
Emzy of Brownwood, TX on Aug. 31, 2010
I bought a Reliance 30 gallon LP heater for a ranch rental house, and it was a total nightmare. After installing it myself, I lit the pilot. Once the burner lit, it only burned yellow. Being aware that LP, like natural gas, should burn blue and that any LP-burning appliance is especially dangerous, I double-checked my ventilation, gas in, and fresh air intake. And after all my efforts, I called Reliance.
After being told that Reliance does not take returns, unless I have had their approved plumber in the area look at the unit, I called McCoy's where I purchased the heater. They stressed that I must deal with Reliance and that they could not take the heater back without Reliance's approval. Well, as luck would have it, I had another plumbing problem and had my plumber take a look at the heater.
He immediately determined that it was defective. The wire for the pilot striker had been routed in the path of the burner, so it quickly burned through after a few minutes of the burner being lit, causing the pilot to never light again. In addition, the unit didn't breath correctly causing the flame to dance around the bottom of the tank and eventually flame out.
We called Reliance again, and now, their staff commenced to argue with my plumber, saying that he wasn't qualified because he wasn't on their list of approved contractors. When I heard them giving him grief, I took the phone and informed them that I wasn't paying a master plumber with 14 years of experience $65 an hour to argue with some Reliance slacky with a book in front of them making $9 an hour about their out-of-the-box defective product.
What really drove me over the edge was when the Reliance employee told me "it could be fixed, and they would be willing to ship me a cleaning kit.. I lost it and not so politely informed her that the onus to repair their product was on them and not on me as the consumer. I also informed them of the fact that it could be fixed was good news for Reliance, because they could "fix" it and unload their POS on some other unsuspecting sap who was unfortunate enough to purchase a Reliance product, unsuspecting that they would be responsible for correcting Reliance's design flaws just in order to get their brand-new product to work.
After calling McCoy's and firmly reminding them about state lemon laws, McCoy's finally agreed to take the heater back after I brought my plumber along in tow to address any reluctance to do the right thing. I gave McCoy's mixed reviews, thumbs up for taking the unit back without too much resistance and thumbs down for carrying such a complaint-riddled line of products.
Reliance, on the other hand, has absolutely the worst customer service I have ever experienced, beating out my previous number one, Sprint, which I never thought could be surpassed in arrogance, uncooperativeness, and obtuseness. Berating customers who refuse to tolerate ice cold showers while awaiting "repair" kits so that they can "fix" the inherent design flaws in their out-of-the-box pieces takes the cake. Reliance: The absolute worst customer service experience ever.