Most of us like to think that Madison Avenue's best efforts roll off us like water off a duck's back. But don't bet on it. New research says advertising has a way of seducing our brains.
After all, it's one thing to go out and buy a new washing machine after the old one exploded, quite another to impulse-buy that 246-inch flat screen TV that just maybe, in hindsight, you didn't really need.
Advertisers come at you in two ways. There is the just-the-facts type of ad, called "logical persuasion," or LP. “Buy this car because it gets 42 miles to the gallon” can be pretty effective when prices at the pump are nearing $4 a gallon.
Then there are the ads that circumvent conscious awareness, called "non-rational influence," or NI. A sultry music track and a beautiful woman draped over a car is a classic example.
Different ads provoke different brain responses
Despite research surrounding the notion of neuromaketing, which studies consumers' cognitive responses to marketing stimuli, the impact on brain function of these types of real-world advertisements was unknown. Now, researchers at UCLA and George Washington University have shown that different types of advertisements evoke different levels of brain activity, depending on whether they use elements of logical persuasion or non-rational influence.
Reporting in the current online edition of the Journal of Neuroscience, Psychology, and Economics, Dr. Ian Cook, a professor of psychiatry at the Semel Institute for Neuroscience and Human Behavior at UCLA, and colleagues found that brain regions involved in decision-making and emotional processing were more active when individuals viewed ads that used logical persuasion than when they viewed ads that used non-rational influence.
Brain activity is good
This brain activity is helpful. We want our brains to work when we're faced with buying decisions. The researchers says these brain regions help us inhibit our responses to certain stimuli. In other words, they help us maintain some self control.
"Watch your brain and watch your wallet," Cook said. "These results suggest that the lower levels of brain activity from ads employing NI images could lead to less behavioral inhibition, which could translate to less restraint when it comes to buying products depicted in the NI advertisements."
Tony Holiday (Wed, 21 Sep 2011 22:47:32 +0000): I beg to differ with you. An ad would have to be a LOT more relevant to me and my lifestyle before I pay any attention to it. I have a very low opinion of most ads, do not have a TV, do not read a newspaper, do not listen to radio, and pay very little attention to billboards or subway ads even if I am sitting there bored waiting for the bus. Most ads do not have anything to do with me and I resent them for their intrusion when I have to be subjected to them at all. So I just ignore them. It's like they just do not register. For instance, I am someone who does not eat junk food or drink soda pop and I feel most ads and commercials are geared towards people who do these things on a regular basis. I shop at natural food stores but it seems that most advertising is for the kind of stuff I have long snubbed and avoided.
Rita R. Robison (Wed, 21 Sep 2011 23:46:22 +0000): How did you (ConsumerAffairs.com) get my photo off Facebook? I don't appreciate it. Only my friends are supposed to have access to my information.
Nikoli McCracken (Thu, 22 Sep 2011 00:25:34 +0000): Well, been watching beer, wine, and alcohol advertising my whole life, but I don't drink, or smoke. My car is 13 years old, and still runs fine.
The ads for same only irritate me. All those cars skidding gracefully in circles to beautiful music? When I hit the brakes on my car, I want it to,
dammit, STOP! As for the commercials for some insurance? Happy with the company I have. Progressive's commercials make me nuts - I hate her vampire lipstick, plastic, big hair, and endless repetition. GEICO? They should stick with the Gekko! I don't need false tooth glue, arthritis rubs, Athlete's foot remedies, DEPENDS, or any of the other nostrums they peddle. I buy what I like, not what some ad impels me to.