American Home Guardian
Overall Satisfaction Rating
  • 5 stars
  • 4 stars
  • 3 stars
  • 2 stars
  • 1 stars
Based on 14 reviews that contain star ratingsSHOW RATING DISTRIBUTION
Looking for a home warranty company?

    American Home Guardian

    ConsumerAffairs Unaccredited Brand

    This company is not yet accredited. To learn more, see reviews below or submit your own. Want to know more about ConsumerAffairs accredited brands? Check out ConsumerAffairs for Brands.

    Be in the know

    Get trending consumer news and recalls


    Keep an eye on your inbox, the lastest consumer news is on it's way!

    16 American Home Guardian Consumer Reviews and Complaints

    Filter by: Any
    profile pic of the author
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: June 11, 2018

    I called for a service of my HVAC because the unit was not cooling properly. The AC tech showed up to my house and determined that the unit has other issues with it. We determined after a thorough investigation that the coils in my AC unit were faulty and not allowing proper circulation within the unit, thus creating the pipes to freeze. Tech told me that he would need to get authorization from AHG to fix the issue because the cost could be in excess of $600 to repair and doesn't have authorization from AHG to perform that amount of work. I understand the checks and balances but there needs to be someone on call to answer these questions and concerns any time a contractor calls into the service center.

    I am disappointed with this service because it is summer in Texas and today's high was 95 degrees. I have a 6 month old baby that is very irritable and fussy because of the temperature in the house. Thus resulting in a heat related visit to the urgent care that evening. Waiting now until Monday to address this issue one way or the other is an unacceptable use of my warranty. At the end of the day, AHG told me that my unit was not covered under my contract. These guys know how to avoid paying for anything. This is my second service call with them and both times it has been a nightmare. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!

    View more
    Be the first one to find this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
    Original review: May 11, 2018

    Run as fast as you can from American Home Guardian, Inc. All this company wants is your money and knows all the tricks to get out of providing anything in return. I have never dealt with a more dishonest company in my life. When I tried to order my HVAC seasonal check up, I was told to call back the following month. I called back the following month and was told that I did not have a signed contract. At this point, I was so frustrated that I couldn't get service on something that wasn't broke and could only imagine how difficult it would be IF something actually needed to be fixed.

    Since their representative told me I didn't have a signed contract and I had never received any services, I opted to request a refund and not deal with this shady company. I sent a certified letter requesting a full refund. There was absolutely no communication from AHG. Instead of refunding the $540 paid, they sent $139.44 which was totally unacceptable. I returned the check certified mail requesting a full refund or to honor the remainder of the contract. That was two months ago. I called AHG yesterday and was advised that I have no home warranty and they have ALL my money!!!

    View more
    Be the first one to find this review helpful
    Not sure how to choose?

    Get expert buying tips about Home Warranties, Service Plans delivered to your inbox.

    Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter!Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
    We value your privacy. Unsubscribe easily.
    Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
    Original review: Jan. 9, 2018

    I called to report a malfunctioning appliance over a week ago. I have called 3 times and just get a promise that someone will contact me the next day. So far nothing. This is not what was promised in writing and verbally when they wanted a contract! Very unprofessional behavior by claims people.

    Be the first one to find this review helpful
    profile pic of the author
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Aug. 8, 2017

    My air conditioner went out on a Friday early afternoon in 115 degree heat. After reporting the problem I wasn't hearing back from anyone. Who knew they shut down for the weekend at 5? I called back and got an answering service. They told me I could look online to see the status of my claim. I did and found that they had assigned a contractor to my claim. I then called them to find out when they would be coming out and found out they did not even service my area. Even if they did they could not get out there until Thursday. 6 days later! Unbelievable.

    I called back to say this was an emergency and something had to be done. I was told to call a repair service myself and I would get reimbursed. I found someone to come out the next day but due to the fact that it was a Saturday it would cost more money. It was expensive but I had no choice. I filed a claim for reimbursement and per the contract they paid me $77. Parts and Labor. Are you kidding me? What a joke. Do not do business with this company.

    View more
    2 people found this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Aug. 7, 2017

    We have been AHG customers for over five years and never had a major claim until last week when the AC died. They sent out a tech -- a day and a half after we called -- despite their contractual commitment to 24 hours for cooling (we live in Texas). The tech determined that the compressor was dead and said he would have his "supervisor" contact me to discuss the options. What I got was a call from the sales department who wanted to sell me a new AC system.

    I contacted AHG and asked what they were going to do. They told me that they hadn't received the report from the AC company. So I called the AC company and they said they were "working on it". Finally, six days with no AC in the Texas summer, I got a response from AHG. Their solution was unacceptable and I had to settle for a paltry payout. When they tell you that they will prevent major expense for an AC failure, they are lying. Moreover, they have no sense of urgency. They left two 70+ years old people without AC for nearly a week in the Texas summer! Now I have to write them a letter to cancel. If you want to buy a warranty, choose someone else.

    View more
    4 people found this review helpful
    How do I know I can trust these reviews about American Home Guardian?
    • 1,138,936 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

    For more information about reviews on please visit our FAQ.

    Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
    Original review: March 18, 2017

    My garage door would not open. I called AHG who sent a tech out to repair it. He disconnected the electrical cord, replaced it and the door worked for two days. I went to take my wife to work morning of the third day. Same problem. I disconnected and reconnected. It worked, day five again the same problem. I called AHG. Have not heard from them. Contract states I have 90 days to not have the same problem or they will send another tech without additional charge. If this is the way I get treated over an item that cost less than $200 what would they do if it was an A/C. I am done. Just need to figure how to cancel auto pay so I can move to a company that is worthy of my business.

    5 people found this review helpful
    profile pic of the author
    Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
    Original review: July 16, 2016

    We had a new a/c and furnace installed by One Hour Air Conditioning and Heating, Sierra Vista, AZ contracted by American Home Guardian. We and One Hour were told AHG would pay $5,000. and we were liable for @3,365.00 for a total of $8365.00. The work was done on 4/27/16. The contract was drawn up and the AHG was contracted again where it was confirmed. I paid my $3,365.00 to One Hour, signed the contract and given all the paperwork. Today, July 15, 2016 we got a call from AHG saying, we need another $1,000 plus, because our policy doesn't cover all that. What??? My original policy says, it does cover up to $5,000. I feel we have closed our part of the deal and owe no more. They are reneging on their contract.

    5 people found this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: July 1, 2016

    Terrible service. Had a seasonal check on my account unit, 2 months later AC overheated due to tech not securing fan in place with screws. Due to outage I was left without air in Phoenix when it was 105 degrees due to shotty work from a company AHG CONTRACTED. AHG did not take any responsibility for this and gave nothing but attitude which came from a manager named Alisia. Unethical company!!!

    6 people found this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: May 14, 2016

    Worst company I've EVER dealt with. This company is completely unethical and fraudulent. Do not give them your money or trust. They approved (multiple times) a repair for our oven in February and when I filed a complaint with the BBB a month later for another misrepresentation issue, the next day they said they no longer covered the oven repair back in February and issued me with an invoice of over $700 in new charges. Not only that but one of their contractors tried selling us on a new $2000 pool/spa heater when we later found nothing was wrong with it.

    I have filed a complaint with the Arizona Attorney General and their response was once again full of lies claiming that my call was for a contractor referral only. I immediately canceled my contract and they took it upon themselves to deduct the oven repair charges out of my refund check. This company is so awful. We have paid them over $1100 for our warranty services, and not only did they refuse to repair covered items, but after we canceled our contract we received a refund check for $282 for barely 3 months of coverage. This company is a complete scam!

    View more
    8 people found this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
    Original review: Aug. 14, 2015

    I submitted a claim for my water last night and received an email confirmation at 6:22 AM. They also called to let me know they were on their way. Less than 24 hours and I have a new water heater. Impressed!

    Be the first one to find this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
    Original review: July 30, 2015

    My wife & I remodeled our kitchen a little over two years ago. We purchased all Kenmore Elite Appliances. They have all been working fine, until about two weeks my wife noticed water running out from under the dishwasher. She called American Home Guardian and they sent a repairman out to diagnose the problem. The repairman stated that drain pump and motor needed to be replaced. American Home Guardian would not approve the repair, and said it exceeded the limit to repair the dishwasher.

    They gave me five options, in which none of them are even close to what we paid for our current dishwasher. Option 1. Replace with Kenmore Model #22-15112 - retails for around $349. Option 2. Sears Gift Card for $297. Option 3. Home Deport Gift Card for $283. Option 4. Lowe's Gift Card for $283. Option 5. CBO Gift Card for $283 (I am not familiar with CBO). I thought these warranty companies were suppose to replace with like item if not repairable. We even purchased the Guardian Plus Plan so we'd have better coverage.

    View more
    8 people found this review helpful
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: July 24, 2015

    American Home Guardian does not stand behind the work of its subcontractors. The subcontractor assigned by AHG to repair my oven broke my oven and then charged me $385 to fix the problem. AHG refused to reimburse me, saying the damage done by THEIR CONTRACTOR was not covered under my policy. I am now pursuing legal means of recovery against AHG and the subcontractor, if I can ever find out his last name. He refused to give me that information and so did AHG. This is truly a disreputable company with questionable business practices. If you buy a policy from them, you'll have no one to blame for your mistake except yourself. CAVEAT EMPTOR!

    UPDATED ON 09/24/2015: In accordance with the instructions given to me on the phone by Lisa ** of American Home Guardian, I mailed a certified letter to American Home Guardian notifying them that I was cancelling my home warranty insurance policy at once. Ms.** advised me that I would receive a refund within 45 days for the unused portion of my premium, which amounted to approximately $200. After 8 weeks with no refund arriving, I sent an email message to Ms.** asking when I could expect to receive my refund on the unused portion of my premium, now past due. I received no response to my email.

    I have filed a complaint with John McCormick, the commissioner of the Arizona Department of Insurance, requesting the Insurance Department's assistance to recover my refund. When I spoke with John approximately 4 weeks ago, he promised me that the Arizona Department of Insurance would assist me with recovering my refund if American Home Guardian didn't voluntarily send it, which, of course, they have not. Another glaring example of American Home Guardian's unethical and downright dishonest business practices, in live Technicolor! How does the owner, Chad Forbush, and his paid crony, Lisa **, sleep at night, knowing they are deliberately and intentionally ripping off customers who once trusted them until that trust was violated with the greed and perfidy of American Home Guardian, Inc.? Save yourself a lot of unnecessary grief and avoid AHG as if it were Typhoid Mary. These guys are VERY BAD NEWS.

    View more
    11 people found this review helpful
    Original review: Oct. 12, 2014

    I have an over the range microwave that stopped working. I called AHG on a Friday at 2pm to request service. Never got a call & I had to call them to schedule on Monday. Was charged $54 to have the guy come out to tell me it can't be fixed. Got $109 towards a new one. So basically they gave me $50 to buy a new one. New ones comparable to mine run $500 + not including installation and delivery. I called the Manager Javier twice with AHG and left messages both times. That was 2 weeks ago & I still haven't heard back. So, I sent an email through their website a week ago, and still no response. In the meantime I had to suck it up and purchase a new microwave with the pathetic $50 they gave me. I thought warranty companies are supposed to give you money for a comparable item. They didn't do that in addition to nobody getting back to me. I'll be cancelling my contract with them at renewal time.

    12 people found this review helpful
    Original review: Aug. 10, 2014

    An absolutely terrible company - I wouldn't even recommend them to someone I hated, they are that bad!! I would give this company a negative rating if I could - they don't even rate a zero. I'm not sure where to even begin - this company is so bad in every aspect. I called them concerning a plumbing issue and because I just bought the house a month ago, they wanted a copy of the home inspection report so I sent the summary. That wasn't good enough. So instead of them just asking me for the full report, they sent an email to the home inspector with the string of emails that had transpired between me and AHG. He wrote back to them and told them flat out he's never seen such unprofessional behavior and, as a professional home inspector, he would be sure to tell his clients to stay away from AHG at all cost.

    The plumber they sent said he couldn't fix the problem, he didn't have the equipment needed. He said he snaked the line as much as he could and that was it. He said a hydraulic pump (or something like that) was needed. I called a few plumbing companies and they said that is ONLY used for commercial buildings as it would blow out residential plumbing lines.

    Skip two days later and the plumbing issue got worse after the plumber was there! Before, some sewage back up was occurring in a guest shower. Now not only is the shower filled with sewage but every toilet is backed up. I don't know what he did but not only did he NOT fix this issue, I'm concerned that he actually made it worse. So I called AHG today (Saturday) and finally got through after being on hold for a long time and after being disconnected twice. The person I spoke with said they would have to call the plumber.

    I asked them to call me back to give me an update - whether or not they were able to reach the plumber or not. That was almost 5 HOURS AGO!!! And this is for an emergency service call since no plumbing whatsoever is working in the house. I'm glad I went with my instincts and had contacted a reliable plumbing service soon after I called them. They will have a plumber out shortly to see what the problem is and fix it if they can today.

    I'm cancelling my contract with AHG and filing a complaint with the BBB first thing Monday. This company should not be in business! Buyer definitely beware!!! They do nothing but cause you additional stress and grief in addition to the issue you are already dealing with.

    ****Update***** Just as I had suspected. The plumber sent by AHG was incompetent and actually made the situation worse. Instead of snaking the line properly, all he did was push the stuff towards the main line and clogged multiple lines by doing so.

    View more
    16 people found this review helpful
    Original review: Nov. 6, 2010 I purchased a home warranty in feb 2010. My AC unit went down on Sep 24, the compressor failed. Instead of replacing the unit which is 20 yrs old, even though they recommended replacement, they repaired it but not without a cost to me. So their website says: "If we can't fix it, we replace it". That is false. They told me that if they hadn't been able to fix it, they only would have given me the book value of the unit or $200. They gave me options to replace the unit that exceeded $4000. I coudn't afford it, so I had no option but had it fixed. Then they tell me I have to pay for the freon, but when I get the bill, it includes other parts as well. Now i have an invoice for $241 that I refuse to pay and they most likely will try to ruin my credit. They also took 3 days to repair the problem in weather conditions that exceeded 100 degrees. This is irresponsible service. What I don't understand is why they have a good rating with the BBB, when they are lying in their advertisement. This company shouldn't be allowed to do business. I should have saved the policy cost of over $400 and just replace the unit myself at a cost of $2000 for a bigger unit than what they wanted to sell me. Not only do they want your money and provide no service, but they want to make money upselling you when you have a problem. Unbelievable.
    3 people found this review helpful
    Original review: Jan. 3, 2010

    I bought my first home in June 2008. It was the usual process: contract, inspection, repairs, closing, and the house came with American Home Shield. For a whole year the house was great, everything worked. American Home Shield had decided to raise the premium for my home warranty the coming year and sent me letters of renewal, that was when I began my "homework" for a more affordable home warranty company with better reviews. I sent many emails to many home warranty companies in the area with the following information: (1) My home is 20+ years old. (2) I need coverage for repair and replacement for my at least HVAC, water heater, plumbing, electric, and unknown pre-existing condition and code violations since building codes change. (3) The conversation went like this: "Also, in your response you didn't mention anything about limits of coverage when it comes to anything needing replaced. Does it mean, for example, if an A/C system needs to be replaced and it costs $4000, AHG will pay for all of that rather than, like some companies, only cover $1500 and let the customer pay the rest, plus the service call fee?" And their reply was this: "Our limits meet or exceed the highest in the industry. We go up to $5,000 per HVAC unit. I don't know anyone who goes that high."

    So in June 2009, I switched my home warranty from AHS to AHG without interruption. November 2009, I noticed that my central heat was not heating my house like it did last winter, so I called in for service. AHG sent a technician to my house about a week later. The technician said that the heat exchanger was leaking and was unsafe to operate, and since it's an old unit, he quoted a $1700 replacement. AHG called me a few days later and told me they will not pay for the replacement, but they will give me a $900 check. The phone conversation went something like this (to the best of my recollection, of course):

    Me: “Is this $900 for just the heating? For example, if I use the $900 for replacing my furnace, I pay the rest, then what happens when my cooling breaks down this coming summer?” AHG: “The $900 is for the entire system.” Me: ”The entire system like, the entire heating system? Or the entire a/c and heating system?” AHG: “The entire system, everything.”

    I think I was on the verge of tears from the shock and frustration. Well, as any reasonable person knows, to replace the entire system as they have implied, will cost at least $5000. Naturally, I did not accept it and told them I was told differently by the person who signed me up, and they said, "Send us the email." That same day I sent them the entire log of email exchanges, and got a response from their company president, who told me this: "When you got your contract in the mail, you also received a letter that asked you to read and understand your contract. It has been our pleasure assisting you." Unsigned. (I didn't know he was the company president until I looked up the company profile online.) He also pointed out in the contract that says everything said before the contract do not count. Goodness! So the company has the policy to warrant ** (pardon me) in order to fish customers? It sounds more like bait and switch if not deceptive trade practice. Knowing this isn't good, I filed a complaint against AHG at the Better Business Bureau. As a BBB rule, companies are given 30 days to respond to a complaint, with one reminder about 2 weeks into the 30 days if no response is received. AHG did not initiate any contact with me nor did they respond to the BBB for the whole duration.

    A couple of days after that given 30 days, after BBB contacted me and pretty much said they couldn't do anything since the company didn't reply, and was probably ready to lower the company's A- rating, I wrote an email to the company's president again asking for the status of my claim and why I've been ignored for 30 days, I got some pretty dirty responses. Here are the highlights: "I do not see anywhere in your emails that you advised AHG of the age of your heating/cooling system, only the age of your home." Even though I never mentioned anything about anything ever having been replaced either." I need to be 100% clear that at no time has AHG ignored you as you state below. This is simply not true and very questionable as to why/how you could make such an outlandish accusation." They didn't reply to my BBB complaint for a whole month! "Because this issue has lingered for so long, I am going to give you until December 29, 2009. If no decision is made, AHG will mail you a $900.00 check and no further actions will be taken by AHG related to this service request." They made me wait for a whole month in the cold. Well, after I wrote back and told them I couldn't accept this since I was exploring my options, in a couple more days, I got a message from the BBB saying that the company has responded, and it was merely the email reply above from them. The president implied to BBB that they didn't ignore me, though they didn't tell the BBB that I had to contact them first after the 30-day wait, nor did they say to BBB that I had refused the "deadline" they tried to impose. I wrote a response to BBB explaining that AHG never asked me about the age of my units, and I never said anything was ever replaced, and per AHG contract, they could have refused the issuance of contract to me at that time, but they didn't.

    Well, AHG responded saying that the entire "age conversation" does not apply (even though he explicitly said I didn't tell him the age of my units) since they cover everything no matter how old, but simply that they get to decide the "value" of the items. For example, even though in their contract it says in case of replacement, they'll replace with builder grade items, he says they had decided that my old units aren't worth anything, so by that "policy" they don't need to pay for it. Furthermore, the president of the company said: "On the estimate, the contractor very clearly states that the heater never worked. She knew this because she has lived in the house for over a year." Well, I have my gas bill as well as that technician's initial invoice/report that simply said my heat exchanger is broken and is unsafe to operate; he never said that it never worked. At least he never did say that in my face. Otherwise, I'd have showed him my gas bill and mentioned the fact that the last home warranty company, American Home Shield, never got a service request from me last winter.

    He also began a string of nasty implications: "The fact that we have offered her anything should be viewed as a very positive statement, I am sure you and she agrees." Wow! I can't believe he said that without proof. That's gutsy. Of course he offered me something, I paid for a warranty with them! Why else would I buy warranty if I expect to have nothing done for me when something breaks down? Of course, I sent a reply to BBB with the photos and documentation of my gas bill and what the technician wrote so that BBB has the record straight. They can check with American Home Shield if they want to verify that I had no problems with my house at the time of the "switch." Unfortunately, at this moment, BBB has not yet changed their rating and has determined this is beyond purview. I'm just frustrated because it's almost two months now. I'm freezing in my house and I do worry about the plumbing that may burst if I continue to have no heat in the house as weather gets colder. I also worry I am going to get sick from the cold as well as the mental stress this is causing me. At the same time, I just don't believe a company should be allowed to lie their way to get customers.

    View more
    21 people found this review helpful

    American Home Guardian Company Information

    Company Name:
    American Home Guardian

    Make the best choice, every time

    Join our community to stay up-to-date with the latest reviews, recall notices, and brand recommendations. Our community members are happier with their purchases than consumers who didn’t research before buying. To see why, sign up below!


    Keep an eye on your inbox, the latest consumer news is on its way!

    ConsumerAffairs Solutions for Business

    Let's talk

    Follow us

    ConsumerAffairs ranks 562 on Inc. 5000 for 2017

    At ConsumerAffairs we love to hear from both consumers and brands; please never hesitate to Contact Us.

    At ConsumerAffairs we take privacy seriously, please refer to our Privacy Policy to learn more about how we keep you protected.

    You’re responsible for yourself and please remember that your use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use.

    Advertisements on this site are placed and controlled by outside advertising networks. does not evaluate or endorse the products and services advertised. See the FAQ for more information.

    The information on our website is general in nature and is not intended as a substitute for competent legal advice. makes no representation as to the accuracy of the information herein provided and assumes no liability for any damages or loss arising from the use thereof.

    Copyright © 2018 Consumers Unified LLC. All Rights Reserved. The contents of this site may not be republished, reprinted, rewritten or recirculated without written permission.