First, I want to say that I did get a puppy through a breeder who had listed on GFP. I had been recommended to the website by a friend who had two German shepherds. Their "no puppy mills guaranteed" statement put me at ease. As someone who had no experience with purebreds, I was unaware of many of the things you should look for in a breeder, but I did know a few things, such as to see the dog in person (never ever buy a puppy that's been shipped, no good breeder does that), demand to see the mother, to see where the dogs were kept, to make sure they were clean, well fed, and happy and active, and had shots and a real AKC registration. The breeder we met were Amish and were kind and had a clean house, clean well cared for dogs, and only had corgis on the premises (just one family and only one litter).
My dog is nearly two and is fine. The only health problem she has is a slight flea bite allergy and problems with the more grain-based dog foods (she gets a more expensive kind and has no problems). However, I have since learned things about the website itself that I cannot ignore. Though the people I met were clearly decent folks who took care of their dogs, they were not good breeders. I have since learned that a good breeder would pay for genetic testing to make sure the dogs had no genetic conditions and I have also learned that an AKC registration (much to my surprise) is no guarantee that you are dealing with a good breeder. So these people were not bad people, but they did not do everything that a good breeder would. So they really should not have been breeding their corgis.
The bottom line here is that I got insanely lucky and I'm counting my blessings. I didn't count entirely on luck, though. Once someone told me about the bad website's reputation, I immediately purchased health insurance for my dog that covered genetic conditions in case the worst happens later down the road. Since I have never trusted a breeder to do shots, that was not an issue as the day after I got my dog I took her to the vet to have them all redone just in case. I was also horrified to discover that many of the "breeders" are in fact puppy millers! They are scum posing as the breeders of the dogs! Do not be fooled by GFP's guarantee, it is meaningless. I just think I am lucky that I already knew to see my dog in person and to investigate the home and everything. Many people do not know these things, and so they are conned by puppy millers.
GFP should either be taken down or forced by the law to take a real banning approach to anyone that is suspected of puppy milling. While it is no doubt true that some of the breeders are decent folk like the ones I met, you just can't ignore that a lot of them aren't. I recently read an article about a couple of people who use the GFP that were arrested for horrible living conditions for their animals! If GFP really checked people out, then obviously that would not have happened.
Since then I have felt scared of what could have happened. There is no doubt that I lucked out; my friends have told me that this family was most likely something called "backyard breeders," which means that they breed just a few pups and take good care of them, but don't understand what it means to be a good breeder and really make sure your buyers are good for the dogs. Another thing I learned is that a good breeder will give you like a year of health guarantee. Apparently, 30 days is nonsense - another lie by GFP to put people at ease with a false sense of security. So, I would recommend that anyone who wants a dog first call the ASPCA and ask them for website and phone number of the local club for the breed you want. At the time, I went looking for a dog and I did not know such things existed, but they do. They can help you find a local breeder with healthy dogs and you will never have to fear.
