
    Private
    Address:
    90 Washington Valley Road
    City:
    Bedminster
    State/Province:
    NJ
    Postal Code:
    07102
    Country:
    United States
    Website:
    www.choicehomewarranty.com

    Media

    VIDEOS & IMAGES 
    Do you have questions about Choice Home Warranty?