I purchased a new iPhone 4S in January. With the phone, I purchased the Apple insurance and was told this would cover a lost/stolen phone (as well as malfunctioning electronics, water damage, etc). The phone was stolen at a bar on January 19th, 2012, about a week after I bought it. I waited a few days for it to turn up as well as calling the bar non-stop, going in and checking the lost and found, putting up ads on Craigslist, hoping a good Samaritan would find it and call the ICE. After that did not pan out, I went into an Apple store to see about replacing it. I was told when I bought the phone that after purchasing the insurance, the phone could be replaced twice for a price of $60.
When I went into the physical store about a week after the phone was stolen, they informed me that I would have to talk to AT&T about it. I chatted with a customer service representative on their website and was informed that since I don't have their insurance, it could not be replaced but that I could purchase their insurance for a $200 fee and $6.99 a month and replace the phone by paying a deductible. It took me until roughly February 4th, give or take a day, to come up with the money and buy the insurance. Two days ago, February 7th, 2012, I printed out the claim forms/most recent billing statement/copy of my drivers license, everything else they needed to file a claim, faxed it to the number they provided and eagerly awaited confirmation. Today, two days later, February 9th 2012, I had received no confirmation via e-mail or the telephone number I left to contact me so I called Asurion's hotline, 888-562-8662, and they told me that since the phone's last usage date was 1/19/12 and I can't prove the phone was in my possession after that (it wasn't!) that they could do nothing about replacing the phone.
After reviewing their insurance policy, this is completely correct. It clearly says that if the theft happens before the coverage date on the insurance, it is not covered. I am remiss for not reading the insurance policy before signing onto it and paying for the service. However, I am extremely upset that at every step of the way, every representative I talked to encouraged me to take this course of action and assured me that I would be able to replace my stolen property. I have now paid for two separate $200 insurance plans that do not help my situation in the slightest. I will no longer be shopping with Apple, AT&T, Asurion or any of its affiliate branches. Skimming this page, I see that many people have similar complaints, most of them with much more right to a complaint than even I have. It is clear that these companies put monetary gain above customer satisfaction and despite the amazing products, I don't feel that this is a business I need to be contributing to. I'll do my best to find a company that will be honest in their dealings.
If Apple, Asurion, AT&T etc. one day decide that the people who are lining their pockets are as important as their check books, maybe I will return. Until then, I advise anyone to avoid these companies at all costs, though, if you are on this webpage, I imagine you have already learned that lesson.
