Complain about a product or service

Manhunt 2: Pushing the Limit of Gore and Violence

Video games deliver new levels of realism & sadism

By Joseph S. Enoch
ConsumerAffairs.com

November 3, 2007     Spanish

Source: Rockstar Games

While Rockstar Games watered down some of the expected gore in Manhunt 2 so that it could be released in the U.S., the game still has plenty of brutal violence, gore, profanity and sex.

The game gained notoriety when word got out that Rockstar Games, maker of the controversial Grand Theft Auto series, was designing a sequel to 2003's Manhunt that was going to push the limits of video game violence.

Many are saying the game is just too violent and too real and the game has been banned from the United Kingdom.

ConsumerAffairs.com picked up a copy to see just how violent is “too violent.” Short answer: quite.

The game starts in an asylum where you take control of Danny Lamb, an inmate who, through an electrical malfunction, gets out of his cell. All the psychos in the place have escaped with you and are tearing each other and all the nurses and doctors to pieces. You do your share of “tearing” as another inmate, Leo helps guide you out of the Asylum.

The horrific scenes and acts in the first level are pretty tame compared to the violence that is to come.

Dark aura

The game has, appropriately, a dark aura. Almost no scenes take place during the day, and you guide your character in and out of the shadows waiting for your next victim. The video is somewhat fuzzy, as though you were watching on a worn VHS. Throughout the game, your eyes and ears are a psychotic killing machine.

You can use almost anything as a weapon: a shard of glass, a plastic bottle, pliers, a shovel, a shotgun, a surgeon's saw, an ax, even a plastic bag. Sometimes you use your surroundings, such as drowning your victim in a toilet or trapping him in a torture device.

As you lurk in the shadows, you wait for your victims to walk by and attack them while they're not looking. Should you get into a brawl, your victim's face will be smashed by your fists, hammer, or whatever weapon you're holding at that time. At the end of any encounter, Danny is covered in blood -- his own or, in most cases, someone else's.

Bad neighborhood

• Can Active Video Games Help Prevent Obesity? • Effectiveness Of Activity-Promoting Video Games Measured • Final Fantasy Suit Alleges Hidden Fees, Penalties • California Petitions Supreme Court To Enforce Video Game Law • Study Suggests Video Games Are Addictive • Video Games Blamed For Poor Family Relationships • Researchers Study Wii's Impact on Fitness • Kids Burn More Calories Playing Active Video Games • Study Questions Effect of Violent Video Games • Active Video Games No Substitute for Exercise • Why Are Men More into Gamesmanship? • Study Measures Impact of Media Violence • Manhunt 2: Pushing the Limit of Gore and Violence • Kids Spending More Time Playing Video Games • Parents Urged To Monitor Kids' Video Games • Fight Over Manhunt 2 Could Get Nasty • The Addictiveness of Virtual Violence • Study: Video Games May Sharpen Vision • Mayo Clinic Study Endorses Concept Behind Nintendo's Wii • Researchers Find Video Games Addicting • Report Finds Progress in Keeping Violent Video Games Out of Kids' Hands • Researcher Urges Parents To Reconsider Giving Video Games • Violent Video Games Leave Teens Emotionally Aroused --- Hardware & Programs • Is Nintendo's Wii Really Good Exercise? • Nintendo Wii: The Buzz Goes On • Nintendo Says It Can’t Meet Wii Holiday Demand • Injuries Grow Along With Wii Popularity • Nintendo's Wii Spreads Mayhem as Wiimote Goes Flying • Nintendo Sued Over Broken Wii Strap • Nintendo Recalls Straps For Wii Controller • Gamers Favoring Wii over PS3 • Nintendo Purchasers Complain of Gamesmanship • Nintendo, Sony Offer Competing Visions Of Video Games • PlayStation 3 Takes the Field • PlayStation 3 Brings Big Bucks on eBay • Gamers Complain "Dead Rising" Fatal to Microsoft Xbox

As you help Danny piece together his violent past, you wander into some of the filthiest and most disturbing locales conceivable. Many of the buildings appear as though they could hurt you just by looking.

One of those buildings was a fetish club – part of a level called “Sexual Deviants.” The men in the place are all wearing leather masks and mutter things such as, “I shouldn't have eaten that gall bladder.” While some of the comments are silly, most are profane. No word or phrase is sacred in Manhunt 2.

While the deviants enjoying the sights and sounds upstairs at the fetish club were surprising, the torture chamber downstairs came as a real shock.

It had a similar essence to the modern Saw or Hostel films as the sounds of bones being snapped and men screaming filled the silence that persists through much of the game.

At one point, you even have a shootout in an X-rated movie theater while porn is playing on the screen behind you. Not something most of us experience everyday.

While video gamers have launched attacks in strip clubs and porno movie theaters in past games, including the classic Duke Nukem 3D, the creepy visuals and realistic sounds in Manhunt 2 make it much more vivid.

No question, Manhunt 2 is intense. After playing for a few minutes every small sound will make you jump.

Minimal dilution

It is clear in some cases that Rockstar Games diluted the violence, most notably during the attacks on unsuspecting prey.

While your character is performing horrendous acts, such as beheading an individual with a crowbar, you actually see very little of that. The game becomes very dark and blurry during these violent fits and all the shots appear calculated to just miss the bloody action.

For the Nintendo Wii version, you do actually act out the actions with your hands, but they only vaguely correlate to what actually takes place on the screen.

Roockstar Games did not censor any of its sounds, however. The slicing sounds that accompany an individual being delimbed with garden shears or the crunching noises of a bad guy being stabbed through the skull with a syringe are frighteningly realistic.

Toward the end of the game, many of your victims succumb to bullet wounds. Although they often end in someone's head exploding, the gunshots are not as graphic as the combat with random objects.

Body count

Manhunt 2 is easily the most graphic game I've played. While the actual body count is lower than the many war games or the popular Half-Life series, the way in which I was sneaking and attacking, made each casualty much more realistic.

It's difficult to compare digital blood to film blood, but based on the language and sex, parents who don't allow their children to watch R-rated films should keep them away from this game.

Like second-hand smoke, children shouldn't be in the same room as Manhunt 2.

Not much research

Dr. Don Shifrin, a committee member of the American Academy of Pediatrics' Media Violence Board, said there's little research so far on the effects of violent video games on children. But he said that he believes it can lead to short-term desensitization to the value of human life and that for children seven and under, may make them perceive the world as a violent and mean place.

He said there are some positives to video games: they may teach children logic, persistence and patience.

Shifrin was aware of Manhunt 2 but had not yet seen it in action.

He said if parents are considering buying a game for their children, they should not trust the Entertainment Software Review Board's rating system because many games rated Teen should be rated Mature and that the game descriptions that come with the ratings give no real indication of what is going on in the game.

Manhunt 2's Mature rating says: “Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Strong Language, Strong Sexual Content, Use of Drugs.”

Concerned parents should check out www.gamespot.com where video game makers post trailers of their games that give a more accurate view of what is taking place than what can be read on the back of the box at the store, Shifrin said.

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Share		Follow us on Twitter.