I signed a contract with It's Just Lunch (IJL), a dating service, after seeing an ad in an in-flight magazine. At the time, I was living in a small city, and having difficulty meeting men of interest in that area. I wanted to be able to meet compatible men in Charlotte, which is the closest large city. I drove down to Charlotte on 8/1/08 to meet with Sandra ** for an intial interview. The office was at **. I was impressed with Ms. **, and she promised me that given where I was living, they would find places to meet that would be halfway between both parties.
I signed a contract with them and paid $1,395 for 14 "dates". On the first arranged date, I was told to meet the date at a location an hour from where I live. The gentleman was pleasant enough, but did mention he lived 10 minutes away, and after an hour he said he had something to do with his kids and left. There was enough interest on both parts, that we did go on 2 more dates. I had difficulty getting IJL to listen to my concerns, and they consistently gave me grief about finding a halfway point that was convenient.
I went on 3 more dates, but kept them informed of my concerns about distant meetings, and continued to request better service. At the beginning of 2009, I learned the IJL office in Charlotte had been closed, and I would now be dealing with someone in FL. I found this to be ridiculous, and let them know the contract stated that they would "refund to the buyer at least ninety percent of the prorated cost of any unused services, within 30 days of request thereof, if: a. is irrelevant, b. also irrelevant, or c. the seller relocates his facility more than eight miles from its present location, or the services provided by the seller are materially impaired.
Given how unsatisfied I was with the services received, and that they closed the Charlotte office, I requested a refund based on this portion of the contract. I was told (after much difficulty) that I would have to go after Gray Sky, Inc., and that IJL Corporate was not responsible. I have a letter from Maritza, coordinating supervisor, dated 2/16/09 stating that "per your request, we are sending you the franchisee information. You must contact the Department of Corporations: Jessica, Gray Sky, Inc."
Needless to say this was an impossible task. I tracked down Ms. ** to a residence in Charlotte NC 28277, almost in SC, but was never able to get any response. I placed my membership with IJL on hold on 1/13/09, hoping they would either come to their senses and refund my money or improve their service. I made several calls over the next year to find out if they had opened another office in Charlotte, but they did not. I ended up moving to the Charlotte area on 10/30/09. I made contact with IJL when I moved here, and was told they had a rep in the area, but no office. They had her call me. She left a message. I returned her call, and left her a message and then never heard anything else. On 1/11/10, I took my membership off hold, because on 1/13, it would have been a year, and I would have just lost the money I paid them. I thought I would give them a chance, and see if things had improved.
My new contact, Lindsey, completed a phone interview to update my information. At the end of the interview, I was asking about their process, and she told me that "everyone goes through the same process". I corrected her, because when I signed on, I had to complete an in-person interview, before going on my first date, and now they do a phone interview, first date, then in-person interview. My point was they could be setting me up with someone they had not even met face to face. She promised she would do her best to not set me up with someone who was on their first date. When I received the information for the date, I was alarmed to see it was in the SW corner of Charlotte (at least 30 min away), while the location they kept wanting to send me to before, was now only 10 min. from my home.
I sent Ms. ** a polite email saying I wanted to "confirm" this location was a halfway point between us. She called me and said she had not checked that before, but now realized we could find a place to meet that was closer. Turns out, the gentleman and I only live10 minutes from each other. Once on the date, things went fairly well. Although he did tell me it was his first date with IJL. There was a decent connection and we decided to walk around the corner for coffee. We had been talking for almost 2 hours, when I asked him how long he has been divorced. Well, he's not divorced! He's separated, and the divorce won't be final for 6 months! So, now I've been out in the community on a date with a married man.
I sent Ms. Willis an email after the date letting her know that I was upset. The response was a call from yet another rep who was replacing Ms. W. She stated her name was Zahara. She looked at the gentleman's file and confirmed they knew his marital status, "his file says he's married, but separated". When I found the consumer affairs website, along with reading the complaints, I also read the response from the company. In the response Ms. Irene ** states, "if clients have spoken with the owner of their local offices, and remain unhappy with the service they are receiving, they should call us directly at the It's Just Lunch Support Office at **.
We can't fix the problem if we don't know about it!" I called the number on 2/22/10 (Monday). Ms. ** left me a voicemail message that afternoon, in which she apologized and stated she was passing the information to Julie **, and they would "get your issues resolved right away". Later in the message, she said she would "get everyone working on this right away". I received a call from Mariel within an hour. She listened to my summary of concerns, and informed me I was not eligible for a refund, because "we have matches for you". My complaint had nothing to do with whether or not they have matches for me.
She said she needed to look into the matter, and wanted to arrange a time to speak the next day (Tuesday). We coordinated this, and I offered to forward her an email my attorney had reviewed, which I planned to send to a local news station consumer investigations. I forwarded her this email the next morning, but never heard from her. Finally, on Thursday, 2/25/10, I called Ms. ** and left her a simple message letting her know I had not heard back from Mariel. I received an email from Mariel that afternoon stating "hi Catherine, you and I had spoken on Monday, and I have not yet received the documentation you had planned on sending me. I was out of the office Tuesday and Wednesday. Please give me a call, at your convenience, to further discuss your membership. I am in the office between the hours of 9AM and 6PM, Monday - Friday.
I look forward to speaking with you". I did not delete her last name from this email. It is only signed with her first name. I compared the email address and found it to be the same as where I had sent the message 2 days before. I resent it, and requested confirmation she had received it. I also stated I would call her the next morning. I called her at 9:30 AM on Friday, 2/26. There was no answer, so I left a message, and sent another email. Incidentally, the recording on the voicemail for the number on her email says that the "call will be responded to within 24 business hours".
I heard nothing by phone or email and on Monday at 11:30, I tried the number for Mariel again, when she did not answer, I called and left yet another message for Ms. **, letting her know the above, and that if I was not contacted by the end of the day, I would move forward with seeking resolution through other means. Ms. ** called me back a few minutes before 5 PM that day, again apologetic and stating "this is not how it is supposed to be". That evening, I received another email from Mariel saying, "hi Catherine, I'm sorry I couldn't reach you today.
I was tied up in meetings. Please give me a call to further discuss your membership, or, provide me with a time when it's most convenient to reach you. Also, I still have not received the information you were referring to. It would help me greatly to have as much information regarding your account. Please send it to the email address below. I am in the office between the hours of 9AM-6PM EST Monday - Friday. I look forward to speaking with you",
I responded that she could literally call me at any time, and if I was not able to pick up I should be able to get back with her in 20 minutes or less. She finally called me on 3/4/10, more than a week after the day she was originally supposed to call me. She stated she had not received any of the 4 or 5 emails I had sent. I suggested there may be someone else in her office, whom I could send the email to, to see if that would produce a better result. She asked if she could call me the next day at 10 AM.
I said that was fine, and we could see if the email went through, and if not, I would try sending it by fax. Well, it is the next day at 3 PM, and again no call nor email from Mariel. So I am posting this here for multiple reasons, so other consumers can be warned, so Mariel can see it, and get the details needed to respond to my complaint and so that Ms. Irene ** can recognize that her suggestion to contact this other phone number is not resulting in better, or even good customer service. I am so frustrated in dealing with this company. All I am asking them to do is live up to their contract, and refund my money (only the portion I am due $768.22).