
Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey Reviews
About Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey
This profile has not been claimed by the company. See reviews below to learn more or submit your own review.
- Polite customer service representatives
- Access to a wide network of providers
- Good coverage options available
- Lengthy claims processing times
- Frequent claim denials
- Poor communication from the company
Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (1)
- (2)
- (3)
- (5)
- (89)
Popular Mentions
- 4,625,379 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Recent
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,625,379 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed June 26, 2024
Blue Cross Blue Shield was EXTREMELY difficult to obtain approval for services even though authorized by my doctors. To make matters worse when I left they continued to take money out of my account every month until I called them on it. So happy to be done with them -CHOOSE ANY OTHER INSURANCE!
Reviewed May 8, 2024
We pay $19,000 a year for the family plan plus have co-pays and $6000.00 deductible and they refuse to cover most prescriptions. Won’t cover my monthly allergy meds because I can buy them over the counter. I have asthma and was in respiratory failure twice from allergies to dust and chemicals, I NEED my allergy meds. I don’t care if I can buy them over the counter! Why should I have to pay $30 monthly when we pay $19,000 a year. They also won’t cover weightloss meds, I have back issues, bulging disc and I get spasms which are extremely painful since I gained weight from steroids, my knees are swelling and pop out from my weight. The more I do the more pain I’m in. Wouldn’t it make sense to cover the meds than to cover knee surgery or replacements, or physical therapy which I already did and it just makes it worse.
Reviewed May 6, 2024
I have Blue Cross Blue Shield Omnia and it has been nothing but stressful and time-consuming to find out any information from them. Their representatives do not understand basic vocabulary of health care and give you different information from each other. You cannot trust what they tell you. You need to call at least twice to make sure. When you ask to speak to a supervisor, you're put on hold and then when someone gets back to you there is a sudden horrible connection so you cannot hear them. Then, either no one calls you back or they call you back with a bad connection, so you cannot have the phone call or they bring you back to someone who is not a supervisor without making you aware that it is not a supervisor you are speaking with.
I was also locked out of my account, so I cannot find out information online. I tried to get this resolved but no one answers and when they finally call me back I am not available. I was even harassed by one of the representatives, who kept calling me back and even from different private numbers. I was able to get this stopped but no one followed up as they said they would. She is probably the one who blocked my account. Just ridiculous. This company should be shut down. We are paying for our insurance and trying to take care of our health. Calling this company could affect anyone's health negatively.

Reviewed April 11, 2024
This insurance provider is such a joke, but it's not funny it's just cruel. Would give them 0 stars if I could. After being jerked around during my entire time paying them for my coverage (a huge premium, by the way), the last straw was them charging me a deductible for testing that was ordered by a covered provider - a service that any reasonable person would expect to be subject to a copay.
It's all a trick. They pull the rug out from under you constantly, just so they can steal money from you. Unless you read the fine print every single week, you're going to get screwed over sooner or later, because they're constantly changing the parameters of your coverage without informing you in an honest way. Their service reps are rude and unhelpful. They should be ashamed of themselves for working for such an abjectly inhumane company. I will be finding different insurance as soon as I possibly can. I would advise anyone else to stay far away from Horizon.
Reviewed April 3, 2024
I tried to do a 0 star rating but I wasn't allowed. I am absolutely appalled by the insensitive computer like customer service this company hires. I am impressed at their lack of accountability and eagerness to blame everything on the consumer locking you into owing them more money. More context: I adjusted my income in December to increase my monthly payments appropriately to reflect. I noticed I was not appropriately billed nor have I received my dental insurance card. I called today to figure out what the heck was going on. The first man was alright but sent me to escalations because he couldn't help me more than saying I am correct and their system mischarged me.
Once with escalations that woman was absolutely horrific. She first picks up and says yeah hello I understand you have a problem and can't make your overdue payment. I said, "Uh no that's not what happened, I called because I noticed I was under charged and wanted to see if I could have anything credited onto my account for your mistake and to see why I didn't get my dental insurance card."
First she told me I never paid for health insurance so they disabled it... When it's autopay. And then after much back and forth even with NJ marketplace people on 3 way call, yep nothing I can do. Because of their error I owe them over 800 and I pay it next month or my account is terminated also I have to pay for dental since January in order to reinstate the policy. I can not wait until next open enrollment so that I can leave this corrupt organization that doesn't cover most of my needs anyway when I just got the dentist twice yearly for cleanings and an MD for a physical and annual bw. What a disgrace. Do NOT sign up for Horizon
Reviewed March 21, 2024
I cannot stand these guys. Every time I call to check if something is covered, I get a different answer. I used their website to find an "Inner Circle Prime" provider and ended up with a huge bill. Insurance rep says the provider is not covered. Billing department for the provider says they're "Tier 1." Contested the bill and got no help. It is nearly impossible to trust them at all. I called about getting a test covered. The first person says it's covered. The second person says it's not covered. The third person says it might be covered if my doctor fills out a pre-determination form. THIS IS FOR STANDARD PRACTICE CARE! I called the lab and they said it would be $3000 out of pocket, $500 if the insurance covers it, and $300 if the insurance denies it. Also it could be $0 because they're not sure, and these are just estimates. I FEEL LIKE I AM TAKING CRAZY PILLS!

Reviewed Feb. 16, 2024
1/23 I made a payment on my Horizon portal to pay for health insurance for month of February. It is now 2/16 (almost 4 weeks) and they still have not updated my portal although I have spoke to MANY representatives over the matter (at least three people). I was told it will not be fixed for another week (2/23) ridiculous. Made me doubt my payment went through. Also - I like to pay for month before about 2 weeks on advance (if I can). Problems with the billing and portal has been very out of sync and going on for over a year now.
Also- I need an AED because I have a life-threatening illness (VT) and my insurance company declined the AED stating its "investigational" and "experimental". Are you kidding me!?!?!? My doctor wrote you guys a letter stating I needed it because with VT I'm at increased risk for more significant detrimental outcome including death!! I'm sure if the shoe was on their foot they'd approve themselves in a heartbeat, if their lives depended on it!!!! Veryyyy disheartening and disgusting.
Reviewed Jan. 6, 2024
Don't know where to begin. Almost every time I want to log into my online account, it has been locked down and I have to call the hotline (which is only open during the week, during work hours). Last time I was told I have to log in once a month or my account gets locked down which I've never heard before and, if true, is frankly ridiculous.
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2023
I have been trying to select a PCP for 6 weeks. Horizon does not require me to do this but the doctor's office does. I have called four times and each time the representative assures me the system will be updated in 48 hours. I have even gone on to the website personally to select the PCP and received confirmation that it would take 48 hours. At this point in time the system is still not updated. I estimate I have spent a combined 3 and 1/2 hours between phone calls and navigating the website.
Today I tried a live chatting and was transferred to five different Representatives, none of which resolved my issue. The irony is that while being on hold I get to listen to Horizons pre-recorded message on tips to deal with stress. I also find it amazing that the vast majority of people I spoke with or chatted with seemed to be reading from a script. For example, I would chat about my issue and then be told that perhaps I should try calling member services or go online after I noted that I'd done these things repeatedly! It was so discouraging that I actually wonder if I'm chatting with bots.
Reviewed Oct. 30, 2023
While a member, my doctor's office always had to call them because their automated system is filled with mistakes. After cancelling my policy and getting paper mail confirmation, I received an email a week later saying I would be billed for the next month. Calling the number in the email, the number on my old card, or several other Horizon BCBS numbers on Google all resulted in being redirected to a "Medical Alert Center" which tried to sell me the "I've fallen and I can't get up" device. Despite an hour of trying, I was unable to reach a human associated with Horizon BCBS. If they continue to charge, I will simply report any such charges as fraud. This company is terrible.
Reviewed Aug. 8, 2023
The incompetence of their customer service dept. Is unmatched. When you finally get someone they are no help. I could not pay online so I spoke to someone and she tried 7 times and two different cards and claimed something was wrong with the card. when I told her my card works fine it was on her end she ran it again and it miraculously worked. When I asked why it wouldn’t work before she asked me to hold for survey. I asked again and she hung up. My card arrived two months later. They used the same member ID for dental and health therefore my insurance was canceled. My doctors could not submit because dental and health were same. It has been a nightmare for the last 3 months dealing with them.
Reviewed Aug. 6, 2023
Good plan if you are heathy and don't need it. But if you are sick it takes 1 hour to enter your info over the phone just to hear automated voice telling you they are not available. Portal doesn't work. It takes too long to find a doctor. Absurd beyond belief. Wasted money. Terrible service.
Reviewed June 24, 2023
I am neglected and stressed every day, by my own, Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, healthcare insurer! I have no more medication for my Multiple Sclerosis (MS)-related fatigue, thanks to my mega Horizon, stiffing me. Horizon and I were friends for years, as it consistently paid for my necessary, energy-boosting ** drug. I got ** through my Horizon NJ Health Medicaid healthcare program. Until May 1st, when I needed a new, dual, Medicare-Medicaid program.
I turned again to Horizon, which offers its Horizon NJ Total Care HMO D-SNP. It should be perfect for me, since Horizon sales agents and literature, say it conveniently provides my Medicare and Medicaid benefits, in one plan, with no out-of-pocket costs for me! But, nah. Horizon decided it wouldn't do crap for ME, as Horizon let my ** run out, instead of swiftly renewing it last month! I am so groggy now. But I manage to talk to Horizon agents who give doctors and me, daily runarounds, while not doing their job of renewing my ** prescription.
And my grogginess and no **, are not my only problems with Horizon, my ex-friend! My filthy rich, former friend, isn't paying all of my doctors and behavioral therapists. Those same health providers who Horizon paid when I had Horizon NJ Health, now mail ME some of their bills! And when I call Horizon, their agents say they'll research my unpaid bills, and will get back to me in 30 days.
Yeah, right! It's June 23rd now. And I ain't seen one, sensible Horizon resolution statement about bills being paid. So, if you are shopping for a good health insurance plan, I unfortunately, no longer recommend Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey! I would like to think that I am the only customer this company is dumping on. But that's unlikely. Horizon is a greatly experienced, huge, well-oiled, insurance machine. So, I know this is not the FIRST time that Horizon has stomped on its members, including - on me!
Reviewed June 16, 2023
We applied for coverage for our employees through Horizon Blue Cross. We didn't get any communication from them until suddenly we were informed that our coverage was being cancelled for non-payment. Turns out, they had completely ignored the mailing address on our application and were sending documents to an incorrect address the whole time. No one had their insurance cards, no one knew what was going on. Yet somehow they were able to get ahold of us to let us know they were cancelling the policy.
Well, we worked out immediate payment to keep the account current, and when I found out that they had the wrong address, I brought it to their attention. Their answer? "We only communicate through the mail" even though they actually confirmed on the phone that they had the wrong address on file, AND that they had the correct address on the application! Okay, so they won't communicate except through the mail, but they can't reach us by mail. Incompetent.
We finally got that straightened out, then they back-charged a new employee addition by two months even though they never sent her a card or any indication that her coverage had been started. When I went to ask what the "adjustment" was on the one bill that their website conveniently had errors in loading, I was told by their call center "We can't tell you what's on the bill." They went through all of the verification questions to ensure I wasn't just some random person. I'm the plan administrator. Yet, they still couldn't tell me what was on the bill that their website was having an error displaying? I have had nothing but problems with this company. God forbid someone actually calls in with a claim. I can only imagine the infuriating process that must be. I would not trust their call center staff to successfully navigate putting on eyeglasses in the right direction.
Reviewed Sept. 11, 2022
I would just like to inform everyone to never ever go with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, or just Blue Cross Blue Shield in general for anything. They have no heart and do not care about anyone but themselves. Patients are just a number to them and even when you fight so hard again and again and again to get approved of a surgery that could change my life because medication alone hasn’t been helping for over 10 years.
I was diagnosed with having “Drug Resistant Epilepsy” so medication alone is not the answer. I have tried this for, as mentioned, for 10 years. I want a life worth living. A life where I can live a so called “semi-normal” life. Without this surgery I will constantly hurt myself because I cannot control these seizures I’m having everyday! And I’m not talking about just one, I’m talking about multiple so I’m getting a lawyer involved. If I could give them 0 stars I would because this is beyond ridiculous what I’ve had to go through these past few months. This was a set in stone procedure that was approved in April to be done back in June 2022 but 15 hours beforehand Blue Cross decided I was not approved anymore and it’s now September 2022 and they are still saying no. As mentioned I’m getting a lawyer because I have hurt myself too many times and enough is enough!
Reviewed July 21, 2022
God help you if they make a mistake processing a claim. It was like living in a bad episode of the Three Stooges. Over 10 months into the initial claim I (not them) am close to having it resolved. Take notes and names w/ every phone call you have to make. Pretty sure they're not allowed to speak to each other out loud with words and are required to communicate via email. Not sure if they are actually typing emails or tapping their fingers on their desks to make it sound as such. Seems like once the emails were "sent", they vaporized. The person in the complaints department was to email me information, that never happened and then we were ghosted. I was disappointed. We'd had this insurance for years without issue. A conference call with an actual human in charge could have solved our issue months ago. But apparently they don't do that.
Reviewed July 1, 2022
The customer is always right yet when NJ Direct for Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield is asked to have checks correctly payable to individual providers, they make excuses instead of re-issuing checks appropriately. They combine providers and patients which mixes up the business and is extra work to get processed. When contacting customer service multiple times about the issues, they get defensive instead and don't fix the problems. Their laziness (instead of organization of what they get paid to do) is what causes bad review.
Reviewed May 1, 2022
For many years I had the Silver Advantage Plan paying over $1k per month for single coverage. Fortunately, I hardly used the insurance. When Pandemic hit my business went down so I looked into lower-cost insurance using "Get Covered NJ", the representative told me the Horizon BCBS "Omnia Silver plan was just as good" and didn't explain about the tier 1 & 2. I specifically asked if I could go to better doctors in Philadelphia and was told yes, but wasn't told this would be considered tier 2 and I would have to pay for everything! Doctors visit $300, 10 min test $2,000!! They wouldn't pay the $370 blood work because it was ordered by a tier 2 doctor, even though I had this lab work done at Labcorp in NJ by my home. If you want health insurance that does NOT pay for anything then the Omnia plan is for you!
Reviewed Aug. 26, 2021
Since I started working in 2005 I have used this insurance company. They provide me with all the information and care that I need to ensure my health is on point. They have a great network of doctors and specialists. This company is always ranked number one for me.
Reviewed Nov. 21, 2020
They were really slow initially in sending us our insurance cards. They did however mail us our cards after constant pestering. They are also slow in processing claims. They are, otherwise okay. They have good coverage of doctors, for both primary care and specialists.
Reviewed Oct. 16, 2020
I cancelled your coverage after the first month of enrollment yet I am still receiving bills. A health care insurance provider should have representatives available 24/7. Not Horizon Blue Cross. I have notified them of my cancellation three months ago yet still receiving bills. It's obvious that your your representatives are not only unavailable but illiterate. If my balance is not deleted I will seek legal action for fraudulent billing!
Reviewed Jan. 6, 2020
A retiree in NJ and was forced to switch over to BCBS of NJ from Aetna. Need to get to doctor in second week of January. Informed several months ago of switch to comparable plan I had with Aenta. Never received a new card or patient ID card/number. So I try to get on portal and it's telling me I have to register as a new subscriber which I understand. However the link to it WILL NOT LOAD after hours of waiting. Called number given and of course "Call volume higher than expected". Here we go. What a joke.
Our NJ politicians and this company are in bed together. They had MONTHS to figure this out. If I can't even get a card or member number, how the hell are they gonna take care of me and my health? There is no email to make a complaint UNLESS you are a REGISTERED MEMBER. HHAHAHA...no registered members-no complaints I guess. Can't even message them on Facebook. What a joke of a company. I never liked them before and when I HAD A CHOICE of insurance I stayed away. I see they they haven't improved customer service, only their bottom line.
Reviewed Oct. 20, 2019
Blue Cross and "Bait and Switch" Health Insurance. I purchased the silver with a 50% out-of-Network only to find out months later there was no out of Network covered. I spent way over my deductible without any medical bills being paid by BCBS. When I called, I was told, "We don't guarantee we cover any of your medical. Paying your bill every month only guarantees we'll keep your account open." I could not believe what I was told while every out over $4,000 of paid insurance and out of pocket over $10,000. What a racket! I spoke to other people who had BCBS and they had similar stories. Blue Cross Blue Shield needs to be shut down and investigated and there should be refunds.
Reviewed May 3, 2019
I am so mad that every time I call on my own claims they tell me I cannot because the insurance in my wife’s name even though she has given the insurance the authorization to do so. Their member services are by far the worst I have ever dealt with. Zero stars????
Reviewed April 16, 2019
I am a state worker and even though everyone thinks we have the best plans with the best coverage, I beg to differ. We were recently forced into Horizon. I use to have Aetna which I’ve now learned was so much easier to deal with. I receive one round of Orthovisc knee injections per year. When I had Aetna the process was seamless. My doctor's office would request the medication, Aetna would deliver it, and the doctor’s office would call me when it arrives in to schedule my appointments. My doctor requested this medication in February and it is now April and still no medication.
Blue Cross uses a slew of different pharmacies for different meds to make things cheaper. It took two months for me and my doctor's office to figure out which pharmacy is filling this prescription. I’ve probably called the insurance company 5xs in the past two months and been on the phone at least a half hour to forty minutes each call. This is unacceptable when you are paying top dollar for an insurance plan. I’d take my Aetna plan back in a heartbeat. Blue Cross needs to get better management/training in their various offices and stop trying to cut corners.
Reviewed March 27, 2019
Any plan can be improved. I have a federal government plan, which is different from the regular Blue Cross Blue Shield plan. I’ve been told the federal plan is the best plan out there by other companies where I have inquired.
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2019
Signing up with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey will cost you big in the years to come. They offer competitive rates when you are initially signing up, everyone is familiar with them and they seem like a good choice... Don't be fooled. When you turn 70 your premium will take a huge jump, beyond normal yearly increases. This is because their premiums are Age Rated. Most Medigap plans are Community Rated. What this means in plain English is that every 5 years from age 65 your premium will increase dramatically... 1st increase at age 70 was $75.00 per month for my husband, plus yearly increase. Be careful how long you live.
If that's not bad enough, new this year, 2019, the age increase is automatically given a nonpreferred rate. In order to get the preferred rate you must pass underwriting questions, which many are not able to pass. Perhaps the worst is that they lie by omission. You are not told about their outrageous increases when you sign up. They also will tell you that all the Medigap Plans are age rated. This is false, they may be the only one to do this. They found a loophole. They also lie and say that their new Preferred/non Preferred rates are the same as other insurers. Again, this is not true. Choose wisely. I switched my policy to AARP/Universal because they are honest, forthright and were shocked when I told them what Horizon is doing.
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2019
If I could give negative stars I would. This could be a total fraud company, nothing is OK and I know the plans are not inexpensive. I am begging our HR to change providers. Horizon has been the worst insurance experience ever and I've had to go through NY State plans which are not the best to deal with. 2 doctors prescribing the same medication I've been taking for YEARS and never had an issue with submitted prior authorizations MANY times. When pharmacy tries to fill, they are told Dr needs to submit PA which they have over and over again. They try to call but cannot get anyone on the phone for hours - both doctors think it is a rouse to make a person give up so this company does not need to cover anything. I agree. This company is completely horrible.
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2019
I was a member of a group insured by Horizon. They said the group did not qualify for coverage any longer and canceled the group. I was told that if I enrolled in an individual plan with them, that the out of pocket expenses, that I incurred would transfer over to my new coverage. After a bout with pneumonia in the emergency room, they informed me that I had to transfer those expenses, only from one group to another group. And that I would have to start a new deductible, all over again. Nowhere in the handbook, is this spoken about. I was taken advantage of by a big company, with no chance of fighting this.
Reviewed April 18, 2018
Absolutely horrible. It takes an hour on the phone to get ANYTHING done. They randomly added two of my adult kids to my policy, then cancelled me when I "didn't pay" (since I didn't realize my premium changed due to the addition of my kids - who have their own insurance and haven't been on my policy for several years!!!) They had my wife's birthday wrong, when she called to fix it, then changed my birthday to match hers - which screwed up my prescription coverage and eliminated my online access. Then they told me it would take 30 days to put my birthday back to the correct date. Many other issues and problems, every one takes hours of precious time. Their overseas based call center is useless - don't waste your time, demand that your concern be "escalated" so they bring the call back to U.S.
Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey Company Information
- Company Name:
- Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey
- Website:
- www.horizonblue.com