Find the Best Breast Pump Brands
Compare Top Breast Pump Reviews
|Hygeia Breast Pumps||Read 63 Reviews|
Hygeia is a breast pump manufacturer focused on providing customers with low-cost, high-quality pumps. They offer double-electric pumps and manual models as well as replacement parts and accessories.
Read 22 Reviews
Ameda is a breast pump manufacturer that has been in operation since 1962. The Swiss company offers single-user, multiple-user and hospital-grade pumps and accessories for breast-feeding and pumping mothers.
|Medela Breast Pumps|
Read 23 Reviews
Medela is a Swedish healthcare company founded in the 1960s, known for hospital grade electric breast pumps. The pumps are covered by many insurance plans and available for purchase online and through retailers.
|Evenflo Breast Pumps|
Read 49 Reviews
Evenflo is a baby product company that manufactures breast pumps and many other baby care products. Evenflo specializes in electric pumps that are easy to maintain and clean and an extensive line of accessories.
|Spectra Baby USA|
Read 18 Reviews
Founded in 2012, Spectra offers high-quality breast pumps at low prices. It is also the only company to offer a Swarovski-encrusted breast pump. Spectra is a best seller in the U.K. and Australia and is now in the American market.
|Philips Avent Breast Pumps||Read 10 Reviews|
Philips Avent is an international manufacturer of baby products. The company was formed by a merger between tech innovator Philips and baby product manufacturer Avent and is known for its bottles, pacifiers, and breast pumps.
|Bellema||Read Author Review|
Bellema is a breast pump manufacturer based in China that launched on the U.S. market in 2016. It offers single- and double-electric pumps that are comparable to elite brands but for more affordable prices.
|Dr. Brown’s Breast Pumps||Read Author Review|
Dr. Brown's is a baby and toddler feeding brand. It has a wide selection of products that include a manual breast pump, bottles and other breast-feeding accessories. Dr. Brown’s guarantees its products against any issues.
|Lansinoh Breast Pumps||Read Author Review|
Lansinoh is a breast-feeding supply company that has been in business since 1984. It offers an electric breast pump and a manual pump along with many breast-feeding and pumping supplies and accessories.
|Naya||Read Author Review|
Naya is a breast pump innovator that launched its first product, the Naya Smart Breast Pump, in December 2016. The pump features a hydraulic motor for quieter, more efficient pumping, as well as silicon breast flanges for comfort.
Questions to ask before you choose a breast pump
Do you need an electric, battery-operated or manual pump?
There are three main types of breast pumps—electric, battery-powered and manual. Which one you need will depend on how often you plan to pump.
- Electric breast pumps: Electric breast pumps are the most efficient but also the most expensive. Many women find that electric breast pumps are convenient and fast to use, pumping a maximum amount of milk in the least amount of time. However, they can be heavy and cumbersome and you will need access to an electrical outlet while you pump.
- Battery-powered breast pumps: Battery-powered breast pumps have motors similar to electric pumps. They are easy to travel with and allow users to pump without the need for an electrical outlet. The batteries may need to be replaced frequently, which can be expensive depending on what type of battery you need. Other models come with fully rechargeable batteries.
- Manual: Manual pumps typically consist of a bottle attached to a breast shield, or flange, that goes around the breast and areola. To use a manual breast pump, you hold it against your breast and squeeze a handle to create suction. Manual pumps are much cheaper than electric or battery pumps and are also smaller and easier to transport. They are great for moms who don’t intend to pump daily, or who want a pump to relieve occasional engorgement.
Do you need a single or double pump?
Breast pumps come with either one or two flanges attached to the motor. While they work the same way, their main difference is efficiency.
- Single breast pumps: These come with one flange attached to a bottle for milk collection. You will pump each breast separately and may need to reattach a new bottle to the pump after pumping the first breast. However, these are often small and easy to transport and cost less than double pumps.
- Double breast pumps: Double breast pumps have two flanges attached to bottles to collect milk from both breasts simultaneously. These tend to be bigger, more cumbersome machines to transport and are considerably more expensive than single breast pumps. However, they cut the time you need to spend pumping in half, so these are great options for working moms and others who need to pump on a regular basis and who want to pump as quickly as possible.
What special features do you need?
Many breast pumps have additional features that help make pumping easier or more convenient.
- Hands-free: Some companies make a nursing bustier that holds the breast shields in place so moms can pump hands-free using a double-electric pump. While they’re pumping, they’re able to do something else, such as answer e-mail or read. Other companies, like Naya, are innovating new technology to allow the entire, cord-free pump to be placed inside the user’s bra, collecting milk into bags for a totally hands-off pumping experience.
- Speed and suction controls: Many companies offer breast pumps with different speed control and suction settings to maximize the effectiveness of the pumping. Different suction and speed settings may help increase production for women who don’t produce enough milk naturally. Many electric breast pumps automatically shift between a shorter stimulation mode and a longer flow mode to mimic the natural letdown of breast milk when nursing.
- Open- or closed-system: Closed-system breast pumps have a barrier between the pump itself and the milk collection tubes and bottle. These pumps are easier to clean and, in some models, are safe for use by multiple women provided each person has their own accessories (breast shield, tubing, valve, membrane and bottle). An open-system pump has no barrier and can be harder to clean, but may have slightly stronger suction. Open-system pumps include most Medela models (except for its hospital-grade options) and most manual pumps.
What accessories do you need?
Many breast pumps have specific accessories that help make pumping easier or more convenient. In some cases these come standard with the pump; in other cases you’ll need to purchase the accessories separately, so be sure that any parts you need are offered by the company.
- Multiple flange sizes: Breast pumps use a funnel-shaped breast shield, called a flange, that fits over the breast and areola during pumping. Because women’s breasts and areolas come in many shapes and sizes, standard- or average-sized flanges will not fit everyone. Many brands offer several sizes of flanges with their pumps, or offer them for sale separately.
- BPA-free bottles and parts: Almost all breast pumps attach to plastic bottles, tubing, flanges and other parts that come in contact with the breast milk. Some plastic ingredients can be harmful for food storage, especially BPA, which can leach out of the plastic when it is being washed and then contaminate the breast milk. Look for pumps that have “BPA free” on the packaging.
- Additional membranes and valves: Pumps come with all the parts they need to operate, but some of the parts are easily damaged or lost. Most pumps use one membrane and one valve to separate the pumping mechanism from the breastshield and milk collection bottle. The membranes and valves on a pump are so small that they are easily damaged and often misplaced when cleaning. Having extras on hand will ensure that you can operate your pump even if you misplace or damage these essential but tiny parts.
How much does the breast pump cost?
Breast pumps come in a wide range of prices depending on the technology and features of the pump. When it comes to pumps, the more expensive pumps are generally bigger and heavier but also more efficient and gentle. Small, manual pumps can be purchased for less than $25 while hospital-grade pumps average around $2,000.
- Hospital-grade pumps: Hospital-grade breast pumps are much more expensive than other types because they have heavy-duty motors and closed pump systems that make them safe for use by more than one mom. These range from several hundred to a few thousand dollars, but can often be rented from a local hospital or lactation organization.
- Affordable breast pumps: While some breast pump companies sell high-tech pumps, some mothers are simply looking for a straightforward and easy to use device. Many breast pump companies are dedicated to selling smaller, simpler pumps that are more affordable than larger models. Some companies sell standard single manual pumps without advanced features, and single electric pumps, to emphasize affordability and make them accessible for all women.
- Insurance coverage: As of this writing, the Affordable Care Act requires private insurance companies in the United States to fully cover breast pumps for nursing mothers. You will need a prescription from your obstetrician to obtain a free breast pump from your insurance company. Contact your insurance provider to find out which breast pumps are “in-network” for your plan. If you prefer a pump that is not covered by your insurance, you may be able to use your Flexible Spending Account (FSA) or Health Savings Account (HSA) to purchase the pump using pre-tax dollars.
Does the company have good customer service?
Breast pump companies that sell pumps to mothers should provide supportive customer service to make sure customers are happy with their purchases and to address any concerns promptly.
- Phone support: Some breast pump companies help customers via telephone, which is a convenient option for consumers who prefer to speak to customer service representatives in person.
- Chat support: Many companies now offer convenient chat support on their websites, which can be a great option for customers who prefer to communicate via written text or the Internet.
- Refunds: Sometimes breast pumps don’t function correctly or stop working after a short amount of time. Find out your breast pump company’s policy regarding returns and refunds.
- Warranties: When purchasing products like breast pumps, it's important to consider the warranties offered that cover damage and wear and tear over time. Warranties often last for a short length of time, often one or two years on the motor, depending on the company. Companies also have different timetables for how fast warranties can be processed.
What are the different types of breast pumps?
Personal electric or battery-operated pumps
Electric or battery-operated home pumps run on motors while plugged into an outlet or powered by batteries. These pumps tend to work much more efficiently than manual pumps, but not as efficiently as hospital grade pumps. They are available in single or double; single pumps have one functioning suction tube that can drain milk from one breast at a time, while a double pump saves time by pumping both breasts simultaneously.
Hospital-grade electric pumps
Hospital-grade electric pumps are the most expensive but most effective on the market. These pumps have larger, heavier motors and are not easy to transport from place to place, but can pump two to three times faster than personal electric pumps for a much more efficient process. They are quite expensive and are often available for rent from hospitals.
Manual breast pumps
Manual pumps are used by placing a plastic breast shield against the breast and squeezing a handle to create suction. Because they have no electrical components and a simple design, they are much more affordable than electric pumps but are also not as efficient at extracting milk. They are best for people who pump occasionally or to relieve engorgement. Many companies that sell electric breast pumps also sell manual breast pumps.
Multi-user breast pumps
Breast pumps are often utilized at the hospital, especially when mothers first deliver or when babies have to be kept in the hospital for long periods of time. Thus, many companies produce electric breast pumps designed for many users. Multi-user pumps are sanitary and can handle a high capacity of pumping.
Who uses breast pumps?
New mothers struggling with supply issues
When a woman has a baby, her body usually responds within a few days by creating an ample milk supply. Some women have trouble creating an adequate supply for a variety of reasons related to stress, diet, health or other factors. These women can use a breast pump to stimulate more milk production between breast-feeding sessions.
New mothers experiencing engorgement
When a woman’s milk first comes in, her body often overproduces and creates an uncomfortable or even painful feeling of fullness called engorgement. Pumping for a few minutes prior to nursing can soften the breasts to relieve pain and make it easier for the baby to latch properly.
Working mothers who want to breast-feed
If you will be working and not with your baby to feed every few hours but still wish to breast-feed, you might consider investing in a high-quality pump. An automatic electric pump with speed and suction options along with double-pumping capability can make pumping at work more efficient and comfortable.
While many mothers breast-feed, some prefer to have the baby drink straight from the breast rather than pump milk into the bottle. Mothers who primarily feed from the breast may only need to use a breast pump occasionally when they will be away from their babies. These customers can use a manual pump or single electric pump because it doesn't need to work as efficiently.
Mothers who can’t or don’t want to feed from the breast
Some mothers have trouble feeding directly from the breast for medical, personal or other reasons. These women may want to use a breast pump to provide their child with breast milk for a few weeks, months or longer.
Women who want to induce lactation
Some women who adopt a newborn but have not given birth use a breast pump to induce lactation so that they can nurse their babies. Most women who have not given birth can produce at least some milk this way, but typically not enough to feed a baby exclusively with breast milk. Still, it can be a great way to bond with an adopted baby and provide a supplement to a formula-based diet. Other women who have breast-fed their baby but then switched to formula can use a pump to “relactate” or begin to produce milk again after losing their milk supply. Inducing lactation requires using a breast pump every two to three hours around the clock, in addition to putting the baby to the breast as often as possible.
Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter!
Compare Top Breast Pump Reviews
|NUK||Read Author Review|
NUK is a leading manufacturer of baby and children’s feeding items. Its line of breast pumps combine convenience and affordability and are available for purchase online and at many major United States retailers.
|The First Years Breast Pumps||Read Author Review|
The First Years has been making infant care products since the 1950s. It specializes in a variety of breast pumps and also offers accessories and replacement parts to make the pumping experience more convenient.
|Tommee Tippee||Read Author Review|
Tommee Tippee is a UK-based infant and toddler product company. It specializes in bottles and cups but also offers a manual breast pump and several breast-feeding accessories, all available for purchase online and in stores.
|Willow||Read Author Review|
Willow is the only wearable, cord- and tube-free breast pump. Willow consists of two devices that fit inside each cup of your bra. Willow can be programmed with an app and pumps milk quietly into discreet collection bags.
Information in this guide is general in nature and is intended for informational purposes only; it is not legal, health, investment or tax advice. ConsumerAffairs.com makes no representation as to the accuracy of the information provided and assumes no liability for any damages or loss arising from its use.