
Mick of Shakopee, MN on July 20, 2011
-End of April I brought in a bid from Menards to see if Home Depot would match the price. Justin from the pro desk compiled a list of materials, and blue print for the garage (34'x24') and advised me that Home Depot would be able to match the price. I sent his material list and blueprint in to the city of Shakopee, along with my building application and waited for approval from the city. After approval, I met back with Justin to finalize the price quote (choose color of siding, color of shingles, brands of nails for nail guns, etc.) It was now that he informed me that he made a mistake, and forgot to add in the cost of the 2 insulated garage doors. He told me the price was going to be $1000 more than our earlier verbal agreement (the same cost as Menards quote). I wasn't happy with this new price.
He then told me that it would be nice to have the entire material list that Menards was going to send with their quoted price, so I drove back to Menards to print off the entire list of materials. I was told when I arrived at Menards that they were unable to pull up the list due to the amount of time that had gone by since I printed out the price quote, and that I will have to start all over on their computer, so that is what I did. I was surprised to see that after printing out this new quote and entire material list that the price had increased by a couple of hundred dollars, when I asked the pro desk at Menards about this price difference they told me that a few of the materials where on sale during the time of the first price quote (including the garage doors). When I brought this new quote back to Justin he advised me that he was going to delegate a co-worker to go through the material list, and try and shave off some cost by seeing what they have in stock in the store instead of special ordering it.
I received a phone call a couple of days later to come back in Home Depot to review my options. The first option was Justin's original order with non-insulated garage doors and an insulation kit. I passed. The second, I was given was a material list that was the same price as the original, but with insulated garage doors. When I asked how they got the price down to the Menards price, I was told that they found a bunch of the material on hand at the store, and when I asked if this is the exact same as Justin's original material list. I was told that is was the same.
So I agreed to purchase this option. After getting home that morning, I realized that I never picked out the color of my siding, the color of my shingles, and I did not give them the brands of my nail guns. I just assumed Justin would have me come in and do all this prior on sending out the shingles and siding.
-The first load of materials showed up on a Thursday (mid-May), when I got home from work on Friday morning I started digging into the materials, to set up the walls of the garage. It was at this time that I noticed there was no lumber sent for my double bottom plate, and no lumber sent for my top plate. I drove in to Home Depot and Justin helped me load up that material, he also told me that he was going to give me 10% off the price of these boards, which I thought was a little weird (I just paid for the entire garage kit, shouldn't these boards been included in that price?). So I paid for the boards and left.
-The following day (Saturday), I noticed after opening the rest of the load of materials, that there were no framing nails sent with the order, so I drove back into Home Depot. Since it was Saturday, no-one was working that knew the history of my order, and when I spoke with a manager, she said there is nothing she can do about it. I paid for a box of framing nails, and went home.
-Sunday came, and once again, I noticed there was also no sheathing nails in the order, so I went back to Home Depot on Monday, and luckily Justin was working and gave me a box of sheathing nails. He told me it was Home Depot's fault and that I did not have to pay for them. He also said he doesn't know what happened with my order, but he will sit down and find out where the errors came from. I still have not heard any reasons for the errors yet.
-After my rafters showed up, my second material delivery showed up as well, and the problems continued. I was told that my windows that i wanted was on back order, which wasn't a big deal. I was short 4 sheets of CDX wall sheathing that I drove in to pick up. I noticed with this second order of materials sent was multiple boxes of single roofing nails (no coiled nails), which I took back. And I think there are also 4 or 5 boxes of various length sheathing and framing nails, which I set aside with the intentions of returning when the garage was completed. I tried to go through all my materials this time and see what else was missing or sent to me by mistake. I found there was no starter strips for my siding, no siding nails, the wrong size roof sheathing clips (which I had to stop work again and drive in to H.D. to switch out), no Tyvek, no rain and ice (which I just drove quick to Lowe's and bought myself), and there was no finish strips for the siding either.
I called Justin and informed him of the items I was short and he had a truck come out a couple of days later and delivered the material. When I was sheathing my roof, I was short 6 sheets of roof sheathing and more sheathing nails, so I called Justin, and he thankfully brought those out that day (after I had to speak with a supervisor). While installing my fascia boards, I was short 4 pieces of 10 2x6's so I drove in to Home Depot again to get them. Being it was a weekend, and remembering all the hassle I went through the other weekends. I just bought them with out trying to explain to someone the history that has been going on with this order.
Upon opening the shingles, I notice they were not even close to matching my house, so I called Justin again, and he arranged for a pick up of the shingles. 4 days had past and still no new shingles, so I called Home Depot again, wondering where the shingle might be and I was told that they will check into it. Later that day ABC materials called me and told my they would deliver the shingles tomorrow, which they did. When I opened the boxes with my siding in it, I then noticed that the color was not what my wife and I had in mind. I drove into Home Depot and asked if I could choose a different color. I was told that the siding I received only came in the color I got (brown) or white. Any other colors would be more money. So I guess we will be stuck with this color (I wish we would have been given the color option in the beginning of this whole process).
While installing the sofit, yep, you guessed it, I was short. I called Justin and told him I was short 7 sheets of sofit, and one piece of fascia. I asked to get that delivered, he said he could arrange that in a couple of days. Two days later I received a voice mail on my phone from Justin stating that he was going to deliver the sofit and fascia, and that he was wanting to pick up some more of the miscellaneous materials that were sent to me by accident, or stuff that was left over. He stated that I have close to a $1000 bill tallied up at Home Depot and he is hoping to shave some of what I owe with the extra materials I have. I was unable to call him back that day, and no one was home when he came to my house that day.
When I got home that evening I noticed that he entered into by garage and left the material he was delivering, and he also took with him some of the material I had in my garage. I have an idea of some of the items that he took with him, but I am not 100% sure of all that he took, and there was no note left either. I have not heard anything more from Justin or anyone else for that matter at the Shakopee Home Depot since this had happened. I did not want to take this experience to the corporate level quite yet, but I don't know what else to do. I still have to put the siding up on my garage before it is complete, and hopefully I won't have any problems with any materials during this time.
I hope no-one else will ever have to experience the countless phone calls, and trips back and forth to Home Depot like I did during this project. This experience is almost too embarrassing for me to tell anyone and the few friends and co-workers whom I have shared this story with, have shaken their heads with disbelief.