
Bryan of San Jose, CA on April 9, 2010
I made a credit card purchase of $115USD (the card purchase actually shown is $120USD, but I get a $5 discount) on or around 04/05/10. My online banking statement 04/07/10 showed that it went through on the 6th, leaving me a balance of $91.19. Planning on spending a little more money the next day, I checked my online account and I was (in less than 24 hours) -$193.90! I am a disabled person who lives on SSDI and only get $1091.00 a month to survive on. I have to be very careful with my money and I knew that after I'd spent that $115 that I'd have a little less than a hundred dollars to live on 'till my next check. So when I saw this, I immediately printed a copy of what I was seeing on my online account and went directly to my bank.
It is important to note that after spending the $115, I had made 5 more purchases for a total of $60.09 which still left me with a positive balance of: $31.10. Following the last transaction, it showed there were 3 $35 overdraft fees, for what I don't know! From what B of W's online banking showed, I still had a positive of $31.10!
Upon talking to a lady at the bank, she informed me that there had been a hold of an additional $120 placed on my account that had not been released (this was for the original purchase of $115 reflecting discount). I asked her to put a stop payment on the $120 because it was for the same purchase and the merchant had already received their money. She refused saying only they can release this "hold" and that I would have to take it up with the merchant which I did.
Here is our correspondence:
"Hi Bryan, Glad I could be of assistance. If the "pre-authorized" charge doesn't disappear after 5 days contact your bank with the authorization code for the transaction and get them to delete it for you - it is as follows: Authorization code: 191144 Our Merchant number is: 275149. Thank you for your patience. Kind Regards, Cat"
"Hi Cat, Thanks for returning my email. I figured it was probably something to do with my bank, although this is the first time this has happened, knowing the corrupt banks over here in the US, I wouldn't put anything past them. I've been a customer of yours for about 5 months now and you people have always been on the "up & up" with me. Right now they're sending me some form to fill out to contest the charge and the overdraft fees that the charge caused. By this time in the month for me, a small amount of money can put me in a world of hurt as I am on a small fixed income. Again, I thank you for getting back to me so quickly, and I will forward your letter to my bank to try and sort this out."
"With the new banking procedures, your card is only 'pre-authorized' when you enter your card details at our website. We do not actually charge your card until we have processed your order and deducted any discount you might be entitled to. The 'pre-authorized' status should automatically delete when the charge appears. However, we've been finding via customer feedback that some US banks list both the pre-authorized status and the completed charge at the same time. The pre-authorization normally deletes after 5 days. If the pre-authorized status is still listed after this time, please contact your bank to delete it from your account. I hope this information has been helpful to you. Please do not hesitate to contact us again if you have any further queries. Kind Regards, Cat"
"Subject: Re: Double Billing of Order Number:** Hi Tom -Bryan Here (Customer Number: **) I left a message on your voice mail regarding my being "double billed" for the following order. My checking account reflects a debit of $115USD on 04-05-2010 to Inhouse Pharmacy (The order was placed on 04-04-2010). Long story short, when I checked my online account balance on 04-07, I was showing 3 $35.00 USD overdraft fees which wouldn't have been there had Inhouse not double-billed me. I went to my bank and confronted them with this whereupon I was informed that there was a $120USD debit on my card from Inhouse (my online bank account did not show this, only the $35.00 O.D. fee). I would appreciate my credit card account be return credited as soon as possible. There is a dispute with the bank that will take a few days (apparently even though I can use this card as a "credit card", they can't, or won't just issue a stop payment on the card!) and I'd rather settle this with you guys than have to deal with a corrupt banking institution. If Inhouse didn't receive the supposed "$120USD" (everybody at the bank, including customer service tells me it hasn't gone through but they won't just cancel it! Sounds kind of fishy to me!), then I apologize, and I then will assume that Bank Of The West is trying to bilk me out of approximately $200USD ($120+Fees)! "
As you can see everything's in reverse. However, when Inhouse Pharmacy gave me the authorization code to release they basically said they weren't going to take that additional $120.. So I called Bank Of The West's customer service line again! I explained to them that I have the authorization code to have the hold on the $120 they effectively "stole" out of my account for the purposes of hoping that I would make more purchases so they could charge me overdraft fees! I explained to the lady (LuAnne -Customer Service manager) that nowhere on my online statement does it reflect any $120 "hold" on my acct. nowhere! And, had I known that I was actually spending $235, instead of $115, I would've managed my funds accordingly!
So, as it stands, as of 04/08/10, Bank Of The West has stolen: $120 (hold) + $140 in O.D. fees(at last count today), for a grand total of $260! What's worse is they are responsible for creating a situation by false and misleading information on their online banking site that gave them the excuse to steal money from a poor and disabled person. This is an outrage! Now, their holding my money hostage until and unless they get around to sending this form out to me to fill-out & send back to wait for them to decide if they're going to pay me back or not. Meanwhile, I have absolutely no money to live on until, of course, they run me through their "Red-Tape" and "bureaucracy" first! Meanwhile, how am I supposed to exist?
I believe (I have a print-out of the very page of my online statement) I have a very good case against them as there is absolutely no indication of a $120 hold on my account. None! Well, if you've read my letter above, I believe it speaks for itself. I also believe I should be entitled to damages (mental, physical, emotional and above all that, financial!) Also let it be known that they did this tortuously to a mentally ill person who lives on disability! Their "customer service" did nothing but give me the proverbial "run-around" and when being apprised of what had happened, stoically (when they had it in their power to do so) kept ignoring all the facts in the case which was just plain evil to to to a disabled person! I may suffer from severe depression (amongst other things), but I'm not stupid! So, in closing outside of financial, mental anguish is certainly on the list!