
Barbara of Stafford, VA on Jan. 14, 2009
On Dec. 1, 2007 my husband and I were in Bassett Furniture Direct in Fredericksburg, Virginia to purchase a credenza for a new television and saw a dining table style we liked. We wanted to replace a table and chairs we have had for 24 years. Since we do not purchase furniture very often I wanted something that would last a long time and stand up to everyday living. Because of this, I was very concerned about the durability of the table top and the hardness of the wood. I did not want something that scratched and dented easily and explained this to Karen, our sales person. I also wanted to know if there were any customers who had any complaints about the table and if it did hold up to everyday living. We were reassured that we would have no problems with this table and the "Indurance" finish that is applied would stand up to everyday living. After much deliberation and wavering on my part we decided to custom order a 48 inch round dining table and four side chairs. We chose a Guilford stain for the leg and apron of the table as well as the seat of the chairs. We chose the body of the chairs to be painted in ebony.
The first problem was during delivery. We called and were told that the furniture was finally in and scheduled a delivery for February 7, 2008. Unfortunately, we only received the credenza and dining chairs. I called immediately about the dining table and was told that we should not have had the furniture delivered because the table was not ready. They apologized and we waited. After delivery I noticed right away that the finish on the credenza was marred and called Bassett back. I was told to call Customer Service, and speak to Brenda. By this time I had already scheduled the dining table to be delivered on February 19, so Brenda scheduled James, the furniture repair guy, to come and look at the credenza on the same day. Unfortunately, James arrived on February 19 before the table was delivered. He looked at the credenza and decided that a new top needed to be ordered through Brenda and it would take a few weeks.
In the meantime, I noticed that there were a couple of spots on the dining table top and on the edge that did not look right. They looked like a small pieces of white something, possibly dried milk spots, stuck to the table until I tried to remove them. It was then that I realized that it was the finish that was cracked and bubbly. I also noticed that the table top had a small indentation in it. The dining chairs also had some areas where the paint had either worn off or not been painted. I called Brenda with my concerns. She suggested that James take care of all my concerns? at one time when he came to put the new credenza top on. James came on April 8, 2008 with the new credenza top. Unfortunately, the credenza top was made wrong and had to be re-ordered. Because of this James opted not to work on the table and chairs. He wanted to wait until the new top was in and then he would take care of everything at one time. I asked him just to look at the indentation and the spots. He told me that the table was a very soft wood and dented easily and the spots were where the finish had bubbled up for some reason. His remark about the soft wood angered and frustrated me because I felt we had been misled by the salesperson. We were told something very different. As for the finish bubbling he had no comment other than nothing is perfect.
While we waited once again for the new credenza top, our dining table was subjected to our everyday living. I continued to notice new dents and a few more small white spots. I became more frustrated that this table was not living up to what we had been told. The latest credenza top finally arrived on May 20 with James. The credenza top was once again built wrong but with some drilling on his part, James was able to finally put the credenza together. He also finally addressed my concerns. He could do nothing about the dings in the soft wood of the dining table top but for the white spots he took some fine wool and some oil (I think) and tried to smooth them out. When I asked him about the finish and why it was bubbling he once again said that nothing is perfect.
After James left I thought about how we were misled and how this custom dining table was not living up to my standards. I called Brenda about my concerns. Our conversation went downhill fast. Brenda asked me what I wanted Bassett Furniture to do for me and I said I wanted someone from Bassett other than James to come and look at this custom dining table top and tell me that the quality was inferior and I wanted it replaced. Her words to me were, Mrs. you have not been happy with the furniture you bought from day one and have found many things wrong. You bought it, you live with it.? We are not going to help you anymore.? I was appalled and surprised that someone in Customer Service would treat a customer that way. After a frank discussion with my husband I let it go and chalked it up to experience? until December 31, 2008.
On December 31, 2008 I had the blinds open and the early morning sun shone on the table. The table top had an odd shadow on it so I took a closer look. I noticed a round opaque ring on the surface and tried to wipe it away. It was not dirt but a round water ring stain about 3 inches in diameter. I then noticed a second round water stain. I walked around the table a noticed two more round water ring stains. This is a dining table. Dining tables are not supposed to get water ring stains. And this table is only 10 months old. And this top has the Indurance finish which features the accident proof furniture finish.?
I immediately drove the 20 miles to Bassett and explained the problem to Jill, the manager, and was told that she would look into it for me. I assumed I would get a call back and have someone come and look at this custom table top. I waited until Thursday, January 8 and called Jill at Basset Furniture to follow up. She was off and I left a message. I called back on Saturday, January 10. Jill was busy and I left another message. I knew by this time I was not going to get a response from Jill. I called back on Monday, January 12, and received a recording that the store was closed for remodeling and would not re-open until February 2 at 10 a.m.
I could not let this end here so I went on-line and found a Bassett Customer Care number. I called the number and explained the situation. I read the woman what the Indurance pamphlet that came with the table said. It is as follows:
This top features the accident? proof furniture finish.
Because of the advanced nature of the Indurance (trademark) finish, you should follow these simple steps to maintain its beauty:
1. Use your tables as you normally would. Indurance by Bassett is designed to better protect against everyday use. You should not subject Indurance to more rigorous use.
2. For best results, clean with a non-ammonia window cleaner. Do not use furniture polishes; they create a thin film on the finish and dull its beauty.
3. Remember, Indurance is only on the top. Clean the sides and legs as you normally would with furniture polish.
4. Nail-polish remover (acetone) may be used to remove permanent marker, nail polish, and other materials. Apply nail polish remover to a soft cloth and rub the material until it is removed. DO NOT ALLOW THE NAIL POLISH REMOVER TO MAKE CONTACT WITH OTHER FURNITURE FINISHES!
5. Do not use an implement edge to scrape material from the surface. Saturate the material with water, let stand for 10-15 minutes, and rub with a soft cloth.
6. Wood is a soft porous material. Indurance cant protect against dents because the wood underneath will compress under extreme pressure.
I went step by step in my conversation regarding the accident? proof furniture finish.
1. We use our table normally. To have water ring stains on a table that you use normally means that something is wrong with the finish. We have not subjected it to rigorous use. I never have used placemats in the past but use them on this table to help protect the surface.
2. I have become very attentive? to this table. I clean the table top with a damp paper towel and then I wipe it dry. I am afraid to use anything else. I get upset when I see anything questionable on the table.
3. Indurance is only on the top and the top is what I have a problem with. It is not very durable if there are water ring stains in only 10 months of use.
4. As I said before, I do not use anything on this table top. I am afraid to.
5. I have not used any sharp implement to scrape material from the surface.
6. I have found that this table is very soft and in 10 months has many little dings on it. It is not at all what we told or what we thought we were buying.
I was told by Customer Care that the Fredericksburg store is an independent store licensed to sell Bassett and that my issue is with them and not Corporate Bassett. The only thing that Customer Care would do for me was to call and leave a message. Corporate Bassett would not help me in any way, not even to discuss the fact that their trademark furniture finish did not endure.
Bassett Furniture misled us during the sale concerning the quality of this table, Customer Service has been rude and are not customer service oriented, and they do not stand behind the quality of their product.