
Premier Auto Protect Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+1 more
About Premier Auto Protect
Premier Auto Protect helps car owners avoid costly vehicle repairs with its vehicle service contracts. The company offers seven plan levels, which all include a 30-day money-back guarantee and 24/7 roadside assistance. Customers can choose any ASE-certified technician for repairs and transfer their contract after selling a car.
Visit premierautoprotect.com- 24/7 support
- Direct payment to repair shop
- Rental car coverage
- No price information online
Premier Auto Protect Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (188)
- (13)
- (4)
- (2)
- (43)
Popular Mentions
- 4,943,548 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Recent
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,943,548 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed Sept. 15, 2025
I couldn’t get them to cover any of my auto repairs. They said they were all parts that were out and need maintenance. Yes, that’s correct. That’s why I got an extended warranty. One was a clutch for my standard vehicle so I wound up paying for that $1700 then I had a problem with the steering and the ride and they denied all those. Not sure what good the warranty is.
Reviewed Sept. 14, 2025
Absolutely the WORST WARRANTY COMPANY!!! Denied my engine repair because my tires were 12.8 centimeters bigger than original. WHAT THE ** does that have to do with my engine. No matter what I claimed, it would have been denied. DO NOT GO WITH THIS COMPANY. YOU WILL REGRET IT.
Reviewed Sept. 3, 2025
Best company hands down, now I can drive in confidence in the vehicle I love so much. Get protected and live life with no worries. Other companies will rob you for your hard-earned money, Premier is the most reasonable company out there. Best decision I made in years. I’m no gate keeper. I tell as many people as possible about Premier. Spread the word and help other get protected the right way.
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2025
We have been shopping around for extended warranty on our used truck that we just purchased. This sales experience was by far the best and the coverage and price was the best also, after checking with several vendors. The salesman was very knowledgeable and met all of our needs and was very patient to answer all of our questions.
Reviewed Aug. 29, 2025
My customer service associate was Alex **. I couldn’t talk over the phone at work, so he gave me excellent customer service through text and email, great communication and was very helpful in me buying a service contract.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2025
I was constantly updated about my options, payments and coverages. The communication with the agent was outstanding. I am excited about the coverage I have chosen and am confident my needs will be met should I need them in the future.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2025
My experience with the process of reviewing, comparing and signing on with Premier was made tremendously effortless thanks to your representative Eli. I will 100% be recommending family and friends to Premier for any vehicle coverage of their cars. Thank you Eli.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2025
D ** was awesome. Answered all of my questions. Explained everything to me thoroughly, even found away to give me an extra incentive. Shout out to d **. I would definitely recommend Premier auto to all of my family and friends.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2025
If you read a lot of the reviews, the 5 stars are based on customer service, questions, how the sales went, etc. They are correct. The problem starts when you need them. My daughter's car, 2019 Malibu, the CVT transmission started to go out. They wouldn't fix it, the mechanic had to do other things they suggested, as they refused until the other options were tried first. We did this at our cost as they paid nothing. Ten weeks later her car is back in the shop because of doing the same thing. It took a week for our mechanic to get an answer on the claim, well response that they would be sending an inspector to verify everything. He got an email on Friday when they didn't show up on Thursday that the mechanic can do the inspection, email for the inspection took 2 days for him to get.
They will fix the transmission. The only options since the car is not a 2024-25 model is a remanufactured or refurbished costing 6000 or a used one costing costing less than 2000, which is what Premier claims said they'd pay for. I tried to call customer service regarding this, very non-caring, advised it was the plan I bought. (I bought the most expensive one because the salesman assured me all would be covered with new parts as I always make sure used/salvage yard parts are not going to be used because of past experiences.) In your plan it states under General Provisions "replacement will be made with parts of like kind and quality and compatible with the Covered Vehicle's specification."
Per the claims team I emailed they stated "Of like kind and quality means that we will source components that are used, aftermarket, remanufactured, or new, as needed. In this case we have sourced the component used, from **". They will only pay for the cost of the one they found that has 69000 miles on it at 1691.60. My mechanic found a better one w/ 61000 miles for 1720 and they refuse to pay for that one as the one they found will work and is cheaper. I will have to pay the difference of the 2 and I have no idea what they are going to pay on labor. I have a 100.00 deductible to pay but I know that it's going to go higher than that. My experience with all of this has been horrifying to say the least.
The last thing you want is a used part being put in your child's car that could break down anywhere, anytime and just hoping they will be safe. Which is the reason I bought a warranty plan to make sure her car stays running good if something goes wrong. Premier is a third party and partners with 4 companies that do the claims based on the wonderful policy the salesman sells you. These are salesman, ask questions, get it in writing - I thought I had - and if they are a third party run and keep looking. Make sure when you read reviews you read bad ones and good ones and you will see a trend that the bad ones are based on usage and the good ones are based on before usage.
If you buy a policy from Premier or any third party beware, it feels safe to have a warranty if something goes wrong but then the nightmare starts when it has to be used. Oh, and finding someone to take the warranty as payment is another issue. I have been looking for other warranties since I plan on canceling after her car is fixed. There are direct, non-third party, plans out there that have it in writing they will only use new parts and will pay the cost no matter where you go, even it's the dealership. Again, buyer beware if you choose Premier. You've been warned.
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2025
Aaron ** answered all of my questions concerning my contract, what my package includes & what is covered and not covered under my contract. He also made sure I knew what my deductible. Aaron was very professional and knowledgeable on all my inquiries. I am thinking about adding my truck.
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2025
Great service. Did not oversell and explained everything. Did not waste my time. Explained all options and plans, and answered all my questions very professional and text and explained mailed information promptly.
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2025
So far so good, but can't give reviews unless I see what happens when my car breaks down and if they keep their word. As of now Great customer service but so was the other 2 car Insurance companies that I left on bad terms...And still waiting on a refund...
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2025
Edward was very professional and helpful.. Understood what I was looking for and explained in detailed terms of what I was asking. The communication was top tier as well. I would definitely recommend to friends and family.
Reviewed July 8, 2025
Premier was happy to open me a policy on the weekend. After several months paying I have never received a policy number or and documents about my policy. I decided to cancel. Here is where the company went sour. I tried to cancel before my renewal date but that was on a weekend and they are not open. Called customer service to cancel and the lady that answered was nothing but hateful. She informed me that everyone knew they did not work on the weekends, well except me. Then instead of letting me ask her questions about what I was billed and the cancelation fee she hollered over me every time I spoke. With this experience I would not recommend this product.
Reviewed June 23, 2025
I would like to take this moment and personally thank Marc for assisting me with my decision to purchase a warranty plan with Premier Auto Protect. He did an outstanding job explaining me the plans and prices. He made the sale to me in about 15-20 minutes. He did not try to trap me into buying a plan like Car Shield did, that salesman would not let me get off the call, he held on the phone for about an hour and a half, meanwhile I got frustrated and finally hung up the phone. The plans Car Shield offer was in no comparison to Premier Auto Protect.
Marc great personally and superb knowledge on Premier car plans made me comfortable enough to do business with them. Sunday, I was doing a cost estimate with a variety of businesses, but I felt like Premier Auto was the best plan for my family vehicles. Thanks again Marc and keep being you, great a person and an awesome salesman for Premier. I don't know what future brings, but I know that Premier Auto plans was the best I saw on Sunday!
Reviewed June 21, 2025
Cameron was extremely polite and took time to answer questions and was not pushing a sale. Wanted to make sure I was informed and had all the information. He volunteered to call me back and wanted me to get the best value for my warranty coverage. He was very pleasant to deal with.
Reviewed June 21, 2025
The gentleman explain things to me very clearly and gave me assurance that this is the plan for me. Even gave me a reason why other policies are so expensive. Enjoy talking with him and I would hope that others would follow his lead in being honest and upfront. I did not feel like I was being taken advantage of.
Reviewed June 20, 2025
Let me just start off by saying I’m glad I chose Premier Auto Protect. Cameron ** (Account Specialist) put my mind at ease. He made me feel confident that I was going with the best coverage. Very attentive..answering any and all questions I had. As a customer you want honesty and clarity. I was given both! I would recommend this Company to anyone I know without question
Reviewed June 20, 2025
Everything went smoothly. Highly recommend this company and its products. Customer service was exceptional and very professional. Best service I’ve seen around for the price. Please go and check them out, you won’t be disappointed in this company and their service.
Reviewed June 20, 2025
Kevin was helpful and followed up with my inquiry in a timely fashion. He made this process smooth and seamless for me. He gave me a good rate for my coverage and detailed the plan over the phone. Thanks Kevin!
Reviewed June 20, 2025
Thanks Ed for your help and guidance.
Reviewed June 20, 2025
It was a pleasure working with Eric. He found a way to get me the best Plan available, for a great monthly rate. Plus some extras for a very reasonable price. It was a pleasure working with Premeir Auto Protect and their staff. They were friendly, courteous and knowledgeable. Great Job!
Reviewed June 19, 2025
Morris ** was prompt, knowledgeable. I had a number of questions over several hours and he answered all promptly and completely. Good experience overall. Would definitely recommend at this point. Looking forward to the same great service when I have a claim.
Reviewed June 19, 2025
I spoke to Kevin. Told him that I needed to cancel the coverage on my vehicle, and that I wanted to add my wife's vehicle, he made the process very easy. Explaining everything. My experience with Premier Auto makes it a no- brainer thanks Kevin.
Reviewed June 19, 2025
No one is perfect but Eric is as close as anyone has gotten!! Great!!!! Service was on point!! Couldn’t be happier with service. If you have a training department he definitely is the one you need to have lead!! Need more customer service agents such as he, him, the one and only Eric!!!!
Reviewed June 18, 2025
They’re very good people to talk and give you a more detailed and know how to talk the person very respectful ways and they will give you accurate details. They are very polite and well known their job. I’m very grateful the way they helped me. It’s been very respectful. Given me more encouraging all the way to ending.

Reviewed May 6, 2025
If I could give this company no stars I would. I purchased a policy. A few months later the transmission went out on the vehicle. Took it to my local dealer and they filed the claim to have the transmission replaced. As expected, they sent out a third-party inspector/adjuster to inspect the claim. The adjuster denied the claim, claiming that the truck was driven to the dealer and not towed which caused further damage, so I in violation of the terms and conditions of the policy. I provided a receipt showing the truck was in fact towed and not driven. After a lot of back and forth with the claims department they told me it doesn't matter what proof I had. We are going with the third-party inspector recommendation. They are not to be trusted.
Hey Matt,
we thank you for writing this review to hopefully educate any other potential customers in your situation.
All companies in this industry do not cover pre existing conditions.
Your vehicle had a clear pre existing condition and continued use while it was broken down.
Reviewed April 23, 2025
Today on April 23 I took my 2017 into the dealership to get my two remotes replaced they have broken. When I bought my policy with Premier Auto Protect the lady told me that my remote would be covered if I had to have them replaced. This was a lie. after waiting for 2 1/2 hours at the dealership while they were being given the runaround by Premier auto protect, they been told the service guy that my remotes were not covered under my policy other than when my air conditioner was fixed, but they did pay for everything else has been denied no matter what it is
The next claim, nothing was called in or initiated. The only communication was on 4/23/2025, when the shop followed up on an estimate they had emailed to the wrong address—claims@protectionloyalty.com.
We informed them that this is not the correct email for claim submissions and reviewed the proper procedure. The repair facility responded that they would not be handling it and told the customer to seek reimbursement before ending the call.
So there was no claim to adjudicate in this situation
Reviewed April 15, 2025
Was assured several times this warranty was a bumper to bumper coverage, with exception of heated seats. Nothing ever said about the repairs are only covered by 50% and customer responsible for the remaining 50%. That is not a bumper to bumper warranty that I have ever purchased. Tried calling numbers provided, much to my dismay they do not reach anything other than a recording. Be cautious when purchasing from companies outside of a dealership.
Hello Tonya,
1st the plan you purchased was a bumper to bumper plan.
2nd due to your states rules and regulations it does operate differently than other states.
3rd Every time you called we answered and already processed a full refund for you as you requested.
So at this time you are not a customer but we wish you and your vehicle well.
Reviewed April 15, 2025
Just spoke with Joe at Premier. He was very friendly, polite, and professional. The policy is well priced and well below the cost of the dealer policy that I just canceled. Never buy a policy from a dealership, thanks Joe. Have fun with your new Willys and the tazer!
Reviewed April 15, 2025
Purchasing warranty coverage for my 2019 Range Rover was incredibly easy! Lance was extremely knowledgeable and answered all of my questions thoroughly. He even emailed me a copy of the warranty contract within minutes! Thank you, Lance, for putting my mind at ease and providing excellent warranty coverage for my vehicle.
Reviewed April 14, 2025
Joshua was very helpful and informative. I am very grateful to have coverage with this company. Thanks again for all that you all offer. I wish there were more companies that had great customer service like Josh does. I’m very big on customer service.
Reviewed April 13, 2025
Stanley was very helpful and was able to inform me on my coverage and get me a comparable price. I was searching for coverage to fit my price range and coverage to help me know that my vehicle would be protected.
Reviewed April 12, 2025
It was a good experience. Fast and helpful. I wish I would have asked more questions. It's no issue though. I called back and they answered right away. I prolly need to call them back and get more answers. We will see how it goes.
Reviewed April 12, 2025
Stan was very helpful and patient when purchasing my car warranty. He took the time to explain everything to me and also got me a great deal. I feel very comfortable with my purchase and would highly recommend Stan and Premier Auto Protect.
Reviewed April 12, 2025
Josh ** explained the plan, benefits and provided quote and answered my questions. He was patient, not pushy because I wanted to think about it. I appreciate that and that is why I called right back and am now a customer.
Reviewed April 11, 2025
Jacob ** is a pleasant and knowledgeable personality. He was able to help me with the price policy and understanding of the plan coverage. I hope to enjoy the peace of mind in our business relationship over the term of my coverage. Thank you.
Reviewed April 11, 2025
Alex was awesome, straightforward and knew I just wanted to purchase. No lengthy sales pitch, just the pertinent information that I was wanting! He was cordial and pleasant. I would definitely work with him again and love the warranty options that were given to me. I ultimately went for complete premium coverage.
Reviewed April 10, 2025
I tried two other companies while getting quotes and it was a nightmare!! However Ed with Premiere Auto was helpful and listened to what I needed vs pushing what he wanted!! Great experience. I would totally recommend Ed and Premiere Auto.
Reviewed April 9, 2025
Very knowledgeable rep. I appreciate how he answered my questions and concerns in regards to the plan I was offered. Thank you for your services. I don't like I have to wait 30 days when your taking my money upfront. I'm glad I had a rep that was knowledgeable about the services being offered to me.
Premier Auto Protect Company Information
- Company Name:
- Premier Auto Protect
- State/Province:
- NY
- Country:
- United States
- Website:
- premierautoprotect.com
