FOLLOW US

Best Renters Insurance in Chicago, IL

Profile picture of Sandi Pope
by Sandi Pope ConsumerAffairs Research Team

Chicago’s high property crime rates make renters insurance a must for tenants. Fires spread quickly between apartments and can damage your belongings as well. A good insurance provider protects you financially and helps you find the right amount of coverage. We’ve created a list of best renters insurance companies in Chicago.

Top 10 Chicago Renters Insurance Companies

Sort
GEICO Renters Insurance
Read 63 Reviews

GEICO is known for its low-cost insurance options as well as its line of commercials featuring a talking gecko. It offers a variety of comprehensive renters, homeowners and auto insurance policies throughout the United States.

Farmers Renters Insurance
Read 39 Reviews

Farmers Insurance is proud of the fact that it first opened its doors just prior to the Great Depression and is still going strong today. It offers a variety of insurance policies, including comprehensive renters' insurance.

Lemonade Renters Insurance

Offers basic renters insurance at super-low rates. No-frills insurance means fewer features like live customer support. Zero Everything option for zero deductible. Users can file claims through a mobile app.

Visit Website
Abe GT & Associates, Inc.
Read Expert Review

Provides most renters insurance quotes from Nationwide Insurance, but delivers some from Travelers. Sells renters insurance policies with protection from theft, fire and weather damage.

Acceptance Insurance Chicago
Read Expert Review

Offers standard and supplemental renters insurance policies from a variety of national carriers. Allows customers to supplement renters insurance with identity restoration coverage.

Allstate Renters Insurance Chicago
Read Expert Review

Offers an array of discounts for multi-policy customers, claim-free applicants, clients older than 55 and residents with security systems. Allows customers to add renters insurance to an auto policy for $4.

Insurance Navy
Read Expert Review

Offers free renters insurance quotes from multiple national carriers. Allows customers to make payments through the company’s online portal. Employs agents that speak English, Spanish, Arabic and Polish.

State Farm Renters Insurance Chicago
Read Expert Review

Sells renters insurance policies. Helps customers make payments and file claims through its app. Gives discounts to customers who bundle renters with auto insurance.

United Auto Insurance Chicago
Read Expert Review

Sells coverage for your belongings. Has an English/Spanish website. Delivers standard insurance policies that cover personal injuries, liabilities and living expenses if displaced.

Urban Insurance Agency
Read Expert Review

Provides coverage for loss of use, personal property and liability with standard renters insurance policy. Gives $15 for referrals. Allows customers to auto-pay for renters insurance.

chicago skyline

Chicago is safer than only 8% of cities in the U.S. The city’s residents have a 1 in 30 chance of being the victim of a property crime, which is almost twice the state average. If your home or car is broken into, renters insurance provides the cash to replace stolen or damaged items.

The city's brutally cold and windy winters also create a risk of frozen or burst pipes. If you’re living in an apartment, water from broken pipes can damage your possessions. For a nominal monthly fee, renters insurance reimburses your loss of property up to the policy's coverage limit.

Average cost of renters insurance in Chicago

The cost of renters insurance varies, but Chicago residents can expect to pay an average of $268 per year for $30,000 in personal property coverage, with the price ranging from $200 to $340 or more each year. These rates are 26% higher than the state average and make Chicago the least affordable city in Illinois for renters insurance, primarily because of its higher crime rates.

Factors like deductible amounts, coverage limits, location, type of residence and your credit score influence the final cost of your renters insurance policy. In a more dangerous neighborhood like South Deering, a $40,000 plan with a $1,000 deductible costs an average of $461. Renters insurance in North Ozanam Avenue/North Avondale Avenue costs an average of $364 for the same limits.

Chicago residents who own high-value belongings or want more coverage for items should expect to pay more per month.

How to choose a renters insurance company in Chicago

It’s crucial to consider a company’s overall responsiveness and customer satisfaction rating when choosing a renters insurance company in Chicago. If you’re dealing with an emergency, the last thing you want is to have problems filing a claim. Other details to look at include:

  • The company’s website interface
  • Whether the company has a mobile app availability
  • Supplemental policies and extended coverage options, including off-premises coverage and add-on coverage
  • Discounts

For accurate quotes across agencies, keep coverage limits, deductibles and liability amounts the same. Many companies offer calculators to help you decide how much coverage you need to sufficiently protect you.

Once you've narrowed down your list of insurance providers, read online reviews to get a better sense of each business. Ask an agent about what the policy covers and how to file a claim — understanding how the companies handle claims and payouts helps you find the one with the best customer service.

Is renters insurance required in Chicago?

Neither Chicago nor the state of Illinois requires renters insurance, but it’s legal for your landlord to request it as a condition of a lease. Even if you're not obligated to have a policy, renters insurance is valuable in Chicago because of soaring property crime rates and the potential of weather-related disasters.

Your renters rights in Chicago

Chicago residents who want to know more about their renters rights and resources can find information on the following websites:

Not sure how to choose?

Get expert buying tips about Renters Insurance in Chicago delivered to your inbox.

Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter!Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
We value your privacy. Unsubscribe easily.

Chicago renters insurance company information

United Auto Insurance Chicago

United Auto Insurance customizes your renters insurance policy to suit your needs and budget. The company’s robust website lets you get a quote and print your new insurance in English and Spanish. United Auto Insurance’s facility also has an on-site payment center with drive-thru service.

  • Address: 3201 N. Harlem Ave., Chicago, IL 60634
  • Phone: (773) 202-5000
  • Hours: M - F: 8am - 9pm; Sat: 8am - 5pm
  • Website: unitedautoinsurance.com
Allstate Renters Insurance Chicago

Joe Schneider is a local Allstate agent who sells renters insurance policies backed by Allstate’s commitment to customer satisfaction. Schneider’s agency donates $10 to those in need for every referral. Representatives who speak English, Romanian, Russian, Spanish and Lithuanian are available. Customers can take advantage of multi-policy, senior and claim-free discounts.

  • Address: 521 W. North Ave., Chicago, IL 60610
  • Phone: (312) 787-0221
  • Hours: M - W: 9am - 6:30pm; Th: 9am - 6pm; Fri: 9am - 5pm; Sat: 9am - 12:30pm
  • Website: agents.allstate.com/joe-schneider-chicago-il.html
Urban Insurance Agency

Urban Insurance Agency has grown into one of the largest insurance agencies in the city. The company offers comprehensive renters insurance policies to protect you against fires, burst pipes, fraud and more. It also gives $15 to existing customers who refer a friend to Urban Insurance Agency. Unlike some insurance brokers or lead-generation sites, the company never sells your information.

  • Address: 800 W. Huron St., Ste. 301, Chicago, IL 60642
  • Phone: (312) 664-8088
  • Hours: M - Sat: 9am - 6pm
  • Website: urbaninsuranceagency.com/homeowners-insurance
Acceptance Insurance Chicago

Acceptance Insurance strives to offer affordable insurance. The company’s local agents help customers decide which policy is best for their needs and offers add-ons such as identity restoration coverage. Acceptance Insurance’s agents are quick to handle claims, and you can start the filing process from its website.

  • Address: 3048 S. Halsted St., Chicago, IL 60608
  • Phone: (312) 842-1000
  • Hours: M - F: 9am - 6pm; Sat: 10am - 5pm
  • Website: acceptanceinsurance.com/il/chicago/3048-s-halsted
Abe GT & Associates, Inc.

Abe GT & Associates is dedicated to helping Chicago residents find the best renters insurance policy to secure their belongings. The company works almost exclusively with Nationwide Insurance, but it does offer some products from Travelers and Atlantic Specialty Lines. Its representatives work one-on-one with customers until they get their renters policy just right. The goal of Abe GT & Associates is to create a lasting relationship with its clients.

  • Address: 1024 W. Fry St., Ste. 102, Chicago, IL 60642
  • Phone: (312) 738-1384
  • Hours: M - F: 9am - 6pm
  • Website: abegtinsurance.com
Insurance Navy

Insurance Navy has Illinois-based agents who speak English, Spanish, Arabic and Polish. The company offers free renters insurance quotes from multiple national insurance carriers. Visit its website, stop by its local office or download its app to request a quote or file a claim.

  • Address: 2418 N. Cicero Ave., Chicago, IL 60639; multiple locations
  • Phone: (773) 478-3700
  • Hours: Call for hours
  • Website: insurancenavy.com/insurance-services-illinois/renters-insurance
State Farm Renters Insurance Chicago

You can save money with State Farm by combining auto and renters insurance, having home security alert devices or opting for higher deductibles. As a customer, you have access to community offers for electronics, dining, fitness and more. English-, French- and Chinese-speaking representatives are available at the company’s Washington Street office.

  • Address: 25 E. Washington St., Ste. 1100, Chicago, IL 60602
  • Phone: (312) 236-5222
  • Hours: M - F: 8am - 4:30pm
  • Website: janicenazar.com
Make the best choice, every time

Join our community to stay up-to-date with the latest reviews, recall notices, and brand recommendations.

Our community members are happier with their purchases than consumers who didn’t research before buying. To see why, sign up below!

THANK YOU

Keep an eye on your inbox, the latest consumer news is on its way!

Profile picture of Sandi Pope
Sandi Pope ConsumerAffairs Research Team

Sandi Pope previously worked in the nonprofit sector as an advocate for environmental and social change and believes information access is a human right. As a member of the ConsumerAffairs Research Team, she seeks to provide consumers with the necessary information needed in making life-altering decisions.