I have used MyCheckFree.com for several years with no problem. On April 26, 2012, I scheduled a payment for $185.85 to be paid to JCPenney on May 1, 2012. By May 4, it still hadn't cleared the bank, although all my other payments scheduled that same day at MyCheckFree.com had cleared. I checked my JCPenney account and no payment had been made. I went to my account at MyCheckFree.com and saw a comment that they had issued a paper check to JCPenney for the amount of $18,585.00. They were unwilling to accept any responsibility for this mistake even though they had the JCPenney bill showing that my total bill was $227.85 (I had already returned an item costing $42 leaving the balance which I paid). They also had all my contact info and I feel they should have contacted me prior to sending out that large of a check. They list no number on their website, but JCPenney gave me their phone number.
As MyCheckFree.com refused to help in any way, I was told by them that I would have to go to my bank and issue a stop payment, which I did. The bank representative even talked to MyCheckFree's representative, trying to get them to stop the check, but they still refused. I had to pay the stop payment fee of $35 which is a lot cheaper than all the overdraft fees that would be generated by this big of a mistake. JCPenney was helpful in every way. If you want a responsible company that will work with you, do not use MyCheckFree.com.
