
sherrie of norwalk, CA on Feb. 27, 2010
I bought my daughter's bed set from Living Spaces in La Mirada, CA on April 2008. When I purchased the set, the salesperson by the name of Lynn ** told me everything from intentional breaks, scratches, markers, kids destroying the bed set are all covered through a service called Guardian Protection. He said if they can not perform the repairs, a replacement will be made through the service free of charge. And if a replacement is not available, they will give me a refund for the full damage of the value of the non-repairable item.
On Feb. 23, 2010, I called into Guardian to make a claim to have some nicks and scrapes, and stains repaired. I got a rep named Ericka who asked me very specific questions about where and how big the scratches, nicks and stains were. She also needed to know the cause of these repairs. I told her that the nicks were from moving the furniture around but the stain I had on the nightstand could have been glue or juice. I said glue because I didn't think it mattered. It happened to be a light grape juice stain in a circular shape.
Ericka said I had to say specifically what it was or she could not file the claim. I told her it "might" be either and I wasn't home to see it. She put the stain down as glue, came back on the phone and told me that "glue" was not covered. I then told her it might be juice which is more likely because of the circular ring shape and purplish color. Then she told me that I specifically said it was glue. I then said that I specifically told her it "might" be either, but I wasn't sure.
I then asked her to speak to her supervisor which she refused. She put me on hold for a very long time and returned to say that she sent an email to the supervisor Alicia and they have 48 hours to respond. When I asked to speak to the supervisor again, she denied me and started telling me that I can't just make false claims and change my claim just to get my furniture covered. I told her that I didn't change it.
She forced me to give an answer when I told her I wasn't sure. Then I told her that the repair person would be able to tell if it was juice or glue and it wouldn't be any dishonest claim. She then said they are not allowed to come out and look at it and that my claim on the nightstand is no longer effective due to what I said the cause was. I was livid that she tricked me into putting a cause for the stain on there and held it against me when I specifically told her it could be either.
I asked to dispute the claim and then she said I couldn't and that she could not change what was already written. I really felt ripped off at that moment. Ericka then rudely had an attitude and asked if I wanted her to read the policy to me and started speaking over me the entire time loudly and rudely like a child. I could not believe this at that moment. I asked to speak to the supervisor again while she was rudely arguing and speaking over me. She hung up the phone on me. I then called back and spoke to a different rep and told her to leave a message for a supervisor about this complaint.
I didn't trust that Erica had left the complaint for the supervisor. On Feb. 24, 2010, a supervisor named Alicia called me back and told me that my claim for the nightstand could not be honored. I told her that I checked the night stand and in fact, it had been juice that created the ring shape stain. She then said since I said it was "glue" stain, I could not change it and they could not change it!
Not only that, she went on to tell me that I can not change things around just to get covered. I could not believe what I was hearing. I was being frauded by the rep and now, the supervisor. I then brought up the conversation with Erica, the sales rep, and then out of nowhere, Alicia the manager cut me off and went on telling me that I put that rep through a hard time and she had to take a break afterward.
I explained to her how the claim questions began and immediately without even listening to me explain (as a paying customer), she cut me off and told me she was sitting right there next to Erica during the call and that Erica had spent too much time on the phone with me. At that moment, I knew I wasn't going to get anywhere and that it was biased so I said, "If you're claiming that you were right next to her during this call, then you would know that she yelled at me at the end and hung up on me right?". Alicia replied, "Well I was across the room".
She made a point to me to tell me she was right next to Erica during the whole conversation with me and backed her up 110% of the way and suddenly, when I bring up the fact that she hung up on me, she totally disregarded it and changed the facts to "right next to her" to "across the room". I told her to check the call logs to see if the call was recorded so that she can listen with her own ears how rude Erica was and that she blatantly hung up on me. Alicia went on to back up Erica and disregarded my complaint. I asked what she was going to do to resolve this issue and she said it was confidential and she will not discuss anything with me. Basically, she never showed any concern for her rep's unprofessionalism. She told me that I had to send a claim form in and pictures. She also told me she would email me the form and that I had until March 3rd to fax in a copy of the receipt. I said okay.
I never received any email from Alicia for the claim forms so on Friday, Feb. 26, 2010, I called back and got in touch with Alicia again. I told her that I didn't receive the email for the claim. She then went on to say that they are not going to cover the glue stain. I told her I checked the stain when I got home and in fact it is juice stain. She said "Nope! Sorry, you can't just change it to cover what you need. If we allowed everyone to do that, we would have thousands of claims a day".
At this point, I couldn't believe this! Alicia then proceeded to say that since I was dissatisfied with the service, she will give me a refund. I was livid. I told her I didn't pay for insurance and then cancel right when I need it. What was the point in purchasing it in the first place? They didn't even attempt to file a claim for the other nicks and scratches that were covered and here she is, disregarding the entire claim and telling me to get a refund. I told her "no". I gave her my email again and she said she would make sure my claim gets to me within 10 minutes. Nothing came and now it's Saturday. I tried to call numerous times but they are closed and I still haven't received anything. I also have to fax in a copy of my receipt by March 3rd. My furniture is not covered when in fact it should be under warranty and policy.