Write a review
  2. Automotive
  3. Best Car Insurance

Best Car Insurance in Cincinnati, OH

  • Allstate Auto Insurance
    1.4(2,335)
  • QuoteWizard
    1.0(1)
  • EverQuote Insurance Services

Top Picks

See who reviewers like

Allstate Auto Insurance logo
QuoteWizard logo
EverQuote Insurance Services logo
See our top picks
Author picture
Author picture
Written by

Best Car Insurance in Cincinnati, OH

Besides being required by law, auto insurance in Ohio is necessary because it keeps you financially protected after an accident, no matter who is at fault. Many policies are available from different companies and agencies, so we created this list of the best Cincinnati auto insurance to help find affordable coverage.

Why trust ConsumerAffairs?
  • Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say.
  • 4,568,520 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

Top 13 Cincinnati Car Insurance Companies

Sort
  • Best Rated
  • Most Reviewed
  • Highest Rated
cincinnati skyline

Driving in Cincinnati, OH

Car insurance is a necessity for drivers in Cincinnati — and not just because it’s legally required. Policyholders use insurance after crashes, weather- and road-related accidents and crime incidents.

  • Crashes in Cincinnati: According to the Ohio State Highway Patrol, there were more than 31,000 crashes in Hamilton County in 2018, almost 50 of which were fatal. Auto insurance covers liability if you are responsible for an accident that leads to property damage or injury. In addition, many drivers purchase collision insurance, which pays for repairs to your vehicle no matter who caused the accident, or uninsured/underinsured motorists coverage, which covers you if another driver is uninsured or doesn’t have enough insurance.
  • Road conditions in Cincinnati: Rain, snow and construction activity cause unsafe road conditions in Cincinnati. Many car insurance companies offer roadside assistance coverage, which usually includes towing, battery boost, flat tire help, fuel delivery and locksmith service.
  • Vehicle theft in Cincinnati: There have been more than 1,000 auto thefts in Cincinnati each year over the past three years, according to the Cincinnati Police Department. Neighborhoods such as Westwood, West Price Hill, East Price Hill, Over-The-Rhine and Clifton have the highest rates of vehicle theft. By purchasing auto insurance with comprehensive coverage, you protect yourself from financial loss if your car is stolen or vandalized.

Average Cincinnati car insurance prices

The average cost for auto insurance in Cincinnati is between $1,100 and $1,200, which is lower than the national average. Each car insurance company uses multiple variables to determine its premiums. According to the Ohio Department of Insurance, insurers often take these factors into account:

  • Where you live in Cincinnati
  • Age, sex and marital status
  • Driving record
  • Driving habits
  • Type of car
  • Credit score

Where you live has one of the most significant impacts on the cost of your insurance. The table below gives car insurance cost estimates for a 30-year-old female in various Cincinnati locations.

Cincinnati areaComprehensiveLiabilityState minimum
Downtown - 45202$1,200$550$500
Blue Ash - 45242$1,040$510$450
Indian Hill - 45243$1,070$500$460
Mason - 45040$1,000$480$430
Anderson - 45230$1,100$510$470
West Chester - 45069$1,040$520$450
"Comprehensive” is defined as $100k/$300k/$50k in coverage, “Liability” is $50k/$100k/$50k and “State minimum” is $25k/$50k/$25k.

Before you get an insurance quote, ask the insurance agency what discounts it offers and if you qualify. You can usually save by insuring multiple cars, bundling car insurance with homeowners insurance or being accident- and claims-free.

Does Ohio require car insurance?

By law, Ohio requires proof of financial responsibility to drive a car. The easiest way to comply with financial responsibility requirements is to purchase auto insurance. You must have liability coverage in at least the following amounts:

  • $25,000 per person injured in one accident
  • $50,000 for all people injured in one accident
  • $25,000 for property damage in one accident

Many drivers purchase liability coverage in higher amounts, depending on the value of their assets — if you get into an accident and are responsible for damages that exceed the limits of your coverage, you could have your wages garnished or lose your home or car. In addition, it’s common to purchase additional types of protection, such as collision, comprehensive and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.

Cincinnati car insurance alternatives

Ohio gives drivers several alternatives to purchasing car insurance. These include:

  • Obtaining a certificate from the Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV) indicating money or government bonds in the amount of $30,000 is on deposit with the Ohio treasurer
  • Obtaining a certificate of bond from the BMV in the amount of $30,000 that is signed by two individuals who own real estate with equity of at least $60,000
  • Obtaining a certificate of self-insurance from the BMV (for those who have more than 25 vehicles registered in an individual or company’s name)
  • A $30,000 bond issued by an authorized insurance or surety company

Cincinnati auto insurance FAQ

Is Ohio a no-fault state for accidents?
No, Ohio is not a no-fault state. Following an accident, fault is established, and the at-fault party is responsible for damages.
Why are Ohio’s rates so high?
Actually, the state of Ohio has some of the cheapest car insurance rates in the nation. Rates in Cincinnati are the fourth-highest in the state, below Youngstown, Cleveland and Toledo.
How do I find cheap SR-22 insurance in Cincinnati?
Many of the car insurance companies on our list help with SR-22 insurance, which is required for certain drivers in Ohio. After you apply and pay for a policy, the insurance company files the SR-22 with the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles, often electronically.

Not sure how to choose?

Get buying tips about Car Insurance in Cincinnati delivered to your inbox.

    By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Thanks for subscribing.

    You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

    Cincinnati car insurance company information

    Cincinnatus Insurance

    Cincinnatus Insurance, an independent agency, provides access to multiple car insurance companies and coverages, which makes it easy to switch from insurer to insurer. The company also offers claims assistance. Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana drivers get a free quote and policy review.

    • Address: 4790 Red Bank Expressway, Ste. 207, Cincinnati, OH 45227
    • Phone: (513) 587-3553
    • Hours: M - F: 9am - 5pm
    • Website: cincinnatusinsurance.com
    Camargo Insurance Agency

    Camargo Insurance Agency is a local insurance broker that offers insurance in Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana. Independent, experienced agents are always available to answer questions, update car insurance policies and review your coverage. Get a free car insurance quote by calling its Downtown Cincinnati office.

    • Address: 615 Elsinore Place, Ste. 310, Cincinnati, OH 45202
    • Phone: (513) 561-5311
    • Hours: M - F: 8:45am - 5pm
    • Website: camargoinsurance.com
    Ohio Insurance Center Agency

    Ohio Insurance Center Agency has been insuring drivers in Ohio for over 40 years. It represents more than 20 top-rated companies and specializes in SR-22/bonds and high-risk insurance. Fill out an online form or call to request a free quote. You can also stop by the office without an appointment.

    • Address: 7404 Hamilton Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45231
    • Phone: (513) 522-6300
    • Hours: M - F: 9am - 5:30pm
    • Website: ohioinsurancecenter.com
    Advantage Insurance Network

    Advantage Insurance Network is an independent insurance agency that represents more than 20 insurance companies and serves clients in the Tri-State area. Compare quotes online 24/7. Clients can log in to their account to view policies, print ID cards, make payments and file claims.

    • Address: 4739 Delhi Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45238
    • Phone: (513) 922-9460
    • Hours: M - F: 8am - 7pm; Sat: 9am -1pm
    • Website: myadvantageinsurance.com
    Pathway Insurance

    Pathway Insurance Services independently shops the insurance marketplace for Cincinnati auto insurance. Its “Pathway Coverage Checklist” is an easy-to-use tool that helps policyholders determine if they have the right coverage. Online quotes are available 24/7 in Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana. You can also chat with a licensed agent online seven days a week.

    • Address: 4221 Malsbary Road, Ste. 201, Cincinnati, OH 45242
    • Phone: (513) 662-7000
    • Hours: M - F: 9am - 5pm
    • Website: pathwayinsurance.net
    Zinser Insurance Agency

    Agents at Zinser Insurance Agency match clients with policies from nationwide insurance carriers. Its staff members help with all aspects of car insurance — from quoting to purchasing to servicing. Go to Zinser Insurance Agency’s website for an instant quote or call to go over your coverage options.

    • Address: 5310 Glenway Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45238
    • Phone: (513) 451-8898
    • Hours: M - F: 9am - 5pm
    • Website: zinserinsurance.com
    Greater Cincinnati Insurance Services

    Greater Cincinnati Insurance Services, an independent agency, offers residents of Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana affordable and individualized car insurance. It also covers motorcycles, recreational vehicles and boats. Clients can log in to a customer service center to view policies, print ID cards and update information. Get a quote online in five minutes.

    • Address: 417 Anderson Ferry Road, Ste. 3, Cincinnati, OH 45238
    • Phone: (513) 471-1400
    • Hours: Call for hours
    • Website: gc-insurance.com
    Huesman Schmid Insurance Agency

    Huesman Schmid Insurance Agency is an independent agency that offers auto insurance to drivers in Ohio, Indiana and Kentucky. Its advisors help clients choose the right coverage and get all available discounts. Request a free, no-obligation quote by completing an online form or calling the office.

    • Address: 5670 Cheviot Road, Cincinnati, OH 45247
    • Phone: (513) 521-8590
    • Hours: M - F: 8:30am - 4:30pm
    • Website: huesmanschmid.com
    Dabbelt Insurance

    Dabbelt Insurance is an independent, full-service agency with more than 70 years of experience in Greater Cincinnati. Agents assist with all types of auto insurance coverage and offer discounts for good drivers, good students and those purchasing multiple policies. Fill out an online form or call for a free quote.

    • Address: 5932 Glenway Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45238
    • Phone: (513) 451-8050
    • Hours: Call for hours
    • Website: dabbeltinsurance.com
    Dwyer Insurance

    Dwyer Insurance is an independent, full-service insurance agency that works with residents of Ohio, Kentucky and Indiana. It checks several preferred insurance companies to find clients the best combination of cost and coverage. Contact Dwyer Insurance to request a free car insurance quote.

    • Address: 3356 North Bend Road, Cincinnati, OH 45239
    • Phone: (513) 389-4100
    • Hours: Call for hours
    • Website: dwyer.biz

    Want your company to be on this guide?

    Yes, continue
    Comparing

    ×