1. Skip to navigation
  2. Skip to content
  3. Skip to sidebar




PhotoAfter your home and your car, your mattress just might be the most important purchase you make. After all, you will probably spend a third of your life on it.

But shopping for a mattress can be an experience with many pitfalls. You can do your homework on the best mattress for your needs, negotiate a fair price, and still not get what you paid for.

Cynthia, of Palmyra, Va., purchased a new mattress from Mattress Discounters and even took a pass on having it delivered, sending her husband to pick it up.

“When my husband went to pick it up, they said it wasn't there but they had a better mattress that they would give us at the same price,” Cynthia wrote in a ConsumerAffairs post.

But her husband had no way to know whether the mattress was actually better or not. He could have taken some time to look it up on the Internet and read some reviews, but since he was in the store, he said “Okay,” and took the “better” mattress.

Losing sleep

“Since day one, I have been in pain and missing sleep,” Cynthia writes. “ A month after we purchased it, the box spring broke. We tried to return the mattress a week after we got it, but were told we had to wait the 60 days. After much complaining, the salesman agreed to let us return and said his manager would call. It never happened! Basically, we are out over $1000 and no mattress. I would personally rather burn this mattress than sleep on it.”

PhotoEven when you research a mattress' specs, you need to make sure you understand all the terms. Ken, of Missouri Valley, Iowa, reports paying $900 for a Sealy mattress with a four-inch memory foam top that almost immediately developed a dip in the middle. But he found he couldn't return it.

“We dug out our receipt and found out it was sold to us as the last one of a discontinued model and with no guarantee or warranty,” he writes. “We went down and discussed it with the sales manager in the mattress dept and he said some of them do that. Heck, I wish he'd told me that before I shelled out $900.00.”

$99 fee to check it out

Debra, of Bolingbrook, Ill., says she also encountered a sag in the mattress she purchased at The Bedding Experts, at a cost of $1,800. She called the store where she bought it and said it was defective and she wanted a replacement. She learned that just finding out if it were defective would be costly.

“Three days later I get a call from Rick in the Joliet store who tells me that the dip in the mattress has to be more than 1 1/2 inches deep and I would have to pay $99 to have someone come to my house to measure the dip and take pictures of it,” Debra wrote at ConsumerAffairs. “Then if it was determined that it was defective, I would have to drive to the Joliet store to get a new mattress of the same kind.”

You will probably have best results if you arrive at the store with a truck or van capable of carrying the bedding, should you find something and decide to buy it. If the display mattress you want isn't in stock, keep looking. That avoids the problem of the wrong mattress arriving at your home.

Not something you want to buy online

That pretty much rules out buying a mattress online. Yes, the advertised price may sound great but a mattress is a product with which you should get up close and personal. The two of you are going to be spending a lot of time together.

Remember, a warranty is different than a comfort guarantee. A warranty covers materials and workmanship and little else. But a retailer or manufacturer who allows you to return the mattress in a reasonable period of time if it's uncomfortable will likely give you both a better product and shopping experience.


Share your Comments

Please enable javascript to comment on this page
Suzanne Bierer
I went through four defective mattresses last year. All were "top of the line" and deemed defective by independent mattress inspectors within one month. Sleep deprived, in pain and at my wits end, I researched the issue online. All I could find to explain this debacle was that industry standards had been loosened dramatically under the Nixon administration. Not making a political statement... just acknowledging that manufacturers have clearly taken advantage of the opportunity to diminish quality while raising prices. Very disappointing...
Suzanne Bierer
I went through four defective mattresses last year. All were "top of the line" and deemed defective by independent mattress inspectors within one month. Sleep deprived, in pain and at my wits end, I researched the issue online. All I could find to explain this debacle was that industry standards had been loosened dramatically under the Nixon administration. Not making a political statement... just acknowledging that manufacturers have clearly taken advantage of the opportunity to diminish quality while raising prices. Very disappointing...
Donna McLaren
I still have an $800 Queen mattress set I got back in 1995. I have both the mattress and box spring sealed in dust & dust mite protectors. It's a flippable, and considering how old it is, there's only very slight dips, impressions. I wanted to buy a new mattress set several years ago, but when I found out they no longer make flippable mattresses, and the newer ones get severe dips in them after a very short period of time, I decided I would just keep my old mattress set and not lose my money on something that would be far worse. I bought a latex topper and it made my old mattress even better. The fact of the matter is... mattresses these days are nowhere near the quality they used to be.
Donna McLaren
I still have an $800 Queen mattress set I got back in 1995. I have both the mattress and box spring sealed in dust & dust mite protectors. It's a flippable, and considering how old it is, there's only very slight dips, impressions. I wanted to buy a new mattress set several years ago, but when I found out they no longer make flippable mattresses, and the newer ones get severe dips in them after a very short period of time, I decided I would just keep my old mattress set and not lose my money on something that would be far worse. I bought a latex topper and it made my old mattress even better. The fact of the matter is... mattresses these days are nowhere near the quality they used to be.
Karen Elise Peterson
frankly this is something that makes me burn just thinking about it. After separating from my partner I got an apartment and needed all new furniture. I decided to splurge on beautiful beds for my daughter and I. nightmare is all I can say. The half price and still nearly $2000 deluxe Sterns & Foster I bought, with a stainguard guarantee and a 15 year warranty sagged in the centre immediately. a horrible man came and put a yard stick across it and measured the dip - at the end of the business day, when it had risen as much as possible after a horrible nights sleep where you felt like I was a hotdog in a big bun, and told me my house was crooked and that that was the problem (rolled a marble across my floor). and that the bed wasnt dipped enough in the centre (needs to be 1.5 inches and at the time he measured it was just over 1 inch - but in the morning easily it would have been 2.5 inches) plus he was sure there were "soiling and discoulouration on it that would void the warrantee anyways.) I could try again in 6 months, but the "stains" couldn't be there and that they only accept professional cleaning. I could barely see what he was talking about, but called the stainguard folks and they said they don't clean everyday spotting, just if I did something like spill a cup of tea. again reiterating only professional cleaning was permitted (the stain guard was an extra cost on this product, too btw) complaining to the store where I bought it did no good at all. I would like to light it on fire in the middle of their showroom. I asked a friend who has a cleaning company if there was anything special about how a professional would clean my mattress and she said - "no" - just using the furntiure attachment for the steam cleaner. also bought a Sealyfrom sears recently and the box spring broke instantly making weird noises when you sat on the bed. They replaced that saying they were so cheap and brittle that they see them all the time. replacement box spring snapped too. my parnter opened the fabric backing and reenforced the wood slats himself rather than waste in the environment another boxspring. this whole business is shoddy and no amount of money paid guarantees anything.
Karen Elise Peterson
frankly this is something that makes me burn just thinking about it. After separating from my partner I got an apartment and needed all new furniture. I decided to splurge on beautiful beds for my daughter and I. nightmare is all I can say. The half price and still nearly $2000 deluxe Sterns & Foster I bought, with a stainguard guarantee and a 15 year warranty sagged in the centre immediately. a horrible man came and put a yard stick across it and measured the dip - at the end of the business day, when it had risen as much as possible after a horrible nights sleep where you felt like I was a hotdog in a big bun, and told me my house was crooked and that that was the problem (rolled a marble across my floor). and that the bed wasnt dipped enough in the centre (needs to be 1.5 inches and at the time he measured it was just over 1 inch - but in the morning easily it would have been 2.5 inches) plus he was sure there were "soiling and discoulouration on it that would void the warrantee anyways.) I could try again in 6 months, but the "stains" couldn't be there and that they only accept professional cleaning. I could barely see what he was talking about, but called the stainguard folks and they said they don't clean everyday spotting, just if I did something like spill a cup of tea. again reiterating only professional cleaning was permitted (the stain guard was an extra cost on this product, too btw) complaining to the store where I bought it did no good at all. I would like to light it on fire in the middle of their showroom. I asked a friend who has a cleaning company if there was anything special about how a professional would clean my mattress and she said - "no" - just using the furntiure attachment for the steam cleaner. also bought a Sealyfrom sears recently and the box spring broke instantly making weird noises when you sat on the bed. They replaced that saying they were so cheap and brittle that they see them all the time. replacement box spring snapped too. my parnter opened the fabric backing and reenforced the wood slats himself rather than waste in the environment another boxspring. this whole business is shoddy and no amount of money paid guarantees anything.
Stuart Ezrin
Another issue with mattress's is the toxic flame retardant chemicals such as formaldehyde, boric acid, antimony which is chemically related to arsenic. There are "Organic Mattress's out there that use wool to pass the flame test. I would recommend one with springs for better support to the spine.
William Holcomb
My wife and I purchased a mattress, foundation, and frame, to ensure that everything was new. The mattress had a two year warranty. The edges began to sag within weeks. I called the store and was told a small sag at the edges was normal, that it would not increase and should not affect our sleep. But to contact them if it did get worse. A year later the sag was so bad we could only sleep in the middle. After complaining, for a fee, an inspector came out. The edges sagged 3 1/2 inches and bulged 5 inches on each side. The store said we did not have a proper frame, but would give us a 20% discount. I countered with a lawsuit offer. We got a full discount on the cost of the mattress.
Bruiser Mann
After over 15 back surgeries I finally found a great back surgeon that explained to me that since you spend so much time in a bed that a proper mattress was a must! He told me to get a sleep number mattress as it wouldn't have any problems and would last a long time. I had a lot of reservations about sleeping on a mattress like that but I have bought several for my house over the years and while my friends have had nightmares with conventional beds and problems associated with them I had two problems and the factory sent out a replacement piece no questions asked. I travel a lot and no matter how nice the hotel is I can't wait to get back to my sleep number bed.
Bruiser Mann
After over 15 back surgeries I finally found a great back surgeon that explained to me that since you spend so much time in a bed that a proper mattress was a must! He told me to get a sleep number mattress as it wouldn't have any problems and would last a long time. I had a lot of reservations about sleeping on a mattress like that but I have bought several for my house over the years and while my friends have had nightmares with conventional beds and problems associated with them I had two problems and the factory sent out a replacement piece no questions asked. I travel a lot and no matter how nice the hotel is I can't wait to get back to my sleep number bed.
Janice Hood
What is the best brand to buy, without spending big bucks?
Janice Hood
What is the best brand to buy, without spending big bucks?
Mattress Inquirer
"Not something you want to buy online" This is extremely opinionated and bias. Here is a link to an "actual study" performed that shows testing in a showroom did not increase satisfaction when compared to buying online://www.rti.org/pubs/rr-0016-1108-hogan.pdf.
Quantcast