Prior to this incident, I have had a few other problems with this repair shop. I know that things happen so I am very forgiving. Once, I paid for an oil change that I did not receive. I called and they corrected the issue right away. But I had to spend another hour or so at the shop waiting for the to get to it. On another occasion; I had brought a set of aftermarket wheels (purchased elsewhere)into their shop, for them to install and they used the original lug nuts.
It wasn't until months later when I went to S&M Truck World for a new set of tires that S&M informed me that the lug nuts were only on by a few threads and were unsafe. They needed to be shanked lug nuts (meaning the nuts were far too short for what was required to secure the wheel to the axle). S&M installed the new lug nuts at no charge because they refused to install the incorrect lugs on my truck.
7/27/09 I brought my 2000 Nissan Frontier 4x4 to Tires Plus for an oil change and tire rotation. I didn't think they could screw it up if I watched them change the oil. 7/28/09 On my way to work, I noticed that the truck had a slight vibration. When I got there, I inspected the truck to find that it was missing two lug nuts (I was missing three actually but the truck had a broken stud prior to this) and several others were about to fall off. I jacked up the truck and tightened ALL of the lug nuts as they were ALL loose. Some of them would not tighten as the threads were damaged. I waited until the following day to call Tires Plus to allow myself to calm down.
7/29/09 I contacted the store manager to inform him of the mistake. He offered to send a tow truck until I told him that I work at Tampa International Airport, apparently the distance (30 miles)was far greater than the generosity. This did not matter much as I had already tightened the lug nuts but I wanted them to look at the damaged ones that I was unable to tighten. I drove the truck to their shop off of East Bay at around 4pm. Mind you that I drove quite cautiously as the right front wheel only had three lug nuts on it and another would not tighten. After a lengthy wait, they put it on a lift and removed all 4 wheels.
The store manager told me that all of the studs and lug nuts would have to be replaced and that they would take care of everything. I was told that the truck would have to stay overnight as they could not get all of the parts needed until sometime the following day. He also assured me that all of my lug nuts were tightened using a torque wrench to begin with and that someone must have loosened all of them during the night. I know that this to be a flat out lie because I watched the technician use an impact gun to put them on and never picked up a torque wrench.
That being said, I assumed that they would be tight. Right? This is not the case. I found out the following day when they worked on my truck that the techs at Tires Plus (at least the one working on my truck) used the impact to snug them down, and then use the torque wrench to insure proper torque has been achieved. The store manager commented on my tow hitch as it is a combination pintle hitch which is something you would not normally find on such a small truck. I told him I used to have a much larger truck and that I pulled a decent sized boat and on occasion, had to use the four wheel drive to get the boat out of the ramp when it was too steep and the tide was out.
Shortly after that comment, I was told that all of this was due to saltwater damage. "What? Are you serious?" I asked. Oh yeah, was his reply. This is the front axle we're discussing. If it went under water when I launched the boat, half of my truck would be under water. Not once did the manager admit their negligence. He apparently was willing to do all this for free out of the kindness of his heart? I didn't mind being put to blame. In my opinion, they were repairing what they screwed up. I was driven home by a friend as the truck was not serviceable/operable.
7/30/09 A colleague provided me with transportation to work. Around 8am I received a phone call from the store manager. He explained to me that he was unaware that my truck was four wheel drive and that the repair would be much more of a hassle than he had anticipated as a result of having to remove the hubs to change the studs. (That's funny, all the times I have had it there before, it has always been four wheel drive) In addition, he told me that they had noticed a small plastic ring inside the hub was cracked and that they had already ordered one from a local Nissan dealer and would take care of it. I thanked him for all that he was doing for me and the phone call ended. I received a ride from work to Tires Plus to pickup my truck.
When I arrived, the service manager handed me a plastic bag containing 24 used lug nuts and 8 stripped studs. I asked what happened to the other 16 studs. He explained that they used a thread chaser and managed to save some of them. This was acceptable to me as I just wanted my truck back. Here's where the real trouble begins. The store manager told me that they had fabricated "something" instead of replacing the plastic ring. I was told "It will be fine. It'll work no problem. I guarantee it."
I was not at all happy with them installing "something" inside the hub so I questioned it. I didn't authorize the installation of a "fabricated" part, nor would I. The store manager took me into his office to show me a printed schematic of the hub. When he got to the Nissan dealer, the part they put on the counter was not the part that they needed to fix my hub. Nissan told him that the part he needed could not be purchased separately, that it was part of the whole hub assembly and that it would cost $475.00 for a new hub. The store manager told me, "[expletive] that!" I'm not paying that kind of money for this! At this point, I was biting my tongue not to fly off the handle. I just wanted it fixed and fixed properly. He assured me again that the fabricated part would be fine.
I had to leave before my anger built into something more so I accepted possession of my truck. I left Tires Plus and headed East on East Bay Drive. I had not driven two traffic lights (approx. 1,500 feet) when an awful noise came out from the front driver's side wheel. Now I was fuming. I turned the truck around and took it back to Tires Plus. As I walked in through the door, the service manager asked me "what is that God awful noise?" I told him, that's you're going to tell me. I could see the look of disgust in the store manager's face. Neither one of us were happy to see one another.
The store manager had me ride with him as he drove my truck around the block to diagnose the problem. He diagnosed it as coming from the left front wheel. He attempted to try the four wheel drive but didn't know how to engage the transfer case. I put the truck in four wheel drive but the front hubs would not lock as they should have. He had it put on a lift to further diagnose the problem. They told me that it looks as though I blew a driver's side axle. I didn't believe that for a second.
It was time for the shop to close so the store manager asked me to leave the truck overnight for a second time so his master technician to look at in the morning. This is the same tech that has been working on it all along. I received a ride home from the technician that helped with the diagnosis. That night I was so upset I could hardly sleep. I couldn't help but feel that they were going to replace the axle, bill me for it to recover some of their losses and it would not be the cause of the problem.
7/31/09 First thing in the morning, I called the store manager and asked that he send the truck to a Nissan dealer for a second opinion. He expressed his concern that I didn't need to do that. He explained to me that his staff was very competent and capable of fixing the problem. I was feeling that they had already proved to me that they were not qualified to work on any four wheel drive, first by fabricating some part to save some money, then by misdiagnosing their negligence. Again, the store manager never admitted to me that his technicians could have failed.
I called Clearwater Towing Service to have my truck picked up and taken to Lokey Nissan in Clearwater. I met the tow truck driver at Tires Plus. The store manager came out and said he could not release the truck until I signed a customer invoice. This is normal as I've had to do it every time I picked it up. Once again, the store manager reassured me that he could repair it. He asked me to give him the opportunity to fix it. I told him that he already had that opportunity when they installed a fabricated part inside the hub. I signed the invoice and the tow truck driver took the truck to Nissan. I met him there as I had received a ride from a friend. The towing bill was $80.30
Once at Nissan, I had explained the whole issue to Jason Y., the Service Advisor at Lokey Nissan. He assured me that he would have the technician go over the truck to ensure there were no other issues with it. While I was outside waiting on a ride home, Jason yelled to tell me they had diagnosed the problem. I couldn't believe they found the problem that fast. It was in fact, the right front hub that had this fabricated part in it. Jason explained that he would need to keep the truck over the weekend as a hub needed to be shipped in.
The Nissan technician did not find any "fabricated" part inside the hub. It may have disintegrated while driving that short period of time, it could have been removed before I had it towed, or they had lied to me and just put it back together. Regardless, I feel that Tires Plus is negligent and provided me with nothing more than substandard service. Now knowing I would need a ride for a few days and not wanting to keep inconveniencing my friends with my problems, I walked over to Enterprise Leasing as it is right next door to pick up a rental.
8/03/09 After work, I drove the rental to Lokey Nissan to pick up my truck. The total bill was $509.06 Jason explained that they gave me a huge discount due to the misfortunate nature of the repair. From Nissan, I returned the rental which came out to $131.28 After returning the rental, I went home and made copies of all of the invoices that I had acquired. The total for that was $720.64 I assembled all of the copies and took them to Tires Plus to give them to the store manager. I couldn't help but feel as though the store manager had expected my return. There was no look of surprise. He looked over the invoices and questioned a fuel receipt.
I was still so upset about the whole issue that when I added all of the invoices, I added the fuel receipt to the total bill for Tires Plus. This was a mistake on my part. They are not responsible for fuel in the rental. The store manager asked if I wanted them to pay for all of the invoices. I told him yes, of course. He told me he might be able to cover the cost of the hub but not all of it. He needed to contact Brian C. who is the Area Manager to approve the payment.
8/06/09 I received a call from Brian C. who informed me that they could not be held liable for a vehicle with such high mileage. It was purely coincidence that this happened and the hub was destroyed by salt water damage. Here we go with the saltwater damage again. My truck only has 135,000 miles on it. According to Nissan, this is not a wear and tear part. They do go bad but that depends on how often the hubs are locked in. I have used the four wheel drive maybe a half dozen times in the five years that I have owned it.
As far as saltwater damage, I have physical possession of the broken hub and there is no indication of such corrosion. After my rejection, I contacted Tires Plus Customer Support to escalate the issue. I explained the whole story as I have here and received a case number. That case number is 1176601. It was escalated to Bruce M., Regional Vice President. I was told that he was not available but would return my call within three business days.
8/13/09 I gave Mr. M. the benefit of doubt and waited a few more days. I contacted Tires Plus Customer Support once again as I had not received a call from Mr. M.. I had to explain the whole issue one more time. They tried to contact Mr. M. but he was again, not available. So I asked it to be escalated to someone else. I was told that it would be escalated to Elianne K., Risk Management but she too was unavailable, that I would hear back from her in three days.
8/20/09 Again, no phone calls from anyone regarding my issue with Tires Plus. I contacted Tires Plus Customer Support again and asked to have it escalated again. They told me that the issue was as high as it would go and that someone should contact me within three business days. I left another message for Elianne K. to please contact me regarding this issue.
8/27/09 I received a call from Brian C., Area Manager. He told me that Elianne K. had requested he call me and ask if there was something he could help me with. I told him he could authorize my check. He informed me that he could not do that and not to continue calling the corporate office. He explained to me that the issue had been resolved on their end and that I would not be receiving anything from Tires Plus.
I have not contacted them since then. Maybe I gave up too early. The consequences are the cost of the rental car, the tow bill and the cost of repairs from Nissan. Oh, and a day of work missed not to mention my friends going out of their way to help me get to work.