
JW of Des Plaines, IL on July 19, 2011
Satisfaction Rating1/5
30,000 miles ago, I purchased top of the line BF Goodrich tires for my SUV from our local Costco. After 13,000 miles since the last rotation, I asked Costco to rotate the tires for free as per the purchase agreement. Before even looking at my car, one of their "techs" (the guys who install tires and build the bicycles Costco sells) told me, to my surprise, that if they were considered worn in a way they didn't approve of (to paraphrase) they weren't going to rotate my tires. I expressed surprise at this, but he said not to worry - "99%" chance, it was okay. Sure enough, 40 minutes later, my cell phone rings. To cut the long story short, the technician claims that because my front tires show more than 2/32" more wear than the back ones, they won't rotate them. I told him never mind all that, just rotate them. He refused. I asked to speak with the manager, Jay, who was immediately smug and curt with me. He talked over my words, made every effort to be condescending, and exhibited very poor customer service skills.
Ultimately, Costco refused to rotate my tires. Nowhere do they state in the agreement that if you don't rotate at 7500 miles, they won't do it. Instead, they referred me to some obscure fine print about this 2/32" rule. They claim they follow tire industry guidelines, but it's hogwash. I'll surmise they figure if they refuse to rotate your tires, you'll need new ones faster - and maybe they have more grounds to weasel out of tire warranty claims (which generally aren't worth the paper they're printed on, anyway). Immediately, I called my mechanic who had seen the car the very same day for another routine maintenance item, and he called their refusal ridiculous. He's an outstanding, very busy mechanic with years of technical training under his belt. He works on complex problems every day, and knows way more about auto technology than the Costco tire guys. In fact, 3000 miles ago, I asked him about rotating, and he told me it was okay to wait til now. Also note, some time ago when I asked Costco to rotate my tires with less than 7500 miles between rotations, they refused me service at that time as well. In the past I've had tires rotated after 25,000 miles and not had any issues.
We have bought tires for several vehicles through Costco tires and, while the initial purchase price has usually been reasonable, the follow-up care is terrible. Every time we've returned for a rotation, they've told us they're marking down on the history uneven wear due to bad alignment or suspension or some other problem. I've taken my car for inspection after their "warnings", only to find out there was no problem at all. In my opinion, they invent problems so that they can opt later to deny tire warranty coverage. The Costco manager also warned me that the tires showed wear from over-inflation, which I told him was funny since they were filled with nitrogen and only his Costco had ever filled my tires. His response basically was, "well, if you can prove that..." Of course, there was no way to prove that at all. From here on in, I will never return to the Costco tire center for any work. I will pay our good mechanic to rotate our tires. And we'll buy our tires from a reputable tire shop.
At the end of my ordeal, after my wife was upset and we suffered through an embarrassing conflict in front of other customers, Jay tried to make amends by saying how sorry he was that I was frustrated by the experience, that he didn't want me to go away upset. I told him the damage was done, and that I would never return to the tire center. He went on, trying to explain their consumer-unfriendly policy with more tire jargon and finger-pointing. He gave me a gift card for my troubles, but it was too little, too late. I advise anyone out there to do your homework; do not buy tires from Costco as you too will be disappointed and frustrated in the long run.