I tried to obtain a credit report from Equifax online yesterday, as a result of a credit denial by Capital One Bank. The letter received from that last-named institution gave us grounds to think that the Equifax Credit file might contain false or wrong information about my wife. The Equifax web page is not too user-friendly; most likely, they try to sell you their products. Although you are entitled to a free credit report as a result of a credit denial, they guide you to the place where you can get a free credit report as a result of Credit Federal Legislation. These two causes for free credit report request are different, but apparently, they try to make them the same.
Finally, I started the request until you get to a page that asks you to answer some questions that "only you can know the answers." These are questions obtained from the information they keep on file. Obviously, you would know the answers if the information related to the questions was information you knew. But what about the answers when the questions relate to information that has been falsely added to your file and you do not know anything about that? Well, you cannot answer the questions. Then you receive a message telling you that a report is not available to you at this time and instructs you to call customer care at a 1-866 telephone number.
I waited until the next day. The telephone system gives you two choices: 1 for English and 2 for Spanish. After pressing 2 for Spanish, we had the following reply: "Your call cannot be completed at this dial. Check the number and try again." Of course, you do not know the number. You pressed only a number 2. So I repeated the call. This time in English. My wife does not speak English, so I tried to speak on her behalf.
The first representative whose name was Sunil was rude, did not solve any problem, and indicated us to call 1800. The second representative I spoke with, Ann, took the information and told us to go back to the online system and that she had done her part at that terminal. We thanked her for her help, just only to find that after repeating the process, we were denied again the report and asked to call to that 1-800 number.
We tried again, called, and this time, spoke with Veronica, who told us they did not permit conversations through speakerphone and transferred us to Christy who is a Spanish speaker representative. Although she was nice, she told us there was nothing she could do, because we were unable to recognize details about a certain car loan that apparently they have on file and we have never had or requested. In consequence, we had to go to the 1-800 or make the request by mail. A lot of time was lost, and the frustration was growing.
The 1800. This is an automated system with a lot of recorded information that makes the process confusing. After some time of unrelated speech, it tells you that "If you have been denied credit, please visit our website to view a free copy of your credit file as allowed for credit legislation." What an irony. The website sends you to the telephone system, and the telephone system sends you to the website. As you can see in the address, this page is the one that gives access to a one free annual credit report by Federal Legislation and not the one that gives you a free credit report for denial of credit.
Anyway, it tells you later "Or if you want to continue with this automated system, to hear your state's fee, please press one. If you would like to add a fraud or active duty alert or request a copy of your Equifax credit file or credit score, please press 2. If you have a copy of the credit file used for employment purposes, please press 3. If you are unemployed or a welfare recipient, please press 4. If you are calling to request your free annual credit file disclosure under the fact act amendment to the fair credit reporting act, please press 5. If your are visually impaired and needs access to the credit file, please press 7 If you are calling on behalf a minor child, please press 8."
You have no choice. You have to click number 5, and immediately you gave up one free report like in a Harry Potter movie. But wait, your headaches have not finished. They will get some information from you and still will give you a confusing long message telling you to send a copy of the letter that informed you of the denial. They will mention the $10.80 they charge for the report fee in your state, and the $7:50 they charge for the FICO rate, I guess, in the hope that you get confused and send them those amounts.
Then they put even more pressure and start mentioning documents you must send them, starting with an illegal request of a copy of your Social Security Card and finishing with others, among them, a copy of your license, copy of W-2 forms, etc., etc. So, at the end, it was not an online request that got an instant answer, not even a telephone request that could have provided you with an immediate mail answer, but a theater act to make the process difficult and lengthy and that discourages its use by any customer. After all, they collected their fees already from the merchants that bought the first report.
You will still have to wait 15 days for them to process your request, 5 days in the mail, and, who knows if they wish to request you some other information that delay still more the process? It is frustrating, it is lengthy, it is humiliating, and it is abusive. It should be illegal; it should be penalized. It should lead to a shutdown of that Company, because they have received too many times warnings, fines, and penalties from the Government. When it all stops? I came to a web page that has 54 pages full of complaints.
Even Wikipedia gives this information "Retail Credit Company's extensive information holdings and its willingness to sell them to anyone, attracted criticism of the company in the 1960s and 1970s. These included that it collected ... facts, statistics, inaccuracies and rumors about virtually every phase of a person's life--his marital troubles, jobs, school history, childhood, sex life, and political activities. The company was also alleged to reward its employees for collecting negative information on consumers."
As a result, when the company moved to computerize its records, which would lead to much wider availability of the personal information it held, the US Congress held hearings in 1970. These led to the enactment of the Fair Credit Reporting Act in the same year which gave consumers rights regarding information stored about them in corporate databanks. It is alleged that the hearings prompted the Retail Credit Company to change its name to Equifax in 1975 to improve its image.
In 2000, Equifax along with Experian and Trans Union were fined US$2.5 million for blocking and delaying phone calls from consumers trying to get information about their credit. In 2003, the FTC took Equifax to court for the same reason and settled its lawsuit with the company for a fine of US$250,000.
It was still 2009, and the same happens the same. Would they invest too much money in lobbying or buying politicians? Customer care doesn't tell you, but it appears to be originated in Southeast Asia based on the accent of their representatives. Apparently, they can do very little for you.
I will keep this report and post it in every place I can in the internet. I will send this complaint to the Federal Credit Commission and to the Protection Consumer Commissions of New York and Georgia. We have never authorized them to collect information on us or to keep a file on us. That should be banned for being a very unfair and dangerous practice. We never agreed on them to keep information on us and much less to provide or sell information related to our lives.
Still, they do not care, and they make errors and are reluctant to correct those errors. They make our lives miserable and make money, big money, doing this. I think that we should be entitled to do the same to them. I told one of those representatives that it was shameful that this company could find employees whose work was to make the lives of other human beings difficult and that it was a shame that this kind of company could find employees willing to do a dirty job for a salary.
So I guess that the employees are a part of this shame that should be barred from everywhere. Their only concern is to sell you services, to make money. It does not matter which is the path that conduces to a profit or how many people get harmed in the way.
I will demand them to reply to our requests, to provide us with the credit report, and to make the necessary corrections. I will pursue any avenue if they try to make this process more difficult, and I will report them again and again and again. I hope that at some point, they will be stopped; and I want to contribute to that.