NEWS    RECALLS    COMPLAINT FORM    SCAM ALERTS   RESOURCES  
Small Claims Guide   Class Actions   Lemon Laws   FAQ   Newsletters  
Share


Complain about a product or service

Automotive    Education    Employment    Electronics    Family    Finance    Health    Homeowners    Insurance    Pets    Shopping    Travel     Print This     Email This    



NEWS   Latest |  Archives |  Auto |  Cells, etc. |  Computers |  Financial |  Health |  Homeowners |  Parents |  Privacy |  Scams |  Seniors |  Travel

Report: Metered Broadband Bad For Consumers, Businesses

Study debunks "false choice" of content blocking or pay-as-you-go Internet





By Martin H. Bosworth
ConsumerAffairs.com

August 8, 2008

Broadband Access

Federal Court Tosses Out FCC Rule On Cable Caps
New Bill Gives FTC Veto Power Over Broadband Caps
Time Warner Cable Changes Contracts To Favor Bandwith Caps
Time Warner Cable Backs Down On Bandwith Caps
Time Warner: Metered Broadband Will Prevent "Internet Brownouts"
FCC Launches National Broadband Internet Plan
Time Warner Doubles Down on Metered Broadband Plans
FCC Pressed To Defend Wireless Open Internet
Time Warner Expands Metered Broadband Billing
New Jersey Sues Verizon Over Deceptive FiOS Marketing
Government Reveals First Steps For Broadband Plans
House Committee Slams FCC Chairman for "Deception and Distrust"
Obama Promises to "Renew Information Superhighway"
Dell Introduces "White Spaces" Capable Laptops
FCC Votes to Open "White Spaces" for Use
Congress Passes Broadband Data Improvement Act
Report: Metered Broadband Bad For Consumers, Businesses
FCC Votes to Punish Comcast for Content Blocking
Comcast Tries to Polish Its Image
Communications Industry Urges Congress to Act on Broadband
Comcast Cuts Deal With Vonage on Internet Traffic
Court Upholds FCC's Video Rules
Report: U.S. Broadband Adoption Slowing
Critics: FCC Inaction Slows Economic Development
Few Are Neutral in Net Neutrality Battles
Google Petitions FCC Over Verizon's Use of Wireless Spectrum
---
More ...

There's a rising swell of support among Internet service providers for "pay-as-you-go" or "metered" broadband plans, which would force users to pay for any usage of their Internet services once they pass a certain cap of bandwith. The companies say it's necessary in order to better control congestion of the network, which can slow down customer access and prevent you from getting the speeds you paid for, and is considered an alternative to blocking content altogether.

But a new report from Free Press debunks that notion, saying that not only is the choice between content blocking and metered broadband a false one, but that metered broadband is bad for innovation on the Internet and will only push customers away from companies that practice "pay-by-the-byte" plans.

“Consumers should not have to choose between secret and arbitrary blocking and the very unreasonable practice of metering,” said S. Derek Turner, research director of Free Press and author of the policy brief. “That is a false choice, one most providers don't even consider necessary or practical. These scare tactics shouldn't deter anyone from pursuing the policies we need to preserve a free and open Internet.”

Companies such as Time Warner Cable, Comcast, and most recently Frontier Cable have been rolling out metered broadband plans in certain markets to determine their viability. One principal some companies are considering metered plans involves reports that Internet usage will exceed its available capacity in just a few years--what some call the "exaflood." If companies don't control how much bandwith their users utilize, they argue, there won't be enough for everyone to go around.

Nonsense, Turner said. "Contrary to the exaflood hype, bandwidth demand increases are pretty predictable, on the order of 50-60 percent per year. And recent data from one of the world’s leading academic researchers on Internet use suggests that the traffic growth rate in the United States is actually slowing."

That researcher, Professor Andrew Odlyzko, director of the University of Minnesota’s Digital Technology Center, said that "There is still no sign of the threatened deluge that was supposed to clog the Internet."

Scare tactics

Metered broadband plans or caps on usage have actually been around for several years. Even before Comcast was caught blocking customers' access to BitTorrent, it was notorious for canceling or restricting customer accounts if they went over, or even near, an undisclosed "bandwith cap." Comcast refused to disclose the cap for fear that customers would flee for competitors who maintained the standard "all-you-can-eat" Internet plan for a flat monthly price.

Verizon Wireless similarly claimed that its wireless broadband service was "unlimited" until an investigation by ConsumerAffairs.com's Joseph Enoch found that usage even slightly higher than surfing the Web or checking one's email could get the account canceled. Verizon Wireless later stopped referring to its service as "unlimited."

As it became more likely that the FCC would punish Comcast for its content blocking, discussion of metered broadband as an alternative to content blocking grew louder in technology and communication circles. But Turner said that these discussions have been going on for years. "If this speculation were really a canary in the coal mine for a future of metering, broadband consumers might have cause for concern," he said. "But history indicates that these murmurs from industry are nothing more than trial balloons."

Morton's Fork

If companies were to adopt metered broadband plans, Turner said, it would be detrimental to their long-term business future. Internet users are taking advantage of high-speed connnections to not only share files, but create, upload, and view video content, and bandwith caps or limitation pricing would discourage usage by all except those who could afford to pay for exceeding the caps.

Some companies might implement bandwith caps or by-the-byte plans to discourage people from using video sites such as YouTube or Joost in favor of the company's own offerings, Turner said, which would make it a matter of breaching antitrust law. Both the FCC and Congress would be empowered to investigate and prevent any such violations.

"Making consumers choose between having applications blocked and limitation pricing is what economists call a Morton’s Fork," Turner said. "Neither path is desirable because they both have the same outcome: reducing the innovative power of the Internet."



Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Share

Follow us on Twitter.

FREE CONSUMER NEWSLETTERS

The Daily Consumer
Afternoons M-F

Sign up now!


Consumer News & Alerts
Every Sunday

Sign up now!





CONSUMER NEWS

SAFETY RECALLS

Back to the top |

Advertisement


Custom Search
AUTOMOTIVE
• Dealers
• Manufacturers
• Service
• Extended Warranties
• Lemon Laws
• Recalls
• Tires
• Transporters

FAMILY
• Aging
• Children, Parenting
• Recalls
• Dating
• Education
• Entertainment
• Pets
• Weddings
FINANCE
• Annuities
• Banks
• Credit Cards
• Debt Collection
• Debt Counseling
• Insurance
• Investing
• Loans
• Mortgages
• Payday Loans
• Student Loans
• Tax Prep

HEALTH
• Doctors
• Drugs, Pharmacies
• Health Clubs
• Hearing Care
• Hospitals
• Nursing Homes
• Nutrition, Diets
• Vision Care
• Weight Loss
HOUSE & HOME
• Appliances
• Cookware
• Furniture
• Home Improvements
• Lawn & Garden
• Movers
• Pools & Spas
• Realtors, Rental Agents
• Recalls
• Utilities

ELECTRONICS
• Cable TV/DBS
• Cameras
• Cell Phones
• Computers
• Home Electronics
• Internet Access
• Local Phone Service
• Long Distance
• VoIP
SHOPPING
• In-Home
• Online
• Retail Stores
• Sporting Goods
• Supermarkets
• Telemarketers

TRAVEL
• Airlines
• Bus Lines
• Car Rental
• Cruises
• Hotels
• Travel Agents
• Trains

RESOURCES
• Class Actions
• Complaint Form
• Small Claims Guide
• Lemon Laws
CONSUMER NEWS
• Latest News
• Automotive
• Telecom
• Financial
• Health
• Homeowners
• Scams
• Seniors
• Travel
• More ...

RECALLS
• Automotive
• Children's Products
• Drugs
• Food
• Household Products
• Sporting Goods

ABOUT US
• FAQ
• Privacy Policy
• Advertise With Us
• Newsroom
• Syndication
• Terms of Use

Terms of Use Your use of this site constitutes acceptance of the Terms of Use

Advertisements on this site are placed and controlled by outside advertising networks. ConsumerAffairs.com does not evaluate or endorse the products and services advertised. See the FAQ for more information.

Company Response Welcome If complaints about your company appear on our site, we welcome your response. Please see the Response Form for more information.

For more information, see the FAQ and privacy policy. The information on this Web site is general in nature and is not intended as a substitute for competent legal advice.  ConsumerAffairs.com Inc. makes no representation as to the accuracy of the information herein provided and assumes no liability for any damages or loss arising from the use thereof. 

Copyright © 2003-2009 ConsumerAffairs.com Inc.  All Rights Reserved.    The contents of this site may not be republished, reprinted, rewritten or recirculated without written permission.