How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

ProtectMyID Reviews

4,948,604reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.

About ProtectMyID

This profile has not been claimed by the company. See reviews below to learn more or submit your own review.

Visit www.experian.com/protection/protect-my-id

Shop with confidence

Compare with top companies

ProtectMyID Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (10)
  • (8)
  • (2)
  • (5)
  • (22)

Popular Mentions

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about ProtectMyID?
    • 4,948,604 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Recent
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about ProtectMyID?
    • 4,948,604 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Page 1 Reviews 0 - 40
    Profile pic of the author.
    Refunds & PayoutsRates

    Reviewed June 10, 2026

    Trash! Absolutely inaccurate credit rating on information. They don't know what the hell they're doing! It's free I guess you get what you pay for. Total garbage!!! I already have two other ones which I pay for monthly and AAAs protect my ID at the bottom of the list. Total inaccuracies unclarified statements and reasons. Probably ran by Israel but a bunch of junk.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageMaintenance

    Reviewed April 30, 2026

    Paid to have complete coverage for VPN access. Mine does not work. Spoke to customer service several times and it seems no one has the knowledge of how to fix the problem. Terrible service!

    Thanks for your vote!

    Not sure how to choose?

    Get buying tips about Identity Theft Protection delivered to your inbox.

      By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

      Thanks for subscribing.

      You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

      Customer ServicePriceBilling

      Reviewed Feb. 20, 2026

      Additional junk email and all you really get is a notification really of an activity, that's completely it... a notification, Anything beyond is a paid service, similar and better services are available via Experian, Credit Karma, Chime, so many department store credit cards and costing zero dollars. I get enough notifications that are more detailed than PMID provides, and a lot of them are also built into the credit union banks, even to include CREDIT AND FICO SCORES FOR FREE. So really unless you don't have any credit union or other free services included to notify you and even include credit/fico scores, this will be just additional email annoyance because it's just a notification like on a phone that you clear out junk notifications.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceMaintenance

      Reviewed Oct. 9, 2025

      Total junk, the password reset does not work for the address that ProtectMyID keeps sending e-mails to. It took 10+ tries to get it set up the first time and now I cannot login with the email address and password I used to set up the account. The password reset never sends an e-mail. This is a total waste of time.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceSales & MarketingBilling

      Reviewed Oct. 4, 2025

      AAA had a blocking ad and one could do nothing. All called were disconnected and l lost two hours of time reporting a serious security breach involving foreign spy water sent by a Local dentist. I pay 10.95 a month via AAA only to contact all banks credit cards etc. Tran ion and requires answered the phone. Never deal with Experian. Also l had to log in the stupid account when bank told me NOT to ad they hung up.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed March 27, 2025

      I was on the phone for 12 hours with them. Narcissistic, word salads and Gaslight the whole time. 5 different representatives. Just a nightmare. They are working at home. Refused to pay attention to their client. Just a nightmare.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer Service

      Reviewed Sept. 17, 2024

      We have AAA Protect My ID through AAA Northeast. We have their premium plan. I got an e-mail of the monthly summary. I was able to get into my wife's account, which said everything was great even though we had 3 previous warnings of dark web activity. When I tried logging into my portion of the account it would not let me in, although I had used the same user id and password a month before. I tried doing a "forgot password" to reset it but they said the e-mail address they sent the initial message to was not on file. I tried calling them but after 1 hour+ on hold I gave up.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Sales & Marketing

      Reviewed March 24, 2024

      The basic membership offers little value. It offers alerts, but when going to their site to learn more - all of the features to see the details are only available with an upgraded membership. Even when I simply want to view my current credit report, I receive a message that says it is "not currently available". The basic membership almost feels like a sales platform for the enhanced membership.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Communication

      Reviewed Aug. 13, 2021

      It was easy to set up and begin using. They keep me informed each month on any activity on my credit report and anything that looks suspicious. I can log on whenever I want to check for myself. It gives me peace of mind.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Oct. 6, 2020

      If you need your identity protected this is the company. I used them for 18 months and every time I had an issue I was notified. Identity theft protection is very important and I suggest to anyone to choose this company.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Sept. 26, 2020

      Your identity is so critical as if it is compromised, bad things happen. What is important is not only the monitoring of your various accounts but the way you are notified of possible issues that do.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Sept. 25, 2020

      I received this basic service with my AAA membership. It does what it is supposed to do in monitoring my credit hits and notifies me if hits occurred.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceCoverageRefunds & Payouts

      Reviewed Sept. 24, 2020

      I get it free through my bank, so that is very satisfying. I get an email once a month telling me if there has been any activity spotted. It only covers basic, and I would have to pay for more cover.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Punctuality & Speed

      Reviewed Sept. 23, 2020

      I enjoy having ProtectMyID, but my only complaint is that notifications of changes to my credit report are not sent as quickly as other credit monitoring services that I use. Providing quicker notifications is an area where I feel ProtectMyID can improve on. Otherwise, they're great.

      Thanks for your vote!
      CoverageStaff

      Reviewed Sept. 21, 2020

      I do not have any issues so far with this company. I have used them for several years. I feel like the monitoring services are very thorough. They also have good coverage. I do not have much comparison because I have not used other companies.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Punctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

      Reviewed May 9, 2020

      They're ok but seems to be a day or two late to notice you on any action on your credit report and the longer I have had it the less notice I get from them. I got this free with a purchase so not sure if that is why but I would not pay for this.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceOnline & AppStaffRates

      Reviewed May 7, 2020

      As an overall company I would rate these guys 4 out of 5. It would be 5 out of 5 if the customer service would become more informed of what they are supposed to be there to help with, then they would represent the company more accurately. Other than that everything looks great. Website is a pleasure to navigate and looks clean and professional. With so many result options to choose from that I almost could not decide what one to pick.

      Thanks for your vote!
      PriceRates

      Reviewed May 6, 2020

      ProtectMyID is offered by the Auto Club as an additional benefit. Considering the price of equivalent services runs from $10-$20 a month on its own, the inclusion of this at no additional cost makes an Auto Club membership even more valuable. The service includes Dark Web, SSN, Credit Report and other monitoring and sends a monthly report at a minimum, plus alerts if there is detected activity of concern on any monitored area.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Billing

      Reviewed May 4, 2020

      I received a free subscription to ProtectMyId after my information was lost as the result of a data breach. I actually had to use ProtectMyId to dispute an entry on my credit report when the service notified me of an issue. The service worked well with Experian and Equifax (had to hire an attorney for Trans Union). ProtectMyId provides great services, notification and protection. If I did not have a credit monitoring service through my credit card company, I would still have ProtectMyId.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed April 29, 2020

      This isn't the best I'd plan but being on a fixed income it the one I can afford. It really doesn't matter to "protect" my identity but lets me know when I'm hacked & to change my password, etc. I Wish I could afford better plan...

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServicePriceOnline & AppRefunds & PayoutsRates

      Reviewed April 27, 2020

      I got this as a part of my AAA membership for free. However, I have been charged $12.95/month for three years now. After a lot of back and forth with the company and AAA nothing has resolved. They beat me down and I have now justified to myself that $12.95/month is not too high a price to pay for protection. I have kept my identity so far! The monthly emails are uninformative and force you to go onto their website. I'd much rather prefer some sort of quantitative summary of my account within the text of the email.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed April 26, 2020

      They were very responsive when a suspected ID theft occurred... They contacted the credit firms and helped create no new credit apps... They followed up several times... They also requested a full credit report be sent to me to review for any issues... I’m very satisfied!

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Dec. 28, 2019

      This is a member's benefit from AAA and it is basic protection with option to upgrade to premium. It was easy to Sign up for and seems thus far to do a good job.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Staff

      Reviewed July 29, 2019

      The employees answering the phone when I called to report identity theft earlier this month. He told me no, no, no!! "You don't want to put a freeze on your credit." What?? Of course I want to freeze it so no one takes out credit in my name. Now I have no idea what's happening. I've been locked out of Experian. They said I am not who I say I am. This is terrifying. I need help and nowhere to turn. Hackers are taking over and getting away with their scams!

      Thanks for your vote!
      PriceStaff

      Reviewed April 5, 2019

      S.C. TAX COMM. Had a breach. Offered a free year of Experian ProtectMyID to all breached. I had it for 4 family members. Decided to continue with annual billings for over 10 years. Then in October of 2018 they emailed me there would be a price increase of tenfold. I replied I needed to cancel all 4 memberships and gave them the 4 account numbers. All went well...THEN today I see on my credit card statement a annual charge for one of the accounts. I called to be informed I may pay for all four accounts but could only cancel mine. That the one account was still active.

      After some follow up questions, like how had I canceled the other 3 then, they agreed they had made a mistake. Would cancel that last account and would refund me a PRORATED refund. So I will have to pay for their mistake. In the scheme of day to day problems, it is my wasted time asking people twice to do what they are supposed to do. And instead of an apology and a refund. I would still have to pay for their mistake. So I will let you judge this. Experian swindled me out of my time, and 9 buck. Hope it was worth it to them...Barry

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed Oct. 19, 2018

      I had a yearly subscription for two years. The first year was free because Experian compromised my information. Everyone should remember that this service to protect one's ID came into being because the credit rating agencies continually failed to do so. The outrage over their leaks is why we can do a credit freeze for free. You can get a free Experian credit report with the membership. But you dont need a membership if you just want the credit report, everyone in America is entitled to a free report from each agency on an annual basis. So the only value left in the membership is the insurance. This is identity insurance, the rest of the services are just to lure you in.

      There is no free base membership. This is actually very odd because the main competition, Transunion and Equifax, offers a free base membership with their identity protection. The free memberships at other agencies can also send out notifications when there are changes to the credit report. So really, the membership is for INSURANCE.

      You cannot delete your credit card information in their account information portal. I called and canceled my membership as soon as I noticed a charge. I did not receive a billing reminder so when I got billed I was not happy. I did not like their call center. I actually had to call twice because they said the "system was down because it was updating." This might be true but it seemed odd to me. Also they do not give reference numbers nor call customers back; this is important because if you call and their system goes down, you have to start all over with a new rep.

      This product might be advisable if you want to monitor your credit before getting ready for a large loan or mortgage application. But before going with ProtectMyID, check the coverage of the main competitors; they offer the same services but the insurance coverage varies. If you don't see yourself applying for a loan within the next couple years, just freeze your credit (free) and you wont have to worry about monitoring your identity/credit report.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed Sept. 13, 2018

      The short story: Rude, incompetent, sketchy reps who take your info and you feel more insecure using the service than not. DO NOT USE. Felt like the reps were harvesting personal information. Long Story: Had service through University. Liked it. Renewed service. Logged in as normal. Try to log in a week later, system has no record of me. Call customer service. First representative is rude and chewing while talking. Hang up. Call second representative, she transfers me to another department, who says they have nothing to do with memberships. Call again, pay for membership. Rep asks me if I want password reset. Answer security questions and she sends link. Never get link. Call back, rep asks me more questions, which she says I did not answer correct and I will have to call back in 24 hours. Speak to supervisor and ask to cancel service. Get cancelation email. Ask for refund, told that I was benefiting from services and could not get refund.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceContract & TermsSales & Marketing

      Reviewed March 10, 2018

      Years ago, my information the state had got hacked and they signed me up with a free credit monitoring service... ProtectMyID. When it was up to renew I renewed it and gave them my credit card information. Later, during the great Equifax hack, I switched to another credit monitoring service. Got a notice from ProtectMyID that my account was going to auto-renew, went into the account and there is absolutely no way, aside from the obscure language I was able to find in the contract to cancel. Tried calling and was left on hold for hours, no answer - like WOW, what if I actually needed this damn service, lol!!

      The website looks like a complete hack job, if this company is really supposed to be associated with Experian I'd assume they'd be able to hire some decent programmers, right?? So, I've sent them the lengthy notice to please cancel my damn account, but really doubt that will do anything - so I called the bank and told them to refuse payment to them. Please!! Please!! Don't have anything to do with this company - it's stinks to high heaven of a scam. Not like we've had enough of that already right. : (

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Customer ServiceOnline & App

      Reviewed Jan. 29, 2018

      Called Experian/ProtectMyID this a.m. - on hold over 1.5 hrs and gave up on trying to reach anyone! Attempted to contact via email - 2 different addresses - first one came back stating not in service, still awaiting reply from 2nd attempt. They send alerts periodically stating all is well but is it really? I am trying to cancel their service. Unable to remove my credit card from their website so I contacted the credit card company to flag my account for cancellation of services. Would not recommend dealing with this company!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Customer ServiceOnline & App

      Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017

      Worst customer service and website. The website does not function properly. It will not allow more than one item to be saved under Debit Cards or Medical Cards. Email link for assistance does not function - blank blue screen asking to choose an email address - with no addresses visible. I've called three times with no help at all. Last time I was told that there was a "service ticket" assigned, but I've had no follow-up yet. It's been a week since I've called and the website still does not function. AAA who promotes this inferior product does not respond to emails about it either. I've attempted to use the website on two different computers, with three different browsers, and two different search engines. It still doesn't work properly. Save your time and money - Avoid this product.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed June 20, 2017

      I received a "free trial period" for this company, after a "break in at my university divulged the information of my SSN and address to hackers". I never ATTENDED that university, and I contacted the University (who's number was not on the paperwork) and they had no record of such a break-in occurring! Please please do not join this company, it is a fraud to GET your SSN and credit card numbers. FRAUD!

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed March 27, 2017

      I received free membership of ProtectMyID as part of an earlier identity theft issue affecting another service provider. As other reviewers have stated, during my membership period I have had my credit cards cloned and fraudulently used, but never have any of these breaches been picked up by ProtectMyID. Ironically, when I have received an alert about possible breaches of my identity, these have occurred while I have been working overseas - where risk of identity theft is usually higher - and from where it is physically impossible to access the ProtectMyID website to find out what the alert is! The site does not allow access from non-US based web servers it would seems. A ludicrous state of affairs and another reason why I would never recommend this company or its products.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Sales & MarketingStaff

      Reviewed March 7, 2017

      I don't like giving negative reviews. I only give them when company is very bad. ProtectMyID from Experian is a joke. I was given 2-year paid membership by my previous company that gave away W2 in phishing scam and about 10,000 employees' personal information were exposed. Since ProtectMyID started "monitoring" my credit cards, etc., I had 3 Visa credit card stolen due to online breach with different websites. I have phone text monitoring of my CCs' spendings. I was able to cancel my CC in time not to suffer any financial loss. I had my CCs replaced with different CC number. Not SINGLE time ProtectMyID caught any of that and notified me. They did not even see when I closed my stolen CCs and opened new ones. Monitoring from Experian is a joke.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed Jan. 30, 2017

      Given a membership due to a data breach to safeguard against identity theft. I did have something come up and tried to contact ProtectMyID regarding my credit report. YOU CANNOT CONTACT THEM or talk to a real live person at all. Their info says they are accessible 24/7, but I emailed and tried three different numbers -- All they provide is a recorded message but no customer service rep is available. Recordings tell how you can sign up for service or info about a report -- all they give you are three different recorded messages. No one is available to help with a question. NOT recommending this company. I'd give zero stars if I could.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed Jan. 24, 2017

      I am having an issue which I think is fraud and have been on the phone for the fraud department for over 30 minutes, nobody ever comes on the line. I have called 3 times, what horrible 'service'. Don't bother, go to Life Alert or a company that will be there when you need them. These people don't even come to the phone and they don't communicate across departments. What a waste of money.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed Dec. 18, 2016

      They failed to show an inquiry on my credit score. I know it was there because it was me to order a new credit card. I contacted customer service several times and every time it ends up with "This issue is sent to an appropriate department" without any followup. When I try to ask about the status, they deny to provide any update. The issue is more than a year now. Totally unprofessional.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Oct. 7, 2016

      ProtectMyID sounds like a good idea at first. Get alerts from one of the major credit reporting companies (Experian) when something unusual is reported to your credit report. But wait! First off, the "alerts" that you get tell you nothing other than the bare appearance of new data on your credit report. In my case, I got repeated alerts while I was shopping for a home loan, all for the same event.

      Next, when you choose to "Dispute" the alert (in my case, an incorrectly billed past-due notice from a department store), you are told to "Click this button" to dispute this entry. When you do, a screen tells you that you have no active credit reports and that you can't dispute an item just because they sent you an alert!!! Well, what the ** is your service good for if not for identifying and disputing incorrect items?

      Thirdly, and most importantly, I had a credit card that was used in Shanghai, China for 2 purchases during the month of August. I was notified that this was suspicious activity by Bank Of America. I was notified that this was suspicious activity by Credit Karma. I was notified that this was suspicious activity by everyone but... You guessed it! ProtectMyID. Avoid this spurious "service" like the plague and just use Credit Karma. It's free and way, way, way better.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer Service

      Reviewed Sept. 19, 2016

      I have had ProtectMyID through AAA for several years now. It's wonderful that I know that something is monitoring my credit and notifying me to make sure that everything is in check but recently I had a situation where I needed their help in resolving a problem. They have a fraud resolution department that they boast will help you and I felt safe knowing that if something came up, they could handle it. Between AAA and ProtectMyID, I pay a lot of money per year for this type of service. I called the fraud resolution department for help with recent activity and all they could do was listen. They ended up patching me over to one of the credit bureaus so that I could handle it with them personally. Was I mistaken to know that they could handle this for me like Discover card does when I have and need fraud resolution with disputes? Apparently so.

      What good is a fraud resolution department if they don't resolve fraud for their customers? They are basically sitting there listening to you and then handing you a phone number to call. It's only a form of therapy at first without the help. Everything else they do is great but don't count on their fraud department to help you with anything. They'll give you contacts but they won't resolve a thing on your behalf. That's deceptive because it gave me peace of mind knowing that I could call them like Discover and have them handle it.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServicePriceStaff

      Reviewed Aug. 26, 2016

      I would recommend their customer service to any and everyone. They treated me nicely, and they showed me what real customer service is supposed to be about. I spoke with them without any problems. The cost is beyond affordable. I can't complain at all. To get started, all you need is a dollar. This will get you started with a free-trial. After your free-trial is up, you can cancel or pay a low monthly fee to continue with their services. The way they monitor is incredible. You can and will feel safe with them. They sent me email and postbox notifications, keeping me updated on a daily basis. They have me what I call, Identity Confidence. They are most definitely reliable. Whenever I needed them, to ask a question, they were always there without hesitation. I knew that I could've always counted on them for full support.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServicePrice

      Reviewed Aug. 23, 2016

      They were very quick to respond to me when I had any questions and made the whole process smooth for me. This service was very adequate and was helpful to my needs and did exactly what was said would be done when I signed up for it. It is worth what you pay. I paid a small amount for the service and I think it was a great deal. I think I got a lot more bang for my buck than I expected to get. They updated me any time something seemed fishy on my account and I feel like this service kept anyone from stealing my identity. I would use it again if I felt like I needed it. Very reliable. Never worried if they were going to mess up and if I was going to end up with some type of trouble. It was so easy and very trustworthy to use.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Loading more reviews...

      ProtectMyID Company Information

      Company Name:
      ProtectMyID
      Year Founded:
      1995
      Address:
      ProtectMyID.com, Attn: Customer Care, PO Box 22
      City:
      Allen
      State/Province:
      TX
      Postal Code:
      75013
      Country:
      United States
      Website:
      www.experian.com