My fianc and I purchased an engagement ring at the Tyson's Corner, VA Zales store. The store manager, Jen, was our sales consultant. We told her - expressly - that I did not want a white gold ring. I wanted palladium (a rare, naturally white metal). She told me any of Zales' rings could be "upgraded" to palladium in exchange for $150. We picked out a ring - the celebration diamond ring with a cathedral setting. We paid $150 for the ring to be made in palladium. The ring came in and Zales gave the ring to my fianc, explaining again that this was the "palladium" ring we ordered.
Upon delivery, my fianc didn't notice (but I did) that the jeweler did not give us the celebration setting - instead, he gave us a generic tiffany setting. Because palladium is a rare metal, I assumed that the jeweler may have had difficulty obtaining the ring; this was the only setting available in palladium. I decided the replacement was okay, because I really wanted palladium. I didn't contact Zales at this time.
However, a professional, independent appraisal revealed that the ring was actually white gold, not palladium. I contacted Zales to see what they would do to fix it. They offered to get the original in palladium or upgrade to platinum. That sounded good, but after the jeweler told them he couldn't do it in palladium, Zales said my only option was to allow the jeweler to choose a different ring with a cathedral setting and reset the ring in that setting.
That's ridiculous. Zales breached the sales agreement as well as multiple express and implied warranties of fitness and merchantability. I would love to sue them. Also, the manager Pam told me that I was not the first customer that had come to her complaining that the Zales store had sold the customer something inconsistent with the claims made at point of sale (e.g., appraisal revealed significant inconsistencies with Zales representations of the goods). My fianc and I relied on Zales' expertise to pick out the right ring and order it in palladium. When we found out the switch and complained, Zales didn't even say they were sorry. How many other customers have they done this to? I wish this would get exposed on the ** or some other bridal website.
