
James of Elko, NV on Dec. 21, 2010
Alltel has been my cellphone provider for at least five years. My account was set up with auto-pay so the amount was taken out of the checking account monthly on the 12th. Alltel has now become AT&T. I received a statement from Alltel dated 11-22, which I received on 11-26, the day after Thanksgiving, informing me that I owed $279.47. The $200.00 was an early-cancellation penalty and was intended to be taken out of my checking account on December 12.
I went down to the Alltel office on 11-29 to inquire about the bill and I was told by an Alltel representative that the bill was in error and I need not to worry about it. I clarified, "You're telling me I don't have to subtract this bill $279.47 from my checking account?" The representative re-affirmed his comment telling me that everyone who had Alltel auto-pay received a bill with the early-cancellation penalty and it was a glitch in the computer system due to the transition from Alltel to AT&T.
I went home with a notation on my Alltel bill stating that I'd spoken to a representative and was assured that I didn't have to pay that Alltel bill and that I'd be receiving a bill from AT&T with the correct amount owing on it. Sure enough, I received a bill from AT&T shortly thereafter with an amount owing of $76.22. I paid by check in the Alltel/AT&T office on 12-3-10 thinking I was set up for AT&T service.
I went online on the 12th when the Alltel fiasco was originally scheduled to be deducted from my checking account and I saw that Alltel had, in fact, taken the full $279.47 out of my account leaving me overdrawn by $269.38! By this time, I was both furious and freaked-out. I went to Nevada State Bank to ask them if they could waive the overdraft fees of $30.00 for the initial overdraft and $5.00 a day additional until the account was brought back into the black. I was told that they couldn't do anything about the fees or the overdraft because it wasn't their fault.
I went back and patiently stood in line at the Alltel office with all the documentation. I was there in line for two hours before I could see a representative. Once I finally got to talk to a live body, I was in full legal-eagle mode and I wasn't about to take prisoners. An hour or so later, after my representative, Adam, had been back and forth to the fax machine half a dozen times and on the phone with, I assume corporate an equal number of times, he came back and said that they were working on it. "Working on what?" I asked, prodding for details.
"Alltel is going to get the $200.00 penalty reversed and will pay all the overdraft fees." Adam said. "But I'll still be overdrawn $79.47 plus whatever fees accrue until they take care of this mess." "That $79.47 charge is legitimate. It's from last month's Alltel bill." "I was told twice that I didn't have to pay that. Now, you're telling me I do have to pay it. I've been misled. I acted in good faith by paying the AT&T bill I was sent. This whole thing is unacceptable!" It only got worse from there.
My representative disappeared behind a locked door and when he came back, he had nothing definite, other than that "they're working on it." He gave me my documentation with a reference number and the corporate fax number, basically telling me to do all the footwork myself, at my expense, even though none of this was my fault. So, every day since the 12th, I've printed a copy of my bank statement, circled every overdraft charge and the original amount taken out that caused the overdrafts, and I've walked that paper in to the Alltel/AT&T office for Adam or whoever, to fax to Alltel corporate. It's now the 20th and I'm overdrawn by $340.33 with a $5.00 per day overdraft fee scheduled to post at midnight tonight.
On Friday, I received a notification in the mail from Nevada State Bank, informing me of the original $30.00 overdraft fee. Note that I received this one week after I'd already contacted the bank about it and asked that they waive the fees. I also received a form letter from AT&T on the same day. The signature name is Leighton ****, Vice President and Manager, Acquired Markets, that is so ludicrous in light of what I'm going through. I must quote the entire letter:
"Dear ****, You were recently contacted with information regarding your service transition from Alltel to AT&T. We are contacting you again to let you know about an additional billing difference between Alltel and AT&T. All AT&T data usage is billed per kilobyte. Data sent and received includes but is not limited to, downloads, email and application usage. For additional details, please see your AT&T wireless service agreement. We highly recommend subscribing to a data package in order to avoid unexpected charges. Thank you for making the transition to AT&T..."
Note again that I had no choice in this matter. If I had chosen to switch providers, I still would have had to pay the $200.00 early-cancellation penalty. As it is, I'm on the hook with AT&T for two years because my Alltel contract doesn't exist anymore. Perhaps I'm just a moron but it seems to me that Alltel and AT&T should have been working together before they did the rollout. This whole thing was bungled from the beginning and from what I've learned, I'm not the only one who has been affected by this. And from what I can discern, Alltel hasn't done anything to make this situation right.
Each day I'm overdrawn, I have no access to my checking account and thank goodness no other payments are coming out of it until after the first of January! However, when I went into the Alltel office today and asked for a definite resolution date, Adam didn't even volunteer one. He got on the phone to corporate while I was standing there and repeated what they told him, it could take up to two weeks. He also sent the account investigations unit an e-mail with my overdrawn bank account information, re-faxed the most current bank statement I'd provided and gave me his work cell-phone number in case I didn't hear back from him within a day or two. Already, Alltel has exceeded its two-weeks estimate.