I am desperate for some help with this issue, which is in fact with a Sony Product, a laptop. I think the best way to communicate this is via the following correspondence I have had with the retailer:
7 Jun 2010, 10:52 AM: "I have been very happy with the laptop, it's great, but there is a fly in the ointment unfortunately. You may or may not have heard of this problem depending upon the amount of models you sold. So here goes: While I was still in South America, I began to see marks on the screen (a light horizontal line) where the palm rest meets. I noticed increasingly that this line would not go with a good anti-static cleaning solution. However, I was not really in a position to take up the issue until my recent return to the U.K. I was comforted by the fact that my Z is still 2 months within the first year warranty.
I called Sony direct and after a while of telling me it 'may' be classed as an 'exterior fault', and thus, if returned, there would probably be a cost for repair, a few times over, I could not help become suspicious that the support person was perhaps being a little evasive of my issue. I've not owned a Sony laptop before and was quite frustrated by the lack of cooperation on an issue that reminded me of the original Mac PowerBook issues which were eventually sorted out on later versions. I did a bit of research first and found this thread; it's apparent Sony have also remedied this issue in the current Z-series line.
I bought what I considered to be one of the best laptops on the market at the time with complete faith in the manufacturer. I'm not satisfied with it, or my treatment, and require an adequate resolution. I feel there are 2 choices: (1) Obtain a similar version of the later Z-series, which I think is perfectly reasonable given the detail / cost / age / overall condition (excellent apart from this issue); or (2) Sell mine and buy another brand. Of course, this would involve taking a great hit on what I paid, which is unreasonable. As the vendor, I really could do with their support in this matter. BTW, whenever carried, it has been in an STM gel case and laptop bag, and it has been lovingly cared for."
15 June 2010: "This is urgent, Oliver, so I wish I knew your movements before you left. As only you probably know the full details, I'm guessing it's best to await your return, but please have some resolution for me Thursday as I only have a few weeks of the warranty left and I want to appeal to the ombudsman for these types of retail complaints and the UK equivalent to the US's 'Better Business Bureau' (as in the thread I posted the link too earlier about these Z-series issues) in pursuit of the appropriate response/action."
Their response, 21 June 2010: "My apologies for the delay, I have been waiting for an official response from Sony. I have spoken with my account manager at Sony, and he in turn, their Customer Relations Team. They have advised in short that the issue you have seen is down to how the item is used rather than a defect in the design of the item. They have offered to investigate your individual circumstance and have further advised that in order to identify if the item has a defect, it is very important to find out if the screen is naturally touching the keyboard. I have been told that in every case with a Z series presented to Sony, so far the answer has been no, and it has been possible to look through the closed VAIO and see daylight the other side. These marks come from pressure being applied to the screen pushing it onto the keyboard. Sony considers this as misuse rather than a defect in the design and will not be accepted liability if this is the case.
The official response is: 'Under normal use, the VAIO should not have pressure applied to the screen in order for it to bring it into contact with the keyboard. If this is unavoidable, please take steps to compensate for this. We would advise not to squeeze the VAIO while carrying it by hand or packing a bag so pressure is exerted on the area either. If these, too, are unavoidable, we suggest placing a cloth upon the keyboard. We recognize the tolerances to produce a powerful slim line low weight notebook are fine, but by design, these areas do not naturally meet.'
I would expect this simple test is something you are able to do quite quickly yourself. Therefore, if your VAIO is defective as above and you wish to return your VAIO for inspection, then please let me know."
21 June 2010: "Oliver, Please take a moment to read this very small section of a long thread about this issue: Ted ** replied 3 months ago: 'Success! After submitting the claim to the BBB, and speaking to a National Customer Relations Manager (the same department I spoke to about 8 months ago), they requested that I send in the laptop. I just got a voicemail from the Sony technician, who informed me that they are replacing the LCD (and hinges, they were loose). He left his phone number, so I will ask to have the newly designed palm rest. Either way, I have a new screen protector ready to install once the laptop gets back to me. I'd like to thank everyone that posted here, and I still will support anyone that may need help resolving this issue. I urge everyone that has this problem to submit it to the Better Business Bureau because they helped me resolve this issue! But I still would like to point out that it should not have gone this far for me to successfully have the screen replaced. Sony should recognize that the design flaw is a great inconvenience, and they should take more responsibility.'
As you see then, there are people who have had this issue resolved, and the new version of the Z addresses this issue which of course denotes some kind of tacit acceptance of the issue itself by Sony. I have been using the screen protector of late and have, as said previously, been extremely careful like many of the others on this posting when transporting it, but still the issue persists, and seems to be worsening no matter what I do. I am pressing this with various consumer protection agencies and would appreciate your continued support and any commentary you may have. How can some people get satisfaction with this and others not?"
Their response, 21 Jun 2010: "Sebastian, when the lid is closed on your VAIO without pressure on the lid, does the screen touch the keyboard/rest area? If so, then Sony have advised that the screen would be replaced."
21 Jun 2010: "It doesn't appear so, no. However, this hardly annuls the problem that the item is not designed to be transported, unlike the fantastic claims by Sony illustrated below. (Note to consumer complaints, there is a Sony advert which claims the laptop is/has: "Built to endure the most grueling business trips, the Z is always travel-ready. Strong, mullet-layered carbon fiber defends the LCD's exterior panel while the innovative display uses a special hard coating to minimize scratches; scratch-proof, anti-glare." This is clearly misleading and untrue advertising or we would not have this problem."
"Oliver, I do not want a screen to be replaced on a model that has a design flaw for the problem to only persist again and again. The only apt solution is for Sony to replace this version with the design flaw with the new version in which the design flaw has clearly been addressed, which in itself is a tacit admission. Why would this non-problem be addressed if it was indeed a non-problem? Ironically, it seems from the various commentaries that the extra expensive carbon version is where the problem is most pronounced. Very ironic indeed. I have to get something here, Oliver; they are trying to fob me off and this is not an acceptable reaction, whatever the what's and wherefores are. If this laptop was built to the specification advertised above, we would not be having this conversation. And, to quote the above, mine was not the "most grueling of business trips". Fortunately, as I suspect, the laptop would be in pieces by now."
Their response, 22 June 2010: "Sebastian, My account manager is in to see me this afternoon. I will discuss it with him then. However, as things stand, you have said it yourself, the screen does not touch the case when closed, the problem occurs due to how the item is handled/mishandled. The screen that was replaced in your correspondence to me previously has been replaced because the hinge casing had become loose causing the issue with the screen. Again, if you wish to return the item for inspection, we are more than happy to arrange this although if as you say the screen does not naturally touch the keyboard or rest it is likely that your claim for repair will be rejected. I will come back with an official response later today."
22 June 2010: "Oliver, you seem a decent enough chap so please do not give me that old Sony 'if you want to send it back for inspection' line again. You and I both know what that really translates, too. You are also intelligent enough to see the cause of my and all of these complaints, i.e. that you cannot even pick the bloody thing up in your hand without the screen touching the keyboard. Hardly makes it, quote, "Built to endure the most grueling business trips, the Z is always travel-ready. Strong, mullet layered carbon fiber defends the LCD's exterior panel while the innovative display uses a special hard coating to minimize scratches; scratch-proof, anti-glare." Big proclamations for a laptop that should read: "Built to endure sitting at your desktop and not being handled in any way whatsoever unless you want the super-sensitive screen mashed up with a ruddy great line straight through the middle of it you not only cannot remove but also cannot prevent if you want to move the item from one side of the room to the other while it is closed unless you design a pretty novel method with which to actually pick it up." I have a sense of humor, but it will only stretch so far. So, please, informed, thought-through, non-regurgitated responses only, with the greatest of respects. P.S. nice curved palm rest on the new design, isn't it?"
Their response, 23 June 2010: "Sebastian, my apologies if you feel my emails are a little regurgitated. I can understand your frustration and also concern regarding the line that has developed on your screen. After taking advice yesterday from Sony, I have been assured that this damage is not something that is or would be covered under the warranty. You have yourself said that the screen does not make contact with the keyboard or rest area under normal use, as such I am not able to help you any further with this issue. Apologies."
25 June 2010: "Oliver, it's clear Sony are stonewalling this, but just for the record, I said no such thing, unless you consider not being able to (carefully) pick up the laptop in any 'normal' fashion, i.e. when it is closed, without the line appearing after a short time. This fact was clearly communicated to you in my previous email, which I presume got no further than yourself. It is a perfectly valid complaint and it is preposterous that either you, your manager, or your Sony contact cannot and will not acknowledge this small and simple fact. You clearly have your company's relationship with Sony as a priority, which I appreciate, however the result is highly less than adequate service to at least one of your customers. I guess you are tired with my protestations now, and I am so sorry to trouble you with my upset at having spent $2300 on a defective laptop.
I will sell my laptop on eBay at a severe loss and having wasted probably $1500 at least over the past year (purchase value - resale value). I'll never buy a Sony product again, and will recommend to friends, family and all in sundry to do likewise. Naturally, any Sony resellers fall into that bracket also. You must appreciate that I've never once been vindictive or rude to you, and I am extremely stressed and unhappy by what has occurred here. I will not rest easy, but I'm sure all you guys will. It's such a shame that shabby service and amoral avoidance of the issue is seen as good business, and that hollow apologies are the order of the day. I am certain, nonetheless, that your company will do very well as there is always another mug like me around the corner of whom to take advantage."
I think everything is in the above communications with the reseller. I also called Sony directly and got the same response. I think it is clear that although some people on the complaints thread listed in the above communications got replacement laptops/screens, these were one-offs and only if they made a loud enough noise. It seems clear that Sony do not wish to have the expense of recalling all of these laptops so they are shifting the blame completely to the purchaser. I hope you can help back me up so I can get some kind of satisfaction such as some kind of refund (taking into account I have had the laptop for a few months now) or better still, and more fitting in my opinion, a replacement laptop with the new design of my laptop which has corrected the fault I have which Sony will not admit, which in itself is pretty incriminating, I feel. Many Thanks in advance.