Complain about a product or service

Administration, OPEC See Different Causes Of Oil Surge

Financial speculation and a weak dollar are the prime suspects

By Mark Huffman
ConsumerAffairs.com

June 4, 2008

• Gas Prices Fall for 37 Days • Gas Prices Slide 8 Percent from Record • Gas Prices Creep Down • Oil Price Trend May Be Good News For Consumers • Gasoline Drops Below $3.90 a Gallon • Gas Prices Pull Back Slowly • Oil Prices Fall As Storm Misses Rigs • Latest Gas Price Round-Up • 'Run Your Car On Water' Scheme Could Leave Consumers All Wet • Unregulated Energy Trading Blamed for Much of Gas Price Gusher • Airlines Join Effort To Limit Oil Speculators • Questions Raised about MyGallons.com • 'Hypermiling' Is Dangerous, Says AAA • Struggling Drivers Blame Washington for High Gas Prices • What’s Really Fueling Those Sky-High Oil Prices • Credit Card Fees at the Pump are a 'Hidden Tax' on Consumers • Survey: 3 Out of 4 Angry About High Gas Prices • $2 A Gallon Gas Possible, Analysts Tell Congress • Speculators Buy More Oil Contracts Than Oil Companies • Saudis to Pump More Oil • Limiting Oil Speculators Gains Ground • Congress To Probe Oil Price Spike • Oil Market 'Saturated,' Iran Claims • Feds See No Relief from High Gas Prices • High Gas Prices Could Mean Lower Insurance Rates • High Gas Prices Good For Kia, Honda • Gas Prices Rip Past $4 and Keep Climbing • Administration, OPEC See Different Causes Of Oil Surge • Feds Probing Possible Oil Market Manipulation • Beware of Fuel Sippers Sipping High-Test • Retailers Respond to High Gas Prices with Discounts, Promotions • Rushing Into a Smaller Car Too Soon May Not Save Money • Hybrid Sales and Prices Climb in Lockstep with Gas Prices • Truckers Bemoan Burden of High Diesel Costs • Gas Prices Biting into Worker Productivity • Consumers Warned About Gas-Saving Schemes • Is Tony Soprano Controlling Gas Prices? • Oil & Gas: The New Bubble • Critics: New Federal Gas Mileage Standard Falls Short • Consumers Feeling Pain of Skyrocketing Gas Prices • New Gas Price Record Forecasts Expensive Summer Driving Season --- • More ...

What's behind the ever-climbing price of oil? Depends who you ask.

The U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission says it is investigating whether speculation among traders in the spot oil market is behind the surge, a notion discounted by a top Bush Administration official.

In the Middle-east last week, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson rejected that view. He told reporters that the facts show that oil supply and demand is solely responsible for the price of oil going over the $130 a barrel mark last month. Some investors agree, saying market fundamentals are at work.

But that's not how the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries sees it.

Chakib Khelil, the president of OPEC, said last week the combination of market speculation and the declining U.S. dollar is the main reason for oil's record rise. That view is also held by a growing number of members of Congress.

Congressional Democrats this week opened discussions on way to limit speculation in the crude oil markets. Sen. Maria Cantwell (D-WA) held out little hope for the CFTC investigation, calling the commission "a toothless tiger." She called on the CFTC to revisit last year's investigation of the West Texas Intermediate Oil Contract on the Dubai Exchange. The commission concluded its probe without taking action.

Other analysts say everyone may be right, at least to some extent. They say market speculators may have taken advantage of growing demand and a declining dollar to place bets on oil going higher.

Joseph Stanislaw, CEO at JAStanislaw Group, told Bloomberg News that speculators are, in fact, playing the commodities market. But he says they are simply following fundamentals in placing their bets, not manipulating the market in one direction or the other.

Oil prices hit $135.09 a barrel on May 22. Government data shows that about that time, hedge-fund managers and speculators, in significant numbers, reduced their bets that oil would go even higher. Oil prices have since fallen almost $10 a barrel.

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Back to the top |