How Much Does It Cost to Replace an Ice Maker?

Ice maker replacement costs

Replacing an ice maker can cost from $75 to $660, depending on the model, with in-unit ice makers costing the least and freestanding (or stand-alone) units costing the most.

If you decide to call a refrigerator repair specialist, you can expect to pay $70 to $125 per hour for labor; for a plumber, budget for $50 to $200 per hour.

Ice maker replacement costs by type

Ice makers come in four primary models: stand-alone, in-freezer/in-refrigerator, built-in and portable/countertop. Stand-alone ice makers are usually more expensive than built-in units and can cost anywhere from $200 to $1,500, depending on the brand.

Built-in freezer or door units can cost around $250 to $600, but prices vary depending on your freezer type. Higher-quality refrigerators with more complex units and added features cost more to replace in parts and labor.

Some in-door and built-in models are interchangeable with certain brands, so you may be able to save money by finding a cheaper version of your ice maker.

Ice maker replacement costs by brand

The brand of ice maker you have will also determine how much it costs to replace your unit. The most common brands come from Whirlpool, GE, KitchenAid, Samsung, LG and Frigidaire. Purchasing an ice maker from a reputable brand may cost more upfront but can save you money over time in repair costs.

While the following ranges represent middle-of-the-pack averages, keep in mind that high-end models with modern technology can cost significantly more than straightforward units.

Ice maker repair costs

Depending on what part of your ice maker is broken, it may cost less to get a simple repair rather than a whole replacement. The cost will depend on the type of ice maker you have and which part of it is malfunctioning.

Repair costs by ice maker type

Just like replacement costs, the type of ice maker you have will affect how much it costs to repair. For example, countertop units are less costly than freestanding models since they typically have fewer parts.

Repair costs by part

Ice makers are composed of several parts, some of which are more expensive to repair or replace than others. Below, we break down the costs to repair or replace several common ice maker parts.

» READ MORE: Cost to repair a fridge

Can you DIY an ice maker repair or replacement?

If you want to save money on labor, you could possibly repair or replace your ice maker yourself.

DIY repairs

If your ice maker isn’t working right but isn’t very old, you might be able to fix it yourself. Most small repairs only take about an hour.

What you’ll need:

• Screwdriver
• Needle-nose pliers
• Towel

Steps:

1. Unplug the fridge and turn off the water supply.
2. Check for ice jams. Remove the ice bin and break up any clumps.
3. Clean or replace the water filter if it’s clogged or overdue.
4. Inspect the water line for kinks or leaks.
5. Replace the fill valve or motor module if the ice maker still doesn’t cycle properly.
6. Plug it back in and run a test cycle to see if it’s making ice again.

If you notice rust, corrosion or leaks inside the unit, it’s usually time to replace it instead of repairing.

DIY replacement

If your ice maker is old, rusty, or beyond repair, replacing it is simple and usually takes less than an hour.

What you’ll need:

• Screwdriver
• Needle-nose pliers

For in-freezer or in-door models:

1. Unplug the refrigerator and turn off the water supply.
2. Remove the old unit by unscrewing it and disconnecting the wiring harness and water line.
3. Attach the new unit, connecting the same wiring and water line.
4. Secure it with screws, turn the water back on and plug in the fridge.
5. Run a test cycle to check for leaks and ice production.

For stand-alone ice makers:

1. Unplug the old unit and empty any water or ice.
2. Set up the new one, plug it in and fill it with water.
3. Run a cycle to make sure it’s working properly.

What are the signs you need a new ice maker?

If your ice maker is over 10 years old, making loud noises, leaking or not making ice, it may be time for a new unit. Also, if you notice your ice maker has rust or corrosion, it might be a sign that the unit has an internal leak, and you may want to consider buying a new one. This can compromise and deposit rust particles into your ice cubes, making them unsafe to drink.

Before buying a new ice maker, double-check to make sure your refrigerator is running properly.

If your ice isn't freezing, it may be more than just your ice maker. This can indicate that your freezer may need repairs or the water filter is clogged.

Here are the most common warning signs that you need a new ice maker:

• It makes loud or unusual noises
• It leaks water or shows signs of moisture buildup
• It no longer produces ice or makes very little
• You notice rust, corrosion or discoloration inside the unit
• Ice cubes appear cloudy or contain rust particles

» COMPARE: Best freezer brands

Does your home warranty cover ice maker repair or replacement?

In many cases, home warranties don't cover in-door or in-freezer ice makers, but there are a few exceptions.

Most companies do cover freestanding ice makers and freezer units for normal wear and tear, such as faulty wiring, malfunctioning compressors and damaged water lines. This coverage is usually provided in the base plan or appliance package. If your claim is approved, you’ll only have to pay a service call fee ranging from $75 to $150 on average.

All home warranty companies have limitations and coverage caps. This means that your home warranty company will only cover the costs of repairs and replacements up to a specified amount, and then you are liable for the remaining fees. Always double-check your contract before filing a claim.

Bottom line

Ice makers can provide a refreshing drink and cool you down on a hot day, but breakdowns can leave you sweltering. In general, repairs cost less than replacement, but it depends on the ice maker type and the part that’s malfunctioning. If your ice maker is aging, corroded or leaking, it may be time for a new one.

If you don’t feel confident in doing the job yourself, you can expect to pay anywhere from $50 to $200 per hour for labor. You can also check your policy to see if your home warranty plan or manufacturer’s warranty can help cover repairs and replacements.