
M/I Homes Reviews
Columbus, Ohio
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.
Our editorial standards
- Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
- We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
- All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
About M/I Homes
M/I Homes creates residential communities featuring single-family homes and townhomes. Established in 1976, the company offers a variety of floor plans and design options across 16 states.
Visit www.mihomes.com/?cookiecheck=true- High-quality construction materials
- Good attention to detail in builds
- Poor communication from management
- Delayed repairs and service response
M/I Homes Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (61)
- (10)
- (3)
- (21)
- (171)
Popular Mentions
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.

Reviewed May 17, 2026
TERRIBLE customer service. Stephanie ** needs a new occupation immediately. She should not be in customer service. She is rude and has no class.
Reviewed May 17, 2026
We chose M/I at a higher price point because of marketing as having much better quality than other builders, exceeding code for certain things, etc. It is a beautiful home and there was good communication with the construction manager. But everything is thin and lightweight (doors, sheet rock, etc). Insulation was marketed with heavy core foam in the block (they really play that up) and show in their model 16" insulation in the attic. M/I denied our request to view the core foam installation (from afar), and I have no confidence they actually did it with the marketed materials. M/I denied our request for a independent pre-closing inspection (our request arrived to them a few hours over the deadline, so be aware there is no grace period). The builder said they would be happy to give me drone photos of the roof in lieu of the inspection, but continued to delay until I told them I would not agree to close until that promise was fulfilled.
At the 11-month independent inspection, several warrantied issues came up, but the M/I rep was rude, combative, and dismissive. For example, the marketed 16" of attic insulation was discovered to be between 6-12". It was suggested that we crawled up there to pat it down, or that the independent inspector was only finding or creating things to make it appear they were worth my money. One of two A/C vents had construction dust and needed cleaned, but they blamed it on me not changing the filter (not true), even after I explained that on a pre-drywall walk-through I had personally seen the builder discover a missing filter. Roof shingles were broken and cracked. M/I agreed to correct some of these things but only after stress and spending time preparing photos and videos to prove things. The landscaping has been a consistent problem, consistently un-level, and with dead patches on closing day. They blamed it our watering (not true).
We continue finding items 4 inches underneath the sod — plastic Coke bottles, large pavers, beer bottles, etc. They just threw the sod on top of their trash. Know these things before you buy. Ask the builder if you can personally walk (even clean) the site before they grade and sod your lawn. Ask if you will be able to observe specific things important to you, BEFORE you sign. Notify them on Day 1 that you will definitely want a pre-closing independent inspection, despite how nice they are or how competent they appear or how much they convince you the county will be inspecting everything to make sure code is met. Your builder will likely seem amazing, but he is not supervising regularly enough, and the workers on site are notorious for cutting corners.
Reviewed May 14, 2026
Updated on 06/18/2026: We submitted a 112-page engineering report detailing the issues with each balcony. These are major structural beams—not merely rotting handrails—and this should never have occurred. After reviewing the report, M/I refused to accept any responsibility, stating: “After reviewing the claim with our corporate attorneys, we have determined that we will not be providing warranty coverage. The statute of repose has expired, and as a result, we are no longer responsible for this community.”
Original Review: Thanks M/I for the shoddy workmanship and the use of incorrect and inferior (cheap) building materials that is forcing us to replace our balconies after only 15 years at nearly $30,000 a piece.

Hi Brett, we’re sorry to hear about your experience and understand how frustrating this situation must be. Our team would like the opportunity to look into this further for you.
Please submit a warranty request through our support page so we can review the details and assist you directly: https://www.mihomes.com/support/warranty
We appreciate you bringing this to our attention and look forward to helping.
Reviewed May 10, 2026
I would recommend M/I Homes, but also let others be aware of some of the caveats of some of the quality. But that's somewhat expected these days with newer builds and neighborhoods. I saw the house across from me be built and that the people working on it were good at their job. I they're not cutting corners. They were just going fast.
I was trying to put my family in a home and stop renting and M/I Homes had some good financial incentives that helped me do that. Also, they were very friendly and helpful. We were in Colorado at the time and we were purchasing the home in Texas. They were very flexible in helping us do the whole process remotely. We had a house built and chose the lot. They worked with our Realtor who was there in Texas. Everyone that we worked with on the staff was very nice.
Our home is a four-bedroom, two-bath. It's 2,100 square feet. The bones of it are solid. But some of the finishes were less than perfect, considering the price range of the home. I guess that's to be expected. But some of the trim work, I would like to redo one day. I tried to address some of that with them and M/I Homes did what they could to fix them, but they weren't interested in redoing it. They came in and tried to touch some things up with paint and sandpaper, but at the end of the day, it wasn't a million-dollar home. When you go into a model home, they look a lot more perfected. Some of the quality on some of the stuff like that wasn't my favorite. I'm a bit of a perfectionist, so maybe that's just me. But we had the home inspected pre-drywall, post-drywall, and 11 months, and no inspector was able to find anything wrong on the large scale. Being a DIY, I've been taking my time to touch it up on the aesthetics and finishes of it.
The neighborhood has one small pool. We're in a smaller town, so we have to drive a bit further to get to things. A Thomson opened up 15 minutes away and the city we're in just announced that there will be a grocery store five minutes from us next summer. So, it's growing. And that's what we knew going into it. It was a more affordable price for a smaller town, but also the town is going to be a lot bigger within the next five years. It was a good investment area.
I would recommend M/I Homes if somebody was looking for a first home and wanted to put a bit of work in to make it their own. It was like a builder-grade home. All the walls were flat paint, it was all the same color. We've gone through and repainted everything and touched things up and added those niceties over time. But considering the cost of the home, what we've invested is minimal to make it feel even more like our own.

Thank you for your detailed review and recommendation of M/I Homes. We're delighted to hear that our representatives were accommodating during your remote buying process and that our financial incentives supported your decision. We understand your remarks regarding some finishes, and we're pleased you found overall quality during inspection satisfactory. It's also exciting to know about the future growth in your neighborhood. We appreciate that you're making the house truly your own with your personal touches. Thank you for choosing M/I Homes!
Reviewed May 9, 2026
Recently Contracted for a new house with M/I Homes Valley Brooke Community in Mesquite Texas. Sales Counselor Laura ** did a great job of providing service in the selection process. She is very professional highly organized and dedicated to customer Service. My client is happy with the great and reputable MI Homes experience. I highly recommend MI Homes for your next Home Purchase.

Hi Abey, thank you for the wonderful recommendation. We are glad to hear that Laura provided such professional and highly organized service for you and your client during the selection process. It is great to know your client had such a positive experience, and we appreciate you recommending us for their next home purchase!
Reviewed May 9, 2026
We were planning on moving from Maryland to Texas, and I told my Realtor the type of houses we wanted. We wanted to look at some newly built homes, too, and she brought us down here. I liked the rep from M/I Homes. She was pleasant, informative and showed us different features of the house. I was impressed that she did not badmouth the competition. The home-buying process was straightforward because we did a lot of it over the phone and on the computer. The construction manager and the warranty manager worked their butt off to make working with M/I a good experience. They were both, and still are, very awesome people, as well as the finance manager who deals with contracts.
I like the house, though there are some things that I’m not thrilled with. 12-foot ceilings are very inconvenient to me and our windows in our living room and dining room are one piece. They don't open and I would've rather that they opened. Texas also has a bad habit of the ground moving and I'm not overly thrilled about that part. I understand the ground that settles. We've been in the home since the end of July and the quality of the build is better than some of the builders that I've heard of. These houses are not inexpensive. They're nice, but there are things that could have been better for the amount of money that we spent. The dollar amount that we spend for these houses could have been part of the price versus an upsell. I've bought a number of houses that were already built.
One thing that would have been nice was the granite counters. The flat square-type edging would be a little bit more upgrade. But if you wanted that, you had to pay more. One thing I did not like about buying a brand-new home was that we went through the design process and 99% of it was promoting the upgrades which cost additional money from what we were originally paying. It was a bit off-putting. In our history, my husband and I have had a lot of builders in our old houses, where we have improved them. It would have been nice for the amount of money. These are not million-dollar homes, but the base price was mid-400s.
From the get-go, you have to buy your property. There are a lot of options to make the house nicer. We had a second story put on. We have a media room and a game room. And we increased the size of the back porch. Each one of those was an additional $20,000. This is not a $5,000 thing. It was quite a bit. And that was almost depressing sometimes. It was a lot because we flew in, spent the night, came to the design, and then flew back out to go back to Maryland. That part was not what I expected. It wasn't a design. It was more of an upsell part. For a house that starts at this price, some of the houses I see around here probably hit $800,000 just by the upsell. I like my house, but there are things I would have thought should have been included.

Thank you for sharing such a detailed review of your experience with M/I Homes. We're pleased you found the home-buying process straightforward and those involved helpful and dedicated. We value your feedback on design choices and upgrades and will ensure our teams remain attentive to the expectations of our customers. We're proud you enjoy your home despite some challenges, and we're committed to continuously improving our offerings. Enjoy your new home in Texas!
Reviewed May 7, 2026
This is my seventh new home and it is my first M/I home. I have only done new homes. I've found the value to be a positive experience. I'm not handy. So, the idea of buying and renovating or doing the construction work in the home never appealed to me. I was not familiar with M/I Homes prior to the move to Texas. My daughter and son-in-law moved to Texas initially, and then they had our first grandson. So, they live in Flower Mound, which is about 19 miles from where we settled. I found an area where taxes overall were more favorable. I wanted to be close enough, but not too close to my daughter and grandson. I started to explore the Justin area and found this development, which was primarily M/I and KB Homes.
I looked at three to five builders in the area, which is typically what I do. I found M/I floor plans to be more attractive to me and also the options that M/I made available. Our consultant was very transparent and honest. It was excellent. It was one of the first times where a consultant would send me updates, even though I hadn't made a commitment to the home. They would send me weekly updates on the build out, and continued to answer my questions very professionally and very promptly, which is less and less how customer service occurs these days. But they were very good and very attentive to my questions. They were very responsive and candid. That really helped me to continue to look at M/I Homes.
I didn't ask for periodic updates and pictures on the home, but they were supplying them, and I found that to be really helpful. All in all, it was a very good customer service experience. We were moving from South Carolina, so we weren't local. So, we had to rely on that interaction to see how the home was being finished out. That was a very good experience, and it led me to the purchase decision. It's the first brick home. It's the first ranch-style home. I have been very, very happy with the quality of the build. I've had enough other homes where the one-year punch lists were longer or some of the depreciation was a little more apparent.
My wife feels were our must-haves. When you look at other homes, you look at floor plans, and you look at where you want to compromise. She didn't feel there was a lot of compromise here. It pretty much had everything she was looking for. It has really good spacing, and good layout. Our grandson is loving it too. We like the little bit of distance, so that we're not sitting on top of my daughter and son-in-law. We're really enjoying it.

Thank you for sharing your thoughtful experience. We're thrilled to hear that the design, options, and transparency impressed you throughout your home-buying journey with M/I Homes. It's delightful to know you felt informed and supported, even from a distance, and we're glad your new home fulfills you and your family's expectations. We're honored to have created a home environment that your wife and grandson love too. Wishing you many happy years in your new community!
Reviewed May 6, 2026
We were moving out of state and it was easier to look for new construction versus a resale because of the time involved. I first heard about M/I Homes through our realtor and by just looking during the search. Since we were only looking at new construction in the immediate area. We looked at everyone else around, like Taylor Morrison and Stanley Martin. We were trying to stay relative to a specific area. M/I Homes was in the area we wanted and we liked the model of the home. There were a few places we dismissed outright because they were closer to the nuclear power plant. But overall, it was the location combined with the layout we liked and the quality of the materials, which was better than others. With some other builders, the quality was not as good.
We worked with our realtor, but we also worked closely with the staff at M/I Homes since they were on the listing side. I liked Eric and Britta, and the listing agents we worked with. We still correspond with them since they’re still out there, so we had a good relationship with them right off the bat. I appreciated that they gave me play-by-play updates and occasional videos about the status of the house because we were out of state. Seeing videos of it was really important. There was sometimes a lag between what the actual system showed and what was going on versus the time, so the timelines didn’t always sync up. But honestly, the old-fashioned video updates helped a lot, along with the periodic videos from my agent.
We’re now settled into the home, and I still like it. We still have a lot to do because we’re not fully unpacked yet, and with new construction, you have to expect gray walls. It’s completely uncustomized, so we’ll work on that over time. We also did two inspections, including a pre-drywall inspection and another one right before closing. Some of our neighbors had issues after moving in, but we nipped a lot of those things in the bud because we had already gone through the inspections. So, we didn’t have many issues afterward.
M/I Homes was great to work with. I’m also a realtor, so I have exposure to how other people work. M/I Homes does a very good job compared to others. Everybody was personable and communication was great, which was especially important since we were moving from out of state. I knew everyone by name and what stood out to me, outside of the communication and timely updates, was the follow-up paperwork. They gave us a drive with everything on it, and we also had a walkthrough orientation of the house that was very clear. They even had a document that spelled out the first things we should do after moving in, which helped a lot because when you’re unpacking and dealing with everything else, your head is somewhere else that first week. I really appreciated that.

Thank you for your detailed and uplifting review, as well as for choosing M/I Homes for your relocation journey. We're thrilled to know our homes met your standards in location, design, and quality, and that Eric and Britta provided excellent communication throughout, making moving from out-of-state much smoother. It's wonderful to hear how inspections and meticulous processes helped ensure an enjoyable transition to your new home. We're honored by your recommendation and wish you continued happiness as you customize your new space.```
Reviewed May 5, 2026
Tracy, the M/I Homes rep, was nice. He was always there for response with whatever questions I have, from day one until closing. I was even impacted by a layoff, three months before closing, and Tracy was very reassuring and empathetic. I like the house. It's a good build. I like the kitchen, and the bathrooms are nice. I went for a bigger kitchen island. It could fit five people compared to the houses close by, even if it has more square footage.However, I've been having issues with HVAC. The humidity kept going up versus after winter. It just started. Recent, it has been 90 something. The warranty guys have been back and forth four times now. Their supervisor for the HVAC company has been to my house twice already and escalating the issue to his boss. I haven't heard anything from them. But so far, the humidity is stabilizing. Hopefully it doesn't creep up again.

Thank you for sharing your positive experience with M/I Homes, specifically highlighting Tracy's helpfulness and empathy throughout your home-buying process. We're pleased you enjoy your home's build quality and exceptional kitchen space. We apologize for the issues you've faced with your HVAC system and appreciate your patience while we work to resolve them. Your feedback is valuable, and we remain committed to ensuring your new home continues to meet your expectations.
Reviewed May 4, 2026
M/I Homes had a great interest option for a new build, which meant I could have gotten a nicer house for less overall with payments, with interest, and the quality of their home. The home-buying process was seamless, and working with their person through my person, they answered all my questions, they walked me through everything, and made it a seamless thing to do. The quality of my build is great. I haven't had any external problems. I like our new home community, too. I think all the houses represent the neighborhood. What I like about it is that you're not on top of each other. There's actual space in between the homes.
The only thing is they don't have any amenities. One thing that I wish they would have done is a community pool. Other than that, what I really like about M/I Homes is there's not a day that I haven't called them with something that they haven't responded within 24 hours, and dispatched someone to look at it. To me, the customer service is what sells it.

Thank you for the positive review of M/I Homes! We're thrilled you found the home-buying process seamless and are happy with your new build. It's wonderful to hear that our interest option and customer service stood out. We appreciate your feedback and note your suggestion about adding amenities. Your satisfaction reinforces our commitment to high-quality and community coherence, and we’re always here should you have any further questions or needs as you settle into your neighborhood.
Reviewed April 17, 2026
We like the models that M/I Homes is building. They were also very welcoming. The representative we worked with was really what sold us on the home. It was a very positive experience. They were very professional, easy to work with, and cooperative. We worked with Lisa as our loan consultant, and I was impressed with her responsiveness, number one. She was very quick to respond to any questions we had regarding the loan approval or anything about the loan process. We were also very pleased with the craftsmanship and the design of the home. They're taking care of some warranty issues, and there seems to be no issue with that. Also, it’s a 300-home community with great amenities in a fantastic location for us.

Hi Bill, we are thrilled to hear that you had such a positive experience from the moment you stepped into our models. It is wonderful that Lisa provided the quick responsiveness you needed during the loan process and that our team has been professional and easy to work with. We are so glad you love the design of your new home and are already enjoying the community's amenities and location!
Reviewed April 14, 2026
We were interested in M/I Homes since we already had friends in the neighborhood, and I chose a new build because of the financing rate at the time we were looking to move. We came randomly one day to take a look, went into the model home, and worked with Jeff. We toured five homes that day then left and came back about a week later to see one of them again before making a decision. From there, I decided to move forward with one of the homes we saw that first day. Jeff was awesome the whole time. It was a good situation price-wise as it was the last house in the neighborhood by the builder, so they were trying to get it out of it.
We’ve been in the house for only a few months and as the house is settling and from winter into spring, we can tell where some of the craftsmanship falls short. But overall, it's been a good home and experience. There's a pool across the street in the older neighborhood and although there is dog park, there are plenty of children's parks.

Hi Brittnee, it's great to hear that Jeff was so helpful and that you found a good situation to join your friends in the neighborhood. We appreciate the feedback regarding the craftsmanship as your home settles through the seasons, and we're glad you're enjoying the local parks. Thank you for choosing to build with us!
Reviewed April 9, 2026
New Home Consultant was great, but her management time and finance team were awful. The finance team lied on the paperwork to get us a pre approval and then a week before closing called and said, "Oh sorry we can’t get you closed and we won’t return your earnest money or lock rate money." The entire process was terrible, no communication, they won’t answer your calls or emails and treat you terrible. Was told if we have until June 30th to get an approval and they would use the funds we gave them to put done on a new purchased, but was forced to sign their cancellation documents by 2pm or lose that opportunity too.
Now I understand why they have horrible reviews. Stay as far away from this company they will rob you of your hard working money and then stop all communication. I will never recommend this company to anyone. And after this experience, why would I even give them another opportunity. Hopefully management will look into their employees and see the fraud that Gilbert ** and Anh ** committed to get the approval and then come up with excuse that my parent and I don’t qualify for a FHA loan 'cause we are not married.
When asked to have this in writing and have management call us, we received nothing. But continued to get emails requesting items and even having the notary show up at our house the morning of closing, because nothing was handled properly, even lying on the cancellation of contract saying the purchaser, cancelled, which we did not cancel it. This company is a joke. Anyone buying from this company use extreme caution.
Reviewed March 30, 2026
We found M/I Homes online and we liked that with a new build, we will be the first ones living in it. We also liked the way we communicated with the representative. Any issues or questions we had during the phase were answered clearly. M/I Homes offered better quality than the other homes we were looking at. And after living in the house for eight months, we are still happy with it.

Hi Daniel, thank you for sharing your experience. We’re so glad that our team kept communication clear and that you’re still loving the quality of your home eight months later. It’s wonderful to hear that being the first to live in your space has been so rewarding!
Reviewed March 24, 2026
We were exploring Florida for some time, and getting a new build made sense, financial sense. We were looking at the existing homes versus the new homes, and the prices were comparable. We liked M/I Homes' housing style. We also like that they paid close attention to quality. That was important to us. It wasn't about speed for us. It was more about quality and ensuring that whatever they did put up was going to stay up. This is our second home. We lived in New Jersey, so it really worked out nicely for us. Our home consultant was wonderful. We did our research. They met all of our expectations. We didn't set unrealistic goals. We know that this stuff takes time, and they exceeded our expectations. The overall experience was great. It’s a huge investment on our part, and thank goodness, it worked out perfectly.

Ariel, thank you for sharing your positive experience with M/I Homes! We’re so glad to hear that your home‑buying journey exceeded your expectations. Your kind words about our home designs, commitment to quality, and your experience with your home consultant truly mean a lot to us. We’re honored to have been part of your homebuilding journey and wish you all the best in your new home.
Reviewed March 19, 2026
I relocated from another state to Indy, and previously, I’ve had two new builds, which is what I prefer. So this is my third new build and because there's one right across the street, I went with M/I Homes. When I came in town last year, I went in to their office and at the time, I didn't know anything about them. Also, my realtor was taking me to the competitor, D.R. Horton. Their homes were nice and some of their finishes were better than M/I. But when I got back, I did a video conference with Mary, M/I's representative. She was so nice and I felt better going with M/I than with DR, even though they said they're number one builders, because of Mary. She has a good personality and she did a phenomenal job.
Everything went smoothly with M/I. The home consultant person picked out a floor plan and I told tell her which house I wanted. She was really on top of her job and I was really pleased with her. She kept me in tune every week and updated me every day. She went beyond. I am also satisfied with the home that I got. The countertops are Formica, so I decided to get aluminum because that is something that I’m not used to. All in all, I would tell my friends to keep M/I Homes in mind and I would recommend this place over the other builders.

Lucion - thank you for sharing your detailed home building/buying experience with M/I Homes. We're thrilled to learn about your relocation journey and appreciate your decision to choose us for your new home. It’s wonderful to hear that Mary’s assistance and the professionalism of our team made you feel confident in your choice. We're always here to assist should you need anything further!
Reviewed March 10, 2026
I'm happy with M/I Homes' end product and very happy with the customer service and transparency throughout the whole process. I had a great experience and I recommend them. The area seemed like a perfect situation. It is an older community, but with some new homes. It was too hard to pass it up. We were looking at other builders like Neil and the timing with M/I seemed perfect. They were down to their last few homes, and the real estate agent told us very good things about M/I. I trusted him, and it all worked out great.
M/I's rep, Damien, was great, very positive, very knowledgeable and supportive through the whole process. In fact, I've been in touch with him a few times since about a variety of things, and the whole experience has been very positive, including the website and being able to look at photos of the home being built. The customer service seems a little better than I expected.
Also, I have no complaints on the quality of the build. Shortly after closing, there was a hurricane, and it handled everything just fine, and the shutters and everything that came with the home worked out great. I didn't have many options. There were only three homes available. Apparently, there was another builder, and then they didn't finish the build. They sold some of their lots to M/I. So it was the perfect one for me because of the lot premium as well. It was a really nice lot. It was hard to pass that up. I have no neighbor behind me.
I had another guy who was in charge of touch-ups. There was a little blemish in the carpet in one of the bedrooms, and I was willing to just take a monetary discount if they didn't replace the carpet because I think the bed might have hit the blemish. However, they came in really fast, ripped it out, and redid it. I was not in Florida at the time. My real estate agent was helping me with some things. They took care of things without complaints, and they were very responsive. I could always get a hold of the people I needed to. The customer service was great.

Hi Brian, thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with M/I Homes! We're thrilled you found both your new home and community to be a perfect match. It's great to know our customer service exceeded your expectations, and we'll pass your compliments on to Damien and the rest of our team who supported you throughout the process. We're especially happy to hear that you stayed safe and that your home withstood the recent hurricane. Wishing you all the best!
Reviewed March 9, 2026
The process with M/I Homes was smooth. There are a lot of new construction in our area, so I was doing shopping for townhomes, and I saw that the neighborhood, Piper Landing, which is in Concord area, was good. So, I bought a home there. My home consultant, Carson, was good. He explained and he gave a lot of information about the builder. I had walk-ins a couple of times. I am not living in that townhome right now. I rent it out, but so far, I don't see major complaints. I'll recommend M/I Homes.

Thank you for your positive review and recommendation, Anil. We’re thrilled to hear about your smooth journey with M/I Homes and that you felt well-supported by Carson throughout the process.
Reviewed March 4, 2026
M/I Homes has been great. I liked being the first one in a house so I bought a new build from them. Everything was very great and very organized. They were very positive and helpful. The sales guy messaged me on February 27th, then I went and saw the property. After that, I was in there by March 27th. So their process was very quick. The price I paid was also really good.
Our home has a pool area and a mailbox area. It’s gated and I really like the quality. So far, everything is built very nicely. There are a few imperfections, but not to where it's bad. It’s kind of one of those things like, “Oh, somebody was probably moving too fast.” But it's still a very good quality home. I had an outside inspector come look at it and everything was great on it. I would tell my friends that they should look into going with M/I Homes. I trust them as a builder. With the things that have been wrong or that have happened just as having a home, I reached out to M/I, and everyone had been quick in getting everything resolved.

AJ, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with M/I Homes. We’re so glad to hear that the process was smooth, well organized, and moved quickly from your first visit to move‑in. It’s great to know you’re happy with the quality of your home and the community amenities, and we truly appreciate your thoughtful perspective. Wishing you many happy years in your new home!

Reviewed March 2, 2026
I do dozens of transactions per month with multiple national lenders and title companies, and this was one of the most frustrating coordination experiences I’ve encountered. Despite repeated clarification, M/I Title insisted that the mortgage broker enter title fees into the lender’s system — something brokers are neither authorized nor legally permitted to do. After being informed multiple times that we cannot access or input data into a lender’s closing system, they continued redirecting responsibility rather than contacting the lender directly. When asked to confirm who at the lender received their fees and when they were transmitted, responses were vague and circular. This created unnecessary delays in balancing the Closing Disclosure and put the transaction timeline at risk.
To be clear: no one was asking them to access a third-party portal. We simply requested that they provide their fees directly to the lender’s Closing Assist team in the proper format — which is standard practice in many transactions. Instead of resolving the issue efficiently, responsibility was shifted back to the broker, despite legal and procedural limitations. Closings require coordination and accountability from all parties. In this case, that cooperation was lacking. I hope management reviews internal communication procedures to prevent future clients and partners from experiencing similar delays.

Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your recent experience with M/I Title. We sincerely apologize for the coordination challenges you encountered during the process.
We place a high value on timely and effective communication with all our partners to ensure transactions play their course smoothly. We understand both procedural accuracy and coordinated action between parties are crucial for the success of closing procedures and are reviewing our internal processes to avert circumstances like this in upcoming transactions.
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2026
We saw M/I Homes by driving through the neighborhoods, and we decided on a new and not used house because I don't want to fix anything. The first person we worked with, Derek, was awesome. We signed off in September and closed in March, and Derek followed through the whole way through. It was a really good experience. Everything went as well as we expected and I would tell people to use M/I Homes. The house build is good and I like the extended island and the morning room. The community is nice as well.

Tim, thank you for sharing your experience with M/I Homes. We’re so glad you found us while driving around and that opting for a a new home rather than resale made the process more simple and stress‑free. It’s wonderful to hear that Derek provided great support from start to finish and followed through every step of the way. Your recommendation means a lot to us, and we truly appreciate your trust in our team!
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2026
The guy at M/I Homes worked with them very well and all the questions were answered. All I did was sign the paperwork. I had a 675 credit score. But there were a lot of little things that needed to be done on my credit or had to be recalled before they could do the loan. During that month, I spent at least five hours on phone calls with Stephanie. This girl was invaluable to me because I didn't know that there was something called buyer's remorse. There was one call at 11:30 at night where she talked with me and just calmed me down. I even went out to dinner with this lady after I bought the house. She was just so nice.
The house is of very high quality. It's wonderful. They have a waterpark and a dog park inside the community. I haven't been able to use the waterpark because I was trying to find out information about it and then I found out it was closed for the winter. But there are little things that are missing that I didn't even realize that I needed until after I got in the home, like in my bathroom, I don't have any drawers. So, I had to go get a carpenter to put in drawers in there, and then build me a medicine cabinet. You gotta have a place to put your toothbrush. But my experience with M/I Homes was wonderful.

Gregory, thank you for sharing your experience with M/I Homes. We’re so glad our team was able to support you throughout the process and answer all of your questions—Stephanie will especially appreciate hearing how impactful her guidance and reassurance were. It’s great to know you’re happy with the quality of your home and the community amenities, and we value your honest feedback.

Reviewed Feb. 21, 2026
Very poor craftsmanship and quality. Kitchen sink fell down 2 years after installation. We have had nothing but problems with this house. Every light has failed and needed to be replaced. Kitchen drawer faces have come off and dropped to the ground. Doors become misaligned and now this.

Thank you for sharing your feedback. We understand how frustrating it is to experience ongoing maintenance and workmanship issues in your home, and we’re sorry your experience has been disappointing. While some adjustments and repairs can occur over time as a home settles, we recognize your concerns and appreciate you taking the time to share them. Your feedback is important and helps inform our ongoing efforts to improve.
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2026
Our experience with M/I Homes was good. But the financing part was a little bit of an issue. But building the actual home itself was smooth. We didn't pick anything. It was already a done model, so our experience was probably shorter than most people's. The house was built, so we just closed and moved in. We got our one-year touchup. Stuff is still tracking a little bit. So, overall, the quality is fine. It still has some settling that happened after the one-year mark. So we had to take care of that on our own.

We appreciate you sharing your homebuying experience, Mason, and are glad to hear the build process itself was smooth and that the quick move‑in option made things straightforward. Thank you as well for your feedback on financing and post‑closing items—those insights are helpful. We appreciate you choosing M/I Homes and wish you the best in your home.
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2026
I went to a garage sale in our neighborhood, and M/I Homes was still building. I reached out to a Realtor and asked her for some information and she connected me with Krista, the person who helped us pick all our stuff for building. Cost-wise, it made more sense to build because the houses and the size that we wanted were the same price or more. We built the biggest square footage but with not many upgrades, so that it was in our budget. We signed everything on June 11th and then, we moved in on January 20th. It was smooth and it was exactly as it was explained in the walkthroughs. The longer we live here, there are things that I notice that are showing wear and tear when they maybe shouldn't, like the molding on the bottom, around the outside of the house or the inside of our home, the baseboards, the paint, and a little bit here and there. But not a lot. Some of the stuff in our kitchen is also showing wear and tear. But it is what it is.
The communication with M/I Homes was clear. They tell you how the process is gonna look and that’s exactly how it was. Everything’s very clear and outlined on the timeline, process and steps, and keeping you informed on the build. When they walk you through your house and show you your warranties, they're very thorough on all that. We love our neighborhood. There are lots of young families and kids. It’s very family-friendly.

Ali, thank you for sharing your experience with M/I Homes. We’re glad the process was smooth, clearly communicated, and aligned with what was explained during your walkthroughs; and that Krista and our team helped you build a home that fit both your needs and your budget! We also appreciate your honest feedback and are happy to know you’re enjoying the family-friendly feel of the community.
Reviewed Feb. 19, 2026
My Realtor was made aware that there was a spec home left in the sub that M/I Homes was still looking to sell. We went and took a tour, and we ended up liking it. At the time, there were some good incentives if you financed through M/I Homes, and that was a selling point for us. It was a brand-new home, but it was already built, so we didn't have to go through the process of building and picking things out. We liked all the finishes, which set it over the top for us. The rep was informative and offered to show us if we wanted to come back and look at the house, or bring our parents back. He was helpful in that regard and went above and beyond. He was awesome to work with.
Even into the first year of owning the home, where we do the 11-month warranty, I've had a good experience with their reps. They've taken care of any issue that arose super quickly and made it a smooth process from purchasing, getting everything going, as far as the deposit up to the closing. The post-move-in has gone very smoothly as well. I didn't have the opportunity to pick all of the finishes out, but they were super neutral, which is clean looking. I've been able to add things cosmetically to make it my own. It was a nice starting point. We've been here now for just a little over a year, and the community has a ton of young families. We have two kids ourselves, and we like it so far. It’s a family-oriented neighborhood. It feels safe and friendly.

Graziella, thank you for taking the time to share your experience! We’re so glad one of our available Quick Move-In homes was a great fit and that the incentives, finishes, and overall process made your decision an easy one. It’s wonderful to hear our team was informative, supportive, and went above and beyond both before and after closing. Knowing your family is enjoying your new home and community means a great deal to us. Thank you for choosing M/I Homes.
Reviewed Feb. 18, 2026
I wanted a new build because it has updated materials, better environmentally, sound, and less warranty issues. I accidentally came upon M/I Homes while looking at Saline, Michigan and the rep who assisted me with my purchase was really thorough. He was open, very responsive, and quick to bring help if asked. I would have been great to have more options on the homes. But for the price, the home is good quality.

Finding the right balance of quality, value, and support is important when choosing a new home, and we appreciate you sharing your experience, Timothy. We’re glad you found value in choosing a new build and are really glad hearing that our team was thorough, responsive, and supportive throughout your purchase! Thank you for choosing M/I Homes and for taking the time to share your perspective.
Reviewed Feb. 17, 2026
Nikki helped us go through everything. It was a little tough on the negotiations, but that's part of her job. She was great. She listened well to what we asked and provided solutions that helped us sort through the different choices. We were very comfortable going through the process. We built several houses to get it. The build quality is excellent. The builder we had, Jimmy, was fantastic. He is, by far, the best builder I've had out of any of the homes that we've built. The community is nice. I like that it is a little bit hidden. I would recommend M/I Homes. We've had a couple of warranty things and they've been taken care of well. When you build a home, there's always going to be something, but everything worked out very well.

David, thank you for sharing your experience! We’re glad to hear Nikki took the time to listen, walk through options with you, and help make the home buying process comfortable from start to finish. It’s also great to know Jimmy made such a strong impression and that you’re happy with the overall build quality. We appreciate your understanding that a few warranty items can come up with any new home and are happy our team was able to take care of them. Thanks again for choosing M/I Homes and for the recommendation.

Reviewed Feb. 13, 2026
My home needs all windows replaced in under 3 years. Even after multiple complaints M/I Homes puts the responsibility on the homeowner knowing windows should not look like this. Instead they advise me to decrease the humidity in my home and raise the shades. This has been their suggestion or to contact the crappy window vendor that they selected because they say it is not a construction defect although all the pouring water will damage my walls and the wood. They say, "Too bad we won’t help." I even have to put plastic to my windows to keep the heat inside. Just terrible. No way anyone should purchase unless you are allowed to choose all vendors for your home because you will be stuck with horrible treatment and a $40,000 bill after paying over a half million dollars for your home. Unacceptable.

Thank you for taking the time to share your concerns, Hawanya. We understand how upsetting it is to experience ongoing issues in your home, especially when they involve windows. While some conditions can be influenced by a variety of factors over time, we appreciate your feedback and take comments like these seriously as we continue evaluating our processes and partners.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2026
I purchased a new build in a new community (Goodland), Prairie Ridge, TX. Dec 2024. I inspected the house several times during the built when the workers were gone to find beer cans on my bathroom floor and pee in both my tubs. GC stated he would look into it but nothing came of it, I was only told I would be given a clean house. Now that it's been a year I find out M/I Homes lender screwed me over on my property taxes. He used taxes for a vacant lot so now my escrow account is short by over $10K.
I had a water leak from the irrigation system they installed, they sent someone to fix it as it was still under the 1 year warranty. I now find out it was not fixed just patched over. So with the freeze we just had, the valve that needed to be replaced but was not, has now broken and I have another water leak. The freeze also caused the walkway to my front door to crack and spall. I contacted M/I Homes but since it's over a 1 year the warranty has run out. Even though the cheap cement they used is the reason why the concrete is cracking. All I hear from them is "it's over the 1 year warranty" so they will not cover it.

Lucia - we're sorry to see your review and appreciate you taking the time to outline your concerns, including those related to the build process, financing, and post‑closing issues. While warranty coverage does have defined timeframes, we recognize how disappointing it can be when issues arise outside that period. Your feedback is important and has been shared internally, as it helps inform our ongoing efforts to improve communication, quality, and the overall homeowner experience.

Reviewed Feb. 1, 2026
I did not get approval for loan and they kept my $5,000 earnest money. In the purchase agreement, it states the earnest money is returned if the loan is not approved. I am 66 and on SS, I needed the money. It’s sad to think they can rip people off like this.

Reviewed Jan. 16, 2026
We're so sad because M/I sales lady Shannie in Justin, Texas ended up lying to us. We trusted her and thought she was really going to help us. She does smile and put on a nice front but will not be honest. Even when there is proof right in front of her. We want to buy a home from a company that has integrity and won't lie. Praying we can find a wonderful home from a trustworthy company.

Thank you for sharing your experience with us - we're sorry to hear this. We value integrity and transparency, and it's important that all interactions reflect these principles. We appreciate your feedback and will address this matter to prevent similar occurrences.

Reviewed Dec. 18, 2025
Let me start by saying the supervisor at Trailside in Cincinnati Ohio is drinking beer and smoking cigarettes in his truck all day long. Been working in construction for 25 years and he is the worst thing I have ever experienced. New houses have so many blemishes, fresh concrete is cracked and I'm not talking about the terrible driveway jobs, the front porches are so bad. The trades are always faced with inappropriate work environments. OSHA has been all over this supervisor (Danny). The plumbing inspectors are sending letters to the state because of the lies and shortcuts he takes. Never buy homes from Trailside, your issues will start from the moment you move in, if you have to deal with Danny then you will be completely disappointed.
Reviewed Nov. 12, 2025
We were very pleased when we purchased our home but as time has gone on, we have had nothing but issues. We have been in our home 5 years and have had to replace windows, replaced appliances, dealt with a roof leak, hundreds of screw pops, cracked ceilings and corners, yellowed cabinets and separating hard wood floors. The only thing worse than the materials is the craftsmanship. I highly recommend looking at other builders.
Reviewed Sept. 19, 2025
It was all good until we ran into the VP of Contruction, Parke **. We asked about looking at our backyard due to not looking as good as we expected. As soon as he introduced himself to my wife and I, he began his degrading demeanor and words. He then started telling and showing us aggressively what we signed. He would not listen and keep telling us that this is a starter lawn and it looks good compared to others. He continued to talk over my wife and to me was disrespectful. I refused to speak to him and told him that. Poor people, if they had to or soon have to even speak to him. I refused to speak to him due to his condescending, aggressive behavior.
The lady with him, Kyla **, was listening inventively along with the gentleman from Start to Finish. If I would have known that we would be treated like this, I would have never purchased a home from MI. He continued to tell us we need to water, in fact $280 for a month. We also hired Tru-Green, who are professionals, do not agree with Parke. We have taken great care of the outside and inside of our home and it is apparent. He walked into the home, the contract in hand and wasted no time pointing things that we signed. It's not what you say, it's how you say it. If MI wants to be known as a track home, you definitely picked the right guy. I felt for the location and price, we deserved better.
I have tried to be heard, and MI homes have failed us in being heard. We feel that this lack of consideration by Parke causes us to let others know about this process through different social media networks, YELP, FACEBOOK and I have started a complaint with the Better Business Bureau of Indiana. According to most of the reviews, I am only one of many that have issues.
Reviewed Sept. 16, 2025
Poor Craftsmanship and Disappointing Experience from M/I Homes. If you're considering M/I Homes to build your home, I strongly urge you to look elsewhere. The craftsmanship throughout our build was shockingly substandard. From the moment we moved in, we noticed glaring issues: leaking valves, ruined cabinets, wet carpet and pad, truss uplift, separating LVP flooring, leaking windows, cracked ceilings and walls, uneven flooring, a front door that won’t open in the winter, and sloppy paintwork that looked like it was rushed by amateurs.
Even basic structural elements were poorly executed. We had to bring in independent contractors to fix what should have been done right the first time. The worst part? When we raised these concerns, the company (M/I Homes) was dismissive and slow to respond—if they responded at all. A home is supposed to be a place of comfort and pride. Instead, we’ve been left with a list of repairs, mounting frustration, and the sinking feeling that we were taken advantage of. If quality and accountability matter to you, steer clear of this builder and its subcontractors.
Reviewed Sept. 10, 2025
M/I Homes is a fraud thieves company. Please be aware of them. Never ever give your hard earned earnest money to them. If you ever back out they won't even give you a single penny. They are giving us stress and anxiety and we are having a hard time as a family because of them..
Reviewed Aug. 17, 2025
Bought a new townhouse with finished basement from MI Homes. Last month, we suddenly found the carpet‘s wet and the furnitures remolded. We were told to cut the dry wall and we found one Rod hole is not sealed! So the leaking issue is there since day one, but because of the insulation and drywall, we didn't notice the issue in the 1st year which means MI homes won't cover all the loss?
MI homes offers to fix the drywall and carpet, but we have to pay for the new furniture and etc. And how they gonna fix the drywall? They don't even want to replace the molded/rotten lumber! Also the bottom lumber MI homes used are NOT pressure treated and MI homes said they didn't use any pressure treated lumber in our neighbour, so it's not an issue?
Reviewed Aug. 12, 2025
My personal experience and opinion of M/I Homes Moran Ranch Willis, Texas. I will list the issues that we have dealt with and are still dealing with in reference to this builder. First nine days after closing spent in a hotel due to the fact that Tankless Water Heater was broken, unable to fix then waiting on parts which did not correct the problem. End result new water heater installed. Should have been found by their Building Superintendent prior to closing.
HVAC Systems are too small for Square footage of home. 2833 sf home, twenty one windows, twelve foot ceilings and we have a 3.5 ton AC Unit. Unit runs "Constantly". Be prepared for ridiculous Electric bills monthly. Smaller SF homes in same area/street with less windows have larger units. Cost cutting measure on builder's part. Checked with Lennox for required size and they stated minimum five ton, and under size will cause overworked system which will not last. BTU rating should be about 70,000 and this one is 40,000 BTU. Lone Star Air Systems who installed for builder notified of issues, to date zero correction.
Attic Insulation not to required depths, I had to add more blown in attic insulation. The whole west side of attic was missing insulation.
Water Sprinkler System zones did not all come on from low water pressure. Not sure how it was inspected and able to see not working. Zones do not overlap to have equal water coverage. I had to move sprinkler heads, add sprinkler heads and change out types of heads for whole yard coverage.
Six foot Cedar fence not new, missing fence pickets, broken fence pickets. Fence sections some are higher than the others, not straight. Iron fence along the back, posts loose and sections were not bolted together.
Roofing is Outdated. Three Tab Shingles with plastic roof vents. Will have issues in the Texas weather within five years.
No Rain Gutters or downspouts on sides or rear of home.
Flooring is Linoleum Strips which separate and bubble up. Made to look like hardwood floors.
Broken rear master bedroom window not found by builder inspection.
Cheap Electrical Breakers that keep tripping.
No Soffit Vents on outside roof. In order to meet Code a Strip Vent, not recommended by roofers, was installed 18 to 24 inches up roof from bottom.
No electrical power to outside patio fans.
Only two ceiling fans.
Garage lighting very weak, had to change out.
Under Kitchen Cabinet lights broken, different colors.
Builder grade appliances cheap grade. May last two years.
Roof Window and rear Hardy Plank not painted.
Concrete driveway has golf ball size divots along with long gouge marks in concrete.
Garage Door concrete sill uneven. Lower on right side causing garage door to not seal all the way across.
Outside Hose Bib Faucets leaking. Had to replace.
Red Clay dirt Stains on brick and exterior white stone.
Roof design over front porch poorly engineered. Rain water does not make it to front gutters before diverting over the side. I had to pay to have a diverter installed. M/I Builder, after showing the video of problem refused to correct.
Closet and bathroom doors damaged and do not close.
Recessed lights in master bathroom not in a straight line pattern. ???m
Uses 1x4's as door and floor molding, no architectural design.
Yes, there are worse builders but when you pay this kind of money you should get more and receive more attention to detail. Along with a better Energy Efficient Home. Bottom line, would I buy another M/I Home? NO. K. ** Moran Ranch Subdivision. Willis, Texas
Reviewed July 23, 2025
I built a home with MI Homes, and unfortunately, I cannot recommend them to anyone. From the beginning, their sales team made impressive promises--many of which turned out to be misleading or simply untrue. Once construction began, the experience quickly deteriorated. The construction managers were polite and responsive--until I signed the 30-day inspection report. After that, their attitude shifted dramatically. Any issues I raised were met with a dismissive "not our problem."
I strongly urge future homeowners: DO NOT SIGN THE 30-day inspection report. You have NO legal obligation to do so, and signing that document only gives MI Homes a legal out, allowing them to limit their support and accountability. IT DOES NOTHING FOR YOU!!!! They may assure you that unresolved issues will be addressed in the 60-day report, but that's a promise I regret believing. One year later, I'm stuck with a failing concrete driveway--cracking and deteriorating--and facing a potential $20,000 replacement cost. This experience has been deeply frustrating and expensive. If you're considering building with MI Homes, proceed with extreme caution and protect yourself at every step. Don't let their paperwork become your problem.
M/I Homes Company Information
- Company Name:
- M/I Homes
- Website:
- www.mihomes.com
