
Pamela of Redding, CA on Sept. 7, 2011
Satisfaction Rating1/5
We buried my sweet male Shih Tzu today. Buster B. was released from his misery on 8/26/11 after suffering since 7/14/11. He and Teddi, my female, have been eating Natural Balance for approximately three years. They loved the Duck and Potato and ate 10 lbs. a month.
Sometime last year, I noticed the shelves at Petco were very empty of D&P. I asked a clerk and he said it was very popular. Actually there was recall that no one told the consumer about. I proceeded to buy various flavors with the sweet potato in it. They also ate a tiny amount of canned food daily and dog treats. After all, they say it is all natural.
On July 6, 2011, I went to Petco and bought food and the D&P was back, so I got the entire set. I had to open the treats right away because they were out. The shape was more flattened and very hard, the smell was also different. Buster would not take his treats or he put it in his mouth, rolled it around and spit it out. We thought he was having trouble biting it with his 14-year-old teeth. We gave him just half, but that did not matter. The new bag of food was taken unopened into the RV, since we were leaving to go to the medical clinic for me. We left on the 13th. We took their food bowl, still 1/2 full to the RV, so they could always eat the dry food at their leisure. They ate that until my husband opened the new bag. It was darker, flatter shaped circle and smelled different as well. We always gave them a morning and afternoon snack of canned food that was about 1 tbls. each.
I was gone every day, but in the evening Buster, "our take it easy boy" was going to the food and water dish and barking. He did this over and over. They usually told us if the bowls were empty, but we told him to be quiet since they were full. Then he would go to the refrigerator and bark. We knew he wanted food from there but they had enough in the bowls. I thought Bo my husband was filling the food and he thought I was filling it.
We got home late on 7/20/2011 and brought the food in the house. Teddi was taking the food and throwing it on the floor. I thought she was playing so I tossed some her way. She ate two bites and walked away. Late Friday, I noticed Buster was having a hard time having a BM, so we thought he was constipated. We even tried to buy a baby enema for him.
First thing on Monday the 25th, we were at the vet. and they tried to get a stool sample, but his body was empty. The tests showed he had pancreatitis. He was in the hospital for six days and came home on July 30, 2011. He was now obviously losing weight. We feed him baby food, but had to stick it in his mouth, also sweet potato and boiled chicken breast. Pills were the hardest. He would not eat on his own.
We decided to go to Lassen Park for a few days on August 7 and continued with the feedings. He was eating more and more easily. He seemed stronger and more alert than when he got out of the hospital. That night, he threw up all the days' undigested food. Friday he ate good, but that night he threw up all the days' undigested food. We left early Saturday to get to the vet. The tests on 8/6/2011 showed the pancreatitis was back. He stayed in the hospital almost two days and we brought him home with a really strict diet of a teaspoon of the canned vet food every two hours. This was not easy, but we got the food down him.
We called and asked if we could increase the food since he was not throwing up. We did and had to get a large syringe to get the food in and down. He fought so hard, but would lick his lips and stay for more. He was starving, but we did not know what was happening inside of him. We made a mush of his Rx food and baby food and got up to 1/2 cup a day by force feeding him at least every one to two hours.
He was taken into the vet on August 18 for a check and the vet noticed he had jaundice. The tests showed his liver was involved now. We brought him home with more pills and watched his jaundice. We continued the daily job of getting food into him. We looked for any sign of improvement. We were in touch with the vet almost daily. He slept good at night and laid on his favorite places during the day. He would go out to potty when we asked him and he used his doggy door as well. He did have some very small BM's. He was very frail and wobbly, but we did all we could do.
On the 25th, he looked like we had made it. He had his tail up and almost trotted outside. He followed us around the house and we were feeling good. We went to bed and the next morning he was in a trance-like state, something catastrophic happened during the night. His jaundice that had been receding was horrible. We took him to the vet and they saw in an ultrasound his bile ducts were swollen shut. Even with our hourly feeding he had lost another pound to 13 lbs. He had been 19 lbs. They admitted him to the hospital again. It was the worst night. We had all worked so hard and knew he could not make it. The next morning before we called the vet, they called and said it was time. We could not let him suffer any longer. His liver test was off the charts. We went in and held our sweet little boy, who was always in a good mood. We could feel all his bones through his pretty black and white hair. He put his head on my shoulder, which he never did. He was not a kissy dog, but that was his goodby to me. We were devastated. We always know when you adopt an earth angel that they will pass before you, but you pray it will not be so traumatic.
I went home and was working on the Internet as I had been trying to make sense of what happened. I put in pancreatitis and up came the website, Consumer Affairs. I was looking at a complaint about a dog dying like my Buster who had been eating the same food. There were more cases and as I started looking at all the brand names they listed, I could not believe it. I had never thought it could be the food, since I always choose the best food available. My heart was even more broken since he was trying to tell me he would not eat it and was hungry.
We went to bed and I jumped up and remembered the food was still down and Teddi had eaten some. It was not much, but what had we done to her? After throwing out two large bowls, we still had 1/2 the bag. We took her in to be checked and her liver test was up slightly. I looked and looked to find a food that was not currently killing dogs and cats. I think it is 2008 all over again. The companies are denying any problem with their food. As a retired detective, I know where coincidence stops. It was too late to have an autopsy since we had him cremated, but I have the food. It is well wrapped up and sealed like evidence in a case.
Today we saw crystals in Teddi's urine. My heart has dropped, since many pets have died from kidney failure. We have another appointment tomorrow to make sure we get ahead of the problem. I have been saying it looks like poison. My dogs are never out of the house without us in sight. They only eat what we give them. We live in the country without close neighbors or stray animals roaming. The food companies are trying to say it is antifreeze. Everyone knows not to have that around pets.
I have filed with the FDA. You can go to safetyreportingportal.gov. They even called me when I asked about reporting. Everyone who has a suddenly sick dog should check out the food and file with the FDA. Our sweet little friends need our help. It takes forever for a recall and how many other pets have to die for greed? If this was a baby food issue it would be on the front page and the companies would be quickly pulling the food and apologizing. We can do something for our four-legged friends. Tell everyone about Consumer Affairs and to see what their pet is eating. Their food should be fit for human consumption. I have found out that many companies buy their food from a few large pet food manufacturers. Try to find out where yours really comes from.
I won't sleep tonight worrying about Teddi.
My name is Jennifer Freeman and I am the Director of Customer Service and the staff Registered Veterinarian Technician for Natural Balance Pet Foods, Inc. When we saw this post, we were moved that Ms. Grimes had experienced such a heart breaking loss. Our pets are like family and one of our core principles at Natural Balance is to provide diets that help the health of the dogs & cats we feed. We are so dedicated to this idea that Natural Balance is the only pet food company with a lab that tests all lots of our food for the nine known contaminants in pet foods. And while we are grieved for Ms. Grimes' loss, we do need to establish that the facts do not support her assertion that Buster's death is related to our food.
I spoke with Ms. Grimes prior to this post and also spoke with Buster's attending Veterinarian. In my discussion with Ms. Grimes' Veterinarian she indicated that Buster had liver failure and chronic pancreatitis and an ultrasound showed Buster had liver nodules suspicious for a neoplasm (possible cancer). When asked if Buster's problems were food related, the Veterinarian responded that this was highly unlikely and noted that Buster was an older dog (14 years old) and that this could be a contributing factor.
Ms. Grimes' other dog, Teddi, was eating from the same bag of food as Buster but is, according to the Veterinarian, healthy and shows no evidence of liver failure or pancreatitis. If the food were the problem, Teddi, eating from the same bag, should have had the same problems.
Ms. Grimes stated in her post that "it was too late to have an autopsy since we had him cremated." Ms. Grimes' was encouraged by the Veterinarian to have a necropsy performed when Buster died and had been offered the opportunity to biopsy the suspicious liver nodules previously. She declined both of these options to learn more about what was wrong with Buster.
The food both Teddi and Buster were eating was tested in the Natural Balance laboratory for the nine most common contaminants in pet foods. The food passed these quality tests.
At Natural Balance, our pets come to work with us every day; we treat them like our children. Natural Balance takes incredible steps to ensure that our food is the highest quality available. After reviewing the records and speaking with Buster's Veterinarian it appears that Buster had a neoplasm of the liver and chronic pancreatitis. We agree with Buster's Veterinarian that Buster's problems are most likely unrelated to his diet. Teddi's good health makes this clear.
Sincerely,
Jennifer Freeman, B.S., R.V.T.
Director, Customer Service
Animal Nutrition
Natural Balance Pet Foods
Natural Balance Pet Foods on Sept. 21, 2011