The following is an explanation of why I am disputing these charges and also a copy of the letter I have sent to my credit card company. I recently had a Life Alert system representative, Elizabeth **, call me on 4/20/2010 about having a Life Alert system installed in my home. The information she gave me on the phone encouraged me to buy this system and that I would never have to worry about not being alone or not being able to get help when I need it. She said I would be able to communicate with the dispatcher and get the exact help I need from the sources I give them to keep on file for me. On April 28, 2010, the Life Alert system was installed and the next day I signed a three-year contract with them.
I am writing this letter of complaint concerning the product Life Alert sent me. I believe that the contract concerning their system wasn't clearly explained and that information about the system was withheld from me. Firstly, the sales representative didn't tell me that I had to notify them 6 months in advance if I wanted to cancel the service, which is in the contract. If I didn't do that, I was automatically signed up for another year. I was never informed of the true terms of the contract. When the man came to install my Life Alert system, I told him that I am hearing impaired and wear two hearing aids. I probably told the sales representative also. I take the hearing aids out at night. I asked him if I was going to be able to hear the voice from the system, especially since it wasn't installed in my bedroom and he assured me that it would be no problem.
He said Life Alert would make sure that the volume was loud enough for me to hear and they would take care of everything, and not to worry. Well, I did worry about it and finally decided to give it a test run even though it had just been tested by the installer. First, I took out my hearing aids and then pressed the button. Shortly after, someone answered me. I was sitting right next to the unit and the volume was turned up as far as it would go. I was able to hear her from two feet away. I then expressed my concerns to her that I would not be able to hear it from a different room so she suggested that I go to a different room and she would talk to me. I went into the living room and she tried talking with me, but all I could hear was mumbling. I had no idea what she was saying. So I went back to sitting next to the unit and told her that. She said it was no problem since they always call the person on the phone to see if they are OK. I told her I can't hear the phone without my hearing aids either and I only have one phone, which of course is next to the Life Alert unit. She said that in cases like that, they would automatically send an ambulance and the police. I told her I did not want that because I would have to pay for the ambulance if it came, and I might not need medical aid. Also, the police were not going to be very happy about racing to my home when I really just needed my son to come over to help me. She said that was their only option and I would have to pay for the ambulance each time I pressed the 'help' button.
I followed up that conversation with a call to their Service Department on May 11. I again explained the situation and told him what the sales person said to me regarding their being able to communicate over the system with me if I am having a problem to determine what kind of help I need or want--just help from a my son or paramedics, police or fire department. He basically said the same thing as the dispatcher but also said that I would probably never be able to hear the dispatcher unless I was in the same room as the unit, hearing impaired or not. He then apologized 'if I was not told the truth by the sales representative' (his exact words).
Their pamphlet says: "2-way audio communication, for Medical Protection and Faster response due to the fact that the emergencies are verified." There is no 2-way communication if I cannot hear them over the unit nor is there any way they can verify an emergency if we cannot communicate over the unit or phone. I read in their add online: "Life Alert is a Personal Emergency Response and Home Medical Alert System company that saves lives from catastrophic outcomes, using a unique technology to provide superior home audio monitoring protection." I understood this to mean that we would be able to hear and communicate with each other over the installed unit even though I am hearing impaired, as are many older people for which this system is made. This is how the sales representative explained it to me as well. Their pamphlet states: "Our dispatcher will talk to you whether you can reach a phone or not and will send the help you need fast, 24/7." If I can't hear the dispatcher, how will they talk to me? How will they know which kind of help I need? The help I need might just be for them to call my son and have him come over to help me up if I've fallen or something, just as simple as that, but if I can't hear them to communicate this, then the service isn't doing for me what they said it would do. I could carry a cell phone on me constantly and be better off.
I believed that when the Life Alert system was installed that it would be loud enough for me to hear it without my hearing aids. After all, Life Alert claims to be loud enough to be heard all over the house if an intruder is breaking in, to warn the intruder that the police are on the way and they better leave. This is what it says in their pamphlet: "In the rare event that someone is breaking in, our dispatcher scares the intruder away with a loud voice over the system." I heard the dispatcher speak with a loud voice while I was two feet from the phone but I never would have heard what was being said if I was in my bedroom or living room, even with my hearing aids on. That does not make me feel safe in the event of a break-in, which is one of the big reasons I ordered Life Alert. As it is, I am not at all happy with this situation. I want to be able to communicate with Life Alert when I press the button so I can tell them what is wrong and they can contact exactly who I need, like the sales representative told me, whether it be my son or police, fire fighters or ambulance. This is what the sales representative promised me when I spoke with her on the phone and also what Gene **, the installer, said. I cannot afford to pay the cost of an ambulance coming to my home whenever I push the help button, especially if I am not in need of medical help, nor do I want the police or fire department coming over unnecessarily if I'm having a problem that my family can take care of.
Their add also says: "Life Alert's protection helps people to live at home with independence and comfort, living their lives the way they want to, with a feeling of safety and peace of mind." That isn't how I'm feeling right now. Not only do I not feel safe, but they have disrupted my peace of mind by charging me for a system that in all likelihood will cost me more money in ambulance fees if I use it. I believe that Life Alert misrepresented what their product can do. They made it sound so perfect over the phone but in actuality, it is not useful for my situation at all. They probably knew this during the sales pitch and when the installer was putting it in and he kept deflecting all my questions about hearing the dispatcher. And the dispatcher did not help me have peace of mind, either, by telling me I would have to have the police and rescue squad come each time I press the help button.
I am calling my credit card company and stopping any further payments from being deducted from my credit card by Life Alert. I am also disputing the charges for the unit, processing and shipping, programming fee and installation: $1.98 on 4/29/2010, $95.00 on 4/29/2010 and $29.95 on 5/3/2010, for a total of $126.93 that was charged to my credit card. Life Alert is welcome to have Gene ** come back and get the unit. I will not pay the return shipping. I do expect a full refund. I have canceled my credit card since I became aware that Life Alert made the charges after I became aware while doing some online research that Life Alert is continuing to deduct payments even after being notified by dissatisfied customers that they are not getting what they paid for or after the person who was using it had died. I am requiring that a full refund be given to me in the amount of $126.93. I am filing a complaint with Consumer Protection and also the Attorney General's Better Business Bureau if Life Alert does not respond in a timely manner to the two messages I left on May 11, 2010.
May 18, 2010. Since Life Alert did not return my phone calls, I called them again on May 13th. I called Life Alert again after not receiving a return phone call from the two messages I left them on May 11. I was given the same story as I wrote before about them sending the rescue squad if I push the help button on their system. After unsuccessfully explaining that I wanted to return the system because it would not do what the sales person or their printed pamphlet and online ads claim it will do to help me, she turned me over to a man named Ami in their service department. He was extremely rude, not letting me speak and interrupting me constantly, even yelling at me. He finally suggested that I allow them to send me a new unit that would serve me better than the first one. I agreed to try a new unit. I received it on May 14th and on Monday, May 17th , Gene ** (from A-A Handyman). It had no volume button on it.
Gene pressed the help button on the unit and it began to beep, showing that the signal went through. It continued to beep for approximately two minutes and he called Life Alert to tell them that he was trying to get a dispatcher on the unit, but no one was responding to the help alert. He tried two more times to get a response from the dispatcher but no one responded. It just continued to beep. He called the company again and they finally responded over the unit. I did the same tests that I did on the first unit. I took out my hearing aids and went to the living room and then to my bedroom and I could not understand the voice coming from the unit in either room. When I returned to the room where the unit was located, I was able to hear the dispatcher with my hearing aids on, but sometimes I was unable to understand what she was saying, even at that close distance from the unit. When I asked Gene what she said, he said he didn't understand her either. That happened two or three times when the dispatcher was speaking to us.
(I mentioned to Gene before he left my apartment that I was going to tell Life Alert that he couldn't understand the dispatcher, either, when she spoke over the unit and he said not to do that or he would be in trouble.) I told the dispatcher I was not going to keep the unit because it was not functioning any better than the other. She then began to suggest that they could call the apartment complex office manager instead of first sending an ambulance, but I explained to her that the manager would not appreciate that and besides, they are only there from 8 am to 5 pm. She suggested calling a neighbor, but I don't know my neighbors in the building well enough and I would not give out my key to someone I don't know or trust. She suggested a lock box for my apartment key for the police to get in, but the apartment manager will not allow things like that to be installed on the outside of the building. Besides that, I don't feel comfortable doing that because someone might break it open and use my key to get into the building and my apartment. I live in a security locked building for a reason.
I finally told her the system they promised me was not working out the way it was described to me by the sales person or their written and online advertising, as well as their contract. I also had even more misgivings after Gene couldn't get a response from them after 3 attempts at using the help button. Also, each time the help button is pressed, the reset button must be pressed after talking with the dispatcher. What happens if I press the button for help and no one responds to me? I may not be in a position to get to the unit to push the reset button in order to try summoning help again. Of course, they don't tell you that in the sales pitch or advertising. Also, the new user's manual says that they can take up to two minutes to answer the call for help. That was not told to me before I signed the contract. I was led to believe that I would get an instant response from the dispatcher.
A lot of bad things can happen in the two-minute span if someone is breaking into my apartment or if I faint, fall and break an ankle (again), am bleeding severely or having a heart attack. Two minutes can mean life or death. The manual for the unit says to follow the instructions of the dispatcher. Again, if I can't hear the dispatcher, I am basically helpless, and the dispatcher isn't going to know what I want her/him to do for me. Given all this, I asked Gene to remove the unit and take both of them with him. He checked on the phone with someone at Life Alert and they told him it was OK to take the units. He told me they said that I should call the company the next day and discuss the contract with them. He said that they would probably try to talk me into keeping the unit. I decided that if that is their intent, I have already been through that several times with them, and their options are not acceptable, as well as the fact that the company does not do what it claims to do and violates its own advertising and contract. I don't want to be yelled at again or have their high pressure sales tactics upsetting me. That has happened four times now and I have had enough. I am being treated for major depression and am on many medications and don't need them aggravating my illness by arguing with me or making threats. I just want a refund for the amount they charged me: $126.93. Not only am I out $126.93 but I am having problems with my illness due to the stress Life Alert and their employees have caused me. I have been so depressed that I have not been able to get out of bed in the morning.