I rent a house in New Mexico and a water heater in an attachment to the house went out. My landlord, who lives in another state, made a trip out and purchased a brand new 30-gallon water heater from Home Depot. It was installed this past Saturday by her handyman that she has used for years. Upon completion of the installation, the handyman told his trainee that it was important to make sure it was full before turning it on since this was an electric heater. He turned on the water to the heater and then the faucets and pressure relief valve. When all were putting out water, he shut all the valves, waited 5 additional minutes, then turned on the power. The install was great and I would have hot water in a bit. It worked great and things were all peachy - or so I thought.
Yesterday, my son woke up out in the apartment to water the covering of the floor. I turned off the power and water. And upon inspection, the water heater was spewing water from the top heating element. I sent a message to my landlord who had gone home. She called GE and they gave her a runaround, but finally told her to get a licensed plumber to come and look at it because we must have "dry fired" it and it was our fault. So I was able to get a guy out here today. He came in and metered the element. No continuity - so bad element. He took it out, inspected it, and there was only about 3 inches of one side of the element. The rest is just gone. He told me that there are wrench marks already on the element and that it looked like it was used. I told him that the unit is new and the label even says it was manufactured April 2012. He insisted that it is used and that it looked like someone took a bad one and put it in this tank.
So I gave him the claim number and telephone number to the GE customer service department. He put on the speaker phone so I can hear the conversation. GE went through the whole thing with him: "did you meter it, did you do this, that and the other thing?" He told them yes to all, explained that he is a licensed, experienced plumber and that the element has old tool marks and looks used. GE said that since it is only the top element, they are not going to warrant it, it was dry fired and that made the old wrench marks, and we would have to pay for everything out of pocket. So I called the landlord and explained what is going on to her. She is livid. This thing is 5 days old and they are giving a runaround. She called GE and they agreed to warranty the parts and up to $125 in labor. But I was told to save the damaged one as evidence or some such.
So, while GE is going to warrant it at this point, I have to come up with an addition expenditure of money and go through the runaround GE gives. I recommend that anyone who reads this go with another brand. GE products are shoddily made and they will try every excuse possible not to take responsibility. It may cost an extra hundred or so upfront, but you will get that back not having to have a plumber out and be home on two different days (the plumber has to come back Monday; no one here carries the specific element to keep the unit in warranty) and not having to pay for it. Good luck and stay away from GE water heaters.

