Best home warranty companies of 2026

Don't wait for the repair bill. Compare home warranty plans first.

HVAC failure. Plumbing leak. Dead refrigerator. Repairs don't wait for a good time. See which of our 7 top-rated companies cover your home and what they charge.

7companies compared
142K+verified reviews of these 7 companies
$24.99lowest starting monthly price of our picks

Written by Amanda Futrell, edited by Kathryn Parkman, fact-checked by Jon Bortin. Updated Oct. 2, 2026.

Compare plans near you

Enter your ZIP to see providers that serve your area.

  • Compare 7 companies side by side
  • Ratings from verified reviews
  • Fees, coverage details and availability up front

A home warranty is a service contract, not homeowners insurance. ConsumerAffairs is not a government agency and may be paid by the companies we match you with.

ConsumerAffairs is not a government agency and may be paid by the companies we match you with. Compensation may influence which companies we feature and the order they appear in, but it does not affect our editors’ advice. A blue check mark identifies a ConsumerAffairs Authorized Partner. How we choose.

The best home warranty companies: Our top 7 picks

Each of these top home warranty companies leads in one area. Ratings come from verified ConsumerAffairs reviews, and prices are starting prices that change with your location, plan and service fee.

Searching for a specific company? Jump to Old Republic or American Home Shield.

American Home Shield logo

American Home Shield

Best coverage variety

3.6(112,063)

AHS offers the widest set of plan options and customizations at a reasonable starting price. Its app makes claims easy to file and lets you video chat with a home repair expert.

Starts at
$29.99/mo
Service fee
$100 or $125
Labor guarantee
30 days
Available in
48 states (not Alaska or Hawaii)

What we like

  • Customizable plans
  • AARP and military service discounts
  • Cancel at any time
  • $50 discount for covering multiple properties

Watch for

  • Some customer service issues
  • Occasional service delays
  • Rates may increase over time

What reviewers say. Online claims get good marks. Slow follow-up, thin communication and unresolved or denied claims are the usual complaints.

“I’m happy with American Home Shield.”
Mohd, Woodbridge, VA, ConsumerAffairs reviewer
HomeSafe logo

HomeSafe

Best claims handling

4.3(809)

Reviewers consistently praise HomeSafe's claims process, and it is the one pick that lets you choose your own technician. You can also file a claim after 25 days instead of the usual 30.

Starts at
$69/mo
Service fee
$65
Labor guarantee
60 days
Available in
49 states (not California)

What we like

  • Choose your own service technician
  • Short waiting period
  • No annual price increases with continued coverage
  • Customizable coverage

Watch for

  • Limited price transparency
  • Not available in California

What reviewers say. Claims are easy to start and usually resolved quickly. A few reviewers hit mixed contractor quality or limited choice on replacement appliances.

“They have never hesitated to file a claim or pay the claim.”
Bradley, Brainerd, MN, ConsumerAffairs reviewer
First American Home Warranty logo

First American Home Warranty

Best roof coverage

4.1(9,150)

Its roof leak coverage applies to more roofing materials than most, including tile, slate, wood shake and tar-and-gravel. It covers nonstructural leaks only, and it is an add-on.

Starts at
$33/mo
Service fee
$100 or $125
Labor guarantee
30 days
Available in
35 states

What we like

  • Low starting costs and service fees
  • No age limit on appliances
  • Month-to-month contracts
  • Lower premiums if you pay annually

Watch for

  • Occasional delays
  • Some customer service complaints
  • Somewhat limited availability

What reviewers say. Claims are simple to file and technicians come across as professional. Some reviewers mention communication gaps or needing more than one visit.

“The claim process has been fairly easy.”
Michele, Greeley, CO, ConsumerAffairs reviewer
ARW Home logo

ARW Home

Best technicians

4.4(3,041)

ARW scored high for technician satisfaction and claims handling. It also protects against everyday mishaps like spills, drops and cracked screens, which matters if you keep pricey electronics at home.

Starts at
$39.99/mo
Service fee
$125
Labor guarantee
30 days
Available in
50 states

What we like

  • Covers systems and appliances regardless of age or model
  • No limit on the number of claims
  • Covers condos and multifamily homes
  • Available nationwide

Watch for

  • Additional fees may apply
  • Doesn't cover the cost of maintenance
  • No add-ons for appliances

What reviewers say. Friendly service and easy claims earn praise. Some people waited on a technician or a reimbursement check.

“ARW’s rates are fair and they get a tech out fast.”
Nicole, Houston, TX, ConsumerAffairs reviewer
Liberty Home Guard logo

Liberty Home Guard

Best for quick service

4.6(2,075)

Liberty has the highest customer rating of our seven picks. Reviewers say they were connected with a technician quickly, and a licensed tech is dispatched within 24 to 48 hours.

Starts at
$49.99/mo
Service fee
$65 to $125
Labor guarantee
365-day workmanship warranty
Available in
50 states

What we like

  • No inspection required
  • Flexible terms, including month-to-month
  • Technician dispatched in 24 to 48 hours
  • Available nationwide

Watch for

  • Can't always choose your own technician
  • 30-day waiting period

What reviewers say. Claims start easily and support is responsive. The main gripe is slow resolution that takes repeated follow-ups.

“I file my claims on the app and it’s good to go.”
Aaron, Perris, CA, ConsumerAffairs reviewer
Old Republic Home Warranty logo

Old Republic Home Warranty

Best value

3.7(2,460)

Old Republic pairs some of the most comprehensive coverage on the market with a reasonable price, flexible service fees and generous coverage caps. Check that it's offered where you live.

Why it’s our best-value pick. Value isn’t only the monthly price. Old Republic’s strengths are comprehensive coverage, flexible service fees and generous coverage caps.

Starts at
$50/mo
Service fee
$100 or $125
Labor guarantee
30 days
Available in
25 states and Washington, D.C.

What we like

  • Customizable coverage
  • Clear pricing
  • Discounts for new customers
  • Seasonal promotions

Watch for

  • Some communication issues
  • No guarantee of coverage if you choose your own contractor
  • Somewhat limited availability

What reviewers say. Some reviewers report communication problems.

“The response time has been nice and the customer care has been outstanding…”
Janice, Blue Springs, MO, ConsumerAffairs reviewer

Ratings & prices current as of .

Side-by-side comparison

Scan fees, guarantees and availability in one place. Scroll sideways on mobile.

CompanyOur pick forCustomer ratingStarting monthly costService feeLabor guaranteeAvailable in
Cinch Home Services Best overall 4.1 (12,687) $24.99 $100, $125 or $150 180 days 48 states (not Alaska or Hawaii)
American Home Shield Best coverage variety 3.6 (112,063) $29.99 $100 or $125 30 days 48 states (not Alaska or Hawaii)
HomeSafe Best claims handling 4.3 (809) $69 $65 60 days 49 states (not California)
First American Home Warranty Best roof coverage 4.1 (9,150) $33 $100 or $125 30 days 35 states
ARW Home Best technicians 4.4 (3,041) $39.99 $125 30 days 50 states
Liberty Home Guard Best for quick service 4.6 (2,075) $49.99 $65 to $125 365-day workmanship warranty 50 states
Old Republic Home Warranty Best value 3.7 (2,460) $50 $100 or $125 30 days 25 states and Washington, D.C.

Monthly costs are starting prices. Your quote will depend on where you live and the plan and service fee you choose.

Are home warranties worth it?

Sometimes. A plan costs money every month whether or not anything breaks, and every visit has a service fee. It pays off when the repairs you avoid cost more than what you put in.

It tends to make sense if

  • Your appliances or HVAC are older and likelier to fail.
  • A big repair bill would strain your budget.
  • You're buying or selling and want coverage in the deal.
  • You'd rather have one company handle repairs than hunt for a contractor.

It may not be worth it if

  • Most of your appliances are new or still under manufacturer warranty.
  • You have savings set aside for repairs.
  • Your biggest worries, such as the roof or structure, are excluded or capped.
Read the limits before you buy. Plans cap what they'll pay per item and per contract term, and denied claims show up among reviewers' complaints. Check a plan's limits and exclusions, and confirm that the thing you're worried about is actually covered.

Run your own numbers

Compare a year of plan costs with paying for repairs yourself.

Plan price for 12 months$0
Service fees$0
Total with a plan$0
Total paying yourself$0

Prices are starting prices from our guide and vary by location. This assumes every claim is approved and falls within your plan's coverage limits. Repair costs are your own estimate.

How much does a home warranty cost?

Among our picks, plans start between $24.99 and $69 a month, and each repair visit carries a service fee.

$24.99 to $69Starting monthly cost
$65 to $150Service fee per visit
  • Plan type. Systems, appliance and combo plans cover different things and cost different amounts.
  • Service fee. Most companies charge less each month if you accept a higher fee per visit.
  • Where you live. Quotes change by location, and not every company serves every state.

Starting monthly cost by company

  • Cinch Home Services$24.99
  • American Home Shield$29.99
  • First American$33
  • ARW Home$39.99
  • Liberty Home Guard$49.99
  • Old Republic$50
  • HomeSafe$69

Each bar shows a company's lowest starting price before location and service-fee adjustments. Cheaper isn't always better: compare coverage limits and reviews too.

What do home warranties cover?

Plans come as systems-only, appliance-only (sometimes called appliance protection plans) or combo plans. What's included depends on the plan you pick.

Home systems

Usually in systems and combo plans

  • Air conditioning and heating
  • Plumbing and plumbing stoppages
  • Electrical
  • Ductwork
  • Water heaters

Appliances

Usually in appliance and combo plans

  • Refrigerators and dishwashers
  • Ovens, ranges and cooktops
  • Built-in microwaves
  • Washers and dryers
  • Garbage disposals

Often an add-on

Extra cost and lower limits

  • Roof leak repair
  • Pools and spas
  • Well pumps
  • Septic systems

Plans differ more than names suggest. American Home Shield's ShieldSilver plan leaves out washers and dryers, but ShieldGold includes them. HomeSafe's Appliances plan doesn't cover AC or heating.

Tune-ups are rare. Of our picks, only American Home Shield's ShieldPlatinum and First American's Premium plan include HVAC tune-ups.

Match a company to your situation

Start with what matters most to you, then check each company's coverage limits and availability.

I want to cancel or stay month-to-month

I'm a senior or on a fixed income

I want to pick my own technician

I need roof leak coverage

I'm buying or selling a home

I want the fastest repairs

Not sure it's offered in your state? Cinch is in 48 states, and ARW and Liberty list all 50. HomeSafe isn't available in California, and Old Republic is limited to 25 states and Washington, D.C.

What verified reviewers say

Every company gets praise and complaints. Here is the pattern for our top three.

Cinch Home Services

4.1(12,687 reviews)

Reviewers like

Simple claim filing and fast technician dispatch.

Reviewers complain about

Delays, denied claims and vague communication.

American Home Shield

3.6(112,063 reviews)

Reviewers like

A user-friendly online claims process and quick repairs.

Reviewers complain about

Slow follow-up, thin communication and unresolved or denied claims.

HomeSafe

4.3(809 reviews)

Reviewers like

Easy claims that are usually resolved quickly.

Reviewers complain about

Mixed contractor quality and limited choice on replacement appliances.

Home warranty questions, answered

Are home warranties worth it?

It depends on how old your appliances and systems are, how much a surprise repair would strain your budget, and how many claims you expect to file. You pay every month and a service fee on every visit, and plans cap what they'll pay. Use the calculator above to test your own numbers.

How much does a home warranty cost?

Among our picks, plans start between $24.99 and $69 a month. Service fees run from $65 to $150 per visit. Your price depends on your location, the plan you choose and the service fee. A lower service fee usually means a higher monthly price.

What's the difference between a home warranty and homeowners insurance?

Homeowners insurance generally covers damage from events such as fire, storms or theft. A home warranty is a service contract that covers repairs or replacement when covered appliances and systems wear out from normal use.

How soon can I file a claim?

Most companies require a 30-day waiting period after you buy. HomeSafe's is 25 days.

Do home warranties cover preexisting conditions?

It varies by company, so read the contract before you sign. Of our picks, Cinch Home Services covers unknown preexisting conditions.

Can I choose my own contractor?

Usually not. The company sends one of its network technicians. HomeSafe lets you choose your own. With Old Republic, choosing your own contractor means coverage isn't guaranteed.

What if my claim is denied?

Denied claims are among the complaints reviewers mention. Ask for the reason in writing, then check your contract's exclusions and coverage limits. Knowing the caps before you buy helps you avoid surprises.

Can I cancel?

It depends on the company. American Home Shield lets you cancel at any time, and First American and Liberty Home Guard offer month-to-month terms. Check the cancellation terms for any plan before you buy.

How we choose

What we looked at

The ConsumerAffairs Research Team evaluated home warranty companies using verified customer reviews, pricing, coverage and plan features. We focused on what matters most to homeowners: reliable service, fair claims handling and useful coverage.

Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say. Our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us, but our publishing policy says that doesn't affect our recommendations or evaluations.

Why trust our reviews

  • More than 142,000 reviews of these seven companies on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to confirm reviewers are real.
  • Software helps us protect the integrity of reviews.
  • Moderators read every review for quality and helpfulness.

Don't gamble on your next repair. Compare plans today.

Enter your ZIP code to see which companies to check first. We compare 7 companies on price, coverage and verified reviews.

A home warranty is a service contract, not homeowners insurance. ConsumerAffairs is not a government agency and may be paid by the companies we match you with. Prices, fees and availability can change, so confirm details with the company before you buy.

Find my plan