More Preschool, Not Less, Is Beneficial To Young Children

As more states consider universal preschool programs, a new study led by a Michigan State University (MSU) scholar suggests two years of pre-K is beneficial, although more time should be spent on teaching certain skills.

In the current issue of the Early Childhood Research Quarterly, Lori Skibbe and her colleagues argue that pre-K programs generally do a good job of teaching literacy and that two years of preschool is better than one.

However, they also recommend preschool teachers should focus more on vocabulary instruction and exercises that build self-control as part of a broader curriculum.

Skibbe, who is also an MSU assistant professor of child development said in terms of kindergarten preparation, preschool does a very good job in certain areas in promoting children’s skill sets, but “it might do a better job if there was also explicit attention directed at building children’s self-regulation and vocabulary skills.”

The researchers assessed the skills of a cohort of Michigan children attending the first and second years of preschool (generally, 3- and 4-year-olds). The study was one of the first to directly assess self-regulation in this age group.

Preschool controversy

The findings come amidst a brewing controversy over preschool.

Many states are debating whether to offer preschool to all families and how many years children should attend -- an important policy question in a time of tight budgets.

Some researchers argue pre-K programs such as Head Start, a federally funded program for low-income families, offer no long-term benefits for children.

Skibbe disagrees. Her study found children who attended preschool were more likely to make gains in literacy skills; specifically, learning the letters of the alphabet and comprehending how they go together to form words.

Holistic approach

Skibbe said she supports a preschool curriculum that combines a focused, “holistic approach” to all three elements: literacy, vocabulary and self-control.

“Children should be spending more time in preschool, not less, because the results appear to be cumulative,” she said. “Children who spent two years in preschool, for example, did better in literacy.”

Skibbe’s co-investigators were Carol McDonald Connor from Florida State University, Frederick Morrison from the University of Michigan and Abigail Jewkes from Hunter College of the City University of New York.