
Bobby of kannapolis, NC on Nov. 17, 2010
I "had" homeowners/renters insurance through Homesite insurance company/GMAC until the canceled me for filing a claim. I purchased homeowners insurance through this company in August 2010.
On October 8th, 2010, our barn style storage building was broken into and about $4000.00 worth of items were stolen including 1. Generator 2. pressure washer 3. Dewalt 4pc tool set. The "value" of the generator on the market today is about $3000 new, the pressure washer market value new is about $1200.00 and the Dewalt Tool set is about $500-$600 new.
I filed a police report and filed a claim with the insurance company. The policy I have is RC - Replacement Cost. At first, upon giving the report over the phone to the claims agent, she stated I needed to send in original receipts. She stated, they would not accept photos (being that anyone can get photos of the web), they would not accept box and/or original manuals, again, being that one can purchase them off the web. She stated they could only accept original receipts. I informed her that I did not have original receipts being that the items were purchased at a yard sale and at the flea market to which I wasn't supplied a receipt.
She asked if I could provide a bank statement around that time showing large amounts of money taken out of my account. I did send her those, as well, I still sent photos of the items I had on my property. (sort of hard to get a photo off the web of an item with my car and shed in the background). I never heard back from her stating that information was not acceptable. For weeks, they dragged their feet, never returned phone calls, never returned emails. Finally, 2 weeks ago, I emailed her once more, and I received an out of office reply stating she would be gone from the office for a week.
I called her supervisor, he informed me the claim would be re-assigned to another lady and she would call me to follow up. I sent the new claims agent several emails and phone calls. Out of about 6 emails and 3 phone calls, she finally emailed me stating that she was looking into the claim. Never heard back from her. Last Monday (November 8), I called the original claims adjuster since she should be back in her office. I spoke with her on the phone, she explained she was still over the claim and was playing catch up from being on vacation for a week.
She stated that the "valuation" for the items had been completed and she would send me an email with the break down. That was a week ago.Today, I called her once again this a.m. didn't get an answer on her phone, so I called her supervisor once again, now he is on a weeks vacation and is out of the office. I sent the claims adjuster an email informing her I was not at all happy with the lack of attention given to my claim and if I didn't get a response today, I would seek legal counsel.
She send me a follow up email with the spreadsheet showing me the breakdown on the claim. This is where it really ( excuse the language please) ** me off! Talk about low balling? Keep in mind, if these items were replaced, collectively, the cheapest I could find them around my area "new" was a combined $3800.00. The insurance company is sending me a settlement check for a little over $700 after the $500 deductible was taken out, as well as 10% depreciation of the items. Their "valuation" department is showing the $3000.00 generator at $500 to replace, around $2-300 for the $1200 pressure washer, and a couple hundred for the $5-$600 Dewalt 4pc 18 volt tool set.
The valuation form has links to websites showing "like" items for sell on various website that can be ordered, not local places. Dewalt is a name brand, very reliable tools. They show a link to a craftsman small electric screwdriver, a link to a cheap "Ryobi" drill, a knock off no name brand circular drill. The tool set also had a nice utility light. The sent me to a link in the valuation form to a $9 aluminum clamp lamp, not to mention, the Dewalt Tool set I had was all 18 volt, the links take you to items that are "14 volt".( sub standard to say the least). I sent her an email informing her I would not accept the check when it arrives as a settlement, rather, I would be sending it back to them and go to court if I have to.
She called back and stated that, "The replacement cost will only pay what I actually paid for the items when I purchased them, not what it would cost to replace new etc." This doesn't make since being that a lot of people have items that have been given to them, and not purchased by themselves. If I have items in my home that have been given to me, just because I did not pay for them, does that mean there not insurable? Doesn't make sense. So, to say they will only pay what I paid for them is crazy. What if those items had been given to me? No where in the policy does it state this as well. She stated that there is still $139.00 of mine they are keeping, once I purchase the items with the $700 check they are sending, and send them receipts, they will send me the rest of the money.
The whole thing stinks to me and is totally unfair to tell me that my belongings are worth about $1200 total when in fact, they are worth about $3600.00 or more, unfair. Not to mention, in the form I sent them when I filed the claim, I had to write down the estimated value of the items, I was told then to enter what "I paid" for them, not what they are "worth" sounds tricky! I informed them as far as the generator, I purchased it at a flea market a couple years ago and do not recall exactly what I paid, maybe a little over $500. In the official police report, it had it listed at $700 which is what I told the officer. I thought I had paid. I have since contacted a couple of Attorneys who say this is a clear case of "Bad Faith" on the insurance companies part. However, "most" law firms will not touch it unless they are to sue for many thousands of dollars!