All notes to date: The car was brought in do to engine stall at 15-30+ mph. Would lose all control of steering, brakes etc.
7/9/2010 - dropped off my car at Subaru, got loaner; sent in for 2 recalls and engine failure.
7/9/2010 3:20 pm - something definitely wrong. Subaru tech support wants a valve and compression test done on the engine, (intake and out take) will have results Monday afternoon. Subaru rep may need to come out and see it. Manch. Subaru did state that it is not a problem with the a/c system. (keep loaner for now). Was told to "enjoy my weekend, you will probably not hear from me until Monday," per April.
7/12/2010 - No call from Subaru. Called at 5pm. Compression test done, no negative results, but aware that something is going on. May need a software update. Spoke to April, waiting for answer from Subaru of America. Said and I quote "I haven't had time to call you. Everyone is ughh because of the heat."
7/13/2010 - Received a message from Manch. Subaru Customer Service Rep that stated still waiting to hear from Subaru of America. Stated it did the valve test (which they stated was done on Monday). No answer to the problem.
7/14/2010 Spoke with April at approx 5:20pm. (Customer service rep at Subaru of Manch) Still has not received any response from Subaru Tech Support, regarding the problem with my car. She said that she feels there will not be a quick fix to this problem. There is something wrong with my car. It cannot be corrected until Subaru identifies what is wrong, rewrite the software to correct it and then fix my car. I asked if I should contact Subaru of America. She said that I need to wait as to what I need to do and calling them may be what I have to do. She asked to give her a few more days to see if Subaru Tech Support returns their calls. (additional notes on phone)
7/16/2010 at approx 9:00 am I received a call from April of Manchester Subaru. I was told that "we received an e-mail from Subaru of America stating that they are aware of a problem and working on a fix, however, it may take up to two more weeks. I can keep the loaner, April still unaware of what the problem could be. Simply saying it is probably just a software update. I asked for a copy of the e-mail that they received. A copy of the email was faxed to Brian *** at work. The SR number on the email did not match my case rather it was another customers case number!
Friday, 7/16 approx. 11:37 - Spoke to Grant at SOA customer service. Initiated a complaint on my vehicle. Was told by the rep, "Wow, I have never heard this before." He suggested I bring my car to the dealership. My car had been at the dealership for 7 days already! He stated that he would investigate the situation with the dealer. I asked for a senior rep. and he said I would receive a call within 24-48 hrs (not including the weekend).
Monday, 7/19 at approx 2:55 pm - I called SOA again (had received no response) spoke to a rep named Meghan who stated that my case had been turned over to Karen ***. She said she would connect me. Moments later, Meghan returned on the line and said that she had just spoken to Karen and to let me know that a "fix" had been found over the weekend and the dealerships should have the information.
Monday, 7/19 at approx 3:05 pm - I called Manchester Subaru. I spoke with April who said that they had received an email from SOA stating that a software update had been made available but my car had not been checked yet to see if the update would work. I told her that I had reached my limit and asked to speak to the Owner . She suggested I speak with Jeff, service manager. She stated he was in a meeting but I could leave a message. Left vm for Jeff expressing my concerns and frustrations that my car was "unsafe" and that my level of trust with Subaru was broken. I expressed my deep concern for the safety and reliability of the manual transmission.
Jeff returned my call and we spoke about the situation. He was very understanding and shared my concerns. He stated that he had already emailed SOA about my concerns and he was awaiting a response. He mentioned that SOA would probably offer me a 6 year, 100,000 mile gold warranty for free on my car. I told him that although I appreciated this gesture I "do not feel safe in may car." He stated that another customer had been offered an automatic transmission upgrade (however, the customer did not want an automatic) and SOA would not give another manual transmission. I told him that I would appreciate him emailing SOA to see about putting me in an automatic. He stated he would perform the "update" and take my car home for the night to get in a road test to see if the problem had been corrected. He said he would contact me when he heard back from SOA on Tuesday.
Tuesday, 7/20 12:37pm - Jeff called and left a message on my cell to call him. At approx 12:49pm I returned the call to Jeff. He was abrupt and quick. He stated that my car was ready to be picked up and that SOA was not going to offer me the automatic transmission since a software update had been given. He stated that he test drove it for approx 8-9 miles and it seemed to run great. I expressed to him my discontent and stated that I could not trust that the safety issue had been remedied to my satisfaction and that I needed some answers. I stated I was going to call SOA directly.
Tuesday, 7/20 1:15 pm - Placed a call to SOA, spoke to Crystal and asked to speak with Karen ***. who was handling my case. She said that she was currently unavailable but was in the office. She sent me to VM. The VM stated that she was out of the office for the day. I left a message with my contact information. I called SOA again, this time getting another rep., Desiree, I told her that I was trying to reach Karen and asked if there was anyone covering for her in her absence. She stated that Bil" was handling her customers but that he was out to lunch until 2pm.
At this time I did not have my case number available but I did have the in-house service number on the email from Manch. Subaru. She stated that the numbers were linked (one in the same). When she pulled up the number, she began to confirm my contact information, phone # ***. I said that I have never had a 978 number. She was surprised the info was wrong and then realized it did not pertain to my case. She looked me up by name and found my info. (red flag) She said she would have Bill contact me.
Tuesday, 7/20 at approx 2:36 pm (call length approx. 17min and 16 seconds) - I received a call from a woman named Judy. Right from the start, she was curt, short, angry and abrupt! She began to tell me that she was "filling in" for Karen and that she was aware of my case. She talked continuously, interrupting me at every junction, for approx the first 5 minutes of our conversation. I tried to voice my sincere concerns about the safety of their product. I wanted reassurance from SOA that the safety issue had been 100% fixed. She said she could not say that. She said my car was ready to be picked up, "You are not getting another car!" She then began to say that she had been working for SOA for over 20 years, that she had owned many Subaru's in her lifetime and that she knew more about Subaru's than I ever would. The disrespect was alarming and unprofessional.
I tried to share with her that I was not going to put my life or the life of another human being at risk. Again, she berated me and belittled me. She tried to compare a "door jam" recall in 1992 to my "sudden engine shut off while driving." She stated SOA would give me a 6 year, 100,000 mile warranty. I asked if she was willing to give me that, it gave the impression that my car was not fixed or that they were aware there could be greater problems down the road. She said "It is a good will gesture. Take it or leave. I can send you a check if you don't want the extra warranty."
I shared with her my information that SOA had set a precedent by offering some customers an upgrade to an automatic transmission free of charge. She said we have done no such thing. I then stated that I had contact information to prove otherwise. She then stated that things are decided on a "case by case basis" and that my case was not the same. I attempted to share with her my information that in fact the cases were extremely similar. She refuted again and then I stated that I had been made aware by the Service Manager at Manch Subaru that a "few" customers had been given the option of an automatic upgrade.
One customer chose not to accept because they wanted to stay with a manual car. She was rude and abrasive by this point, raising her voice. I expressed that although I appreciated her point of view and time, I wanted to speak to someone above her. She went on a rant! She said that I was "wasting my time" and that everyone else would tell me the same thing. "We are not giving you another car!" I said that I appreciated her concern for my time but that I wanted to speak to her superior. She proceeded to express my waste of time and that no one else was familiar with my case and that now she would have to go over everything with someone else and that the end result would be the same. I again requested her superior. At this point, she stated a name Shirley *** and said that she didn't know when she would be able to call me. I began to say, "Thank you for your..." and she hung up on me.
Tuesday, 7/20 at approx. 2:59 pm - I received a phone call from Jeff the SM at Manch Subaru. He was very upset and stated that he had just received a call form some woman at SOA and that I had stated that he had told me "Subaru had upgraded several people to automatic transmissions free of charge in Manchester. " I relayed to him my conversation with Judy and had made it very clear about the separation of what SOA was doing and what his customer had been offered." We continued to have a good conversation, he apologized for what I had to go through and that no one should ever be treated like that. He said it was not acceptable what she did and suggested I write a letter directly to SOA to file a complaint. He then went though the car issue with me stating that Subaru had known about this issue for probably several months and that stringent testing had to have occurred prior to them releasing an update.
He said that normally some of the initial cars are bought back and that road testing (1000's of miles of road testing) is done to ensure the safety of the vehicle. He stated in fact the government had to approved it because this update "effected the emissions of the car" and stated that there were strict federal and state guidelines that had to be followed. I thanked him and expressed that all I really ever wanted was to be walked through the process and assured that I was going to be safe behind the wheel of my car after this fix. I expressed that because the trust was broken it was hard to just put blind trust back into their product that had failed me. He offered to take a test drive with me when I picked up the car Wednesday morning. The call lasted approx 20 minutes and 23 seconds.
Wednesday, 7/21 at approx 10:40 am - I returned the loaner car to Subaru to pick up my car. I spoke with Apryl and told her Jeff had offered to take a test drive with me. I started the car and did what I normally do upon start-up. I turned on the ac. I proceeded to back out of the space when the car sputtered, almost stalled, dropped in RPM's then suddenly rose. I looked at Jeff and said "this car is obviously not fixed! " It was obvious he didn't know what to say. I decided to take a "test drive" to see what occurred. On two other occasions during the 5 mile test drive the car did the same thing...almost stalling out, dropping in RPMS's stuttering and then raising the RPM's....(the clutch was FULLY engaged) it was NOT driver error!
At this point, I broke down, I didn't know what else to say or do. I was in shock. Jeff spoke very little during the test drive. When we returned to the lot I just said "I am not safe in this car, something is still fundamentally wrong and I will not take it back. " He said that although he noticed the RPM's drop and felt the stuttering, he thought that might just be "normal" for the new legacy. He began explaining that the new car had a bad design and that what I was probably hearing was the engine mounts rattle. I wasn't hearing things, I was feeling them!
The car was stalling out! I said I did not want to argue with him. I was at a loss and got very emotional. He mentioned other manual cars that he had owned that did similar things, I stated that I had never had a car that did anything remotely close to this. I asked him if there was a technical service bulletin sent out on this issue and he stuttered and then said "Yeah, I think so." Then I asked him if there would be a recall to this dangerous safety issue and he said "I don't think so."
I then asked him if he thought it was all manual transmissions that were effected. He said "no, I think it is only a very few and yours is one of them. " (an admittance of a problem? ) We went into the service area, I told him I was going to call SOA right there. I called and while holding he came back and said, "I just spoke to my rep, Karen is out but I expressed to this rep that you had 'lost all confidence in our product' and that you do not feel safe in this car." He continued and said that the rep said he would speak with Karen about getting me into another car. He also stated that Todd, the owner was at a Subaru convention (I piped in and said "lucky him.") Jeff laughed and said, "I am sure they are talking about this problem." He said that hopefully by Monday they could work this all out and that Todd would sit down with me regarding the money side of the transfer to an automatic.
He then said the rep said go ahead and take your car until then while they worked it all out. I refused. I stated again that my car was not safe to drive! He said okay. I asked if I could keep the loaner and he said that SOA would not allow me too. I said "Okay, I will get a ride home." At this point I was very distraught. He offered their shuttle service. I said okay and sat down. A few moments later he came out and said, "I am probably going to get in a lot of trouble for this but that's okay, I am going to go over Subaru of America's head and I am going to let you keep the loaner."
I thanked him and offered to write a letter on his behalf. He said don't worry about it but restated the above. I thanked him. When the loaner was ready (needed an oil change), I went to the desk to ask April for my keys so I could get some things out of my car. Jeff piped in from the back and said "I torched it!" I laughed and said, "Well at least now I can collect the insurance money." I was told I would hear from them when they knew more. He wanted to be sure that I didn't lose confidence in Subaru of Manchester. They said, "Don't worry, we will get this all figured out."