I am writing this mail, to bring certain issues to your notice. I had purchased a Mercedes C-180, in Nov 2006 from Gargash Enterprises Used Cars unit, at that time this car had done about 55,000 kms and I was told that it is single owner driven, has an accident free history and has a 100% service history with Gargash as well. I had also taken a 2 yr extended warranty at that point. At this point, the salesman involved was one Mr Jay.
Post the purchase in the past 2 yrs and 9 months, I have clocked less than 25,000 kms and all servicing / repairs have been carried out at Gargash alone and this history is available with them. There has not been a single accident that the car has been involved in, major or minor, which can be verified with the Insurance company / RTA / any other authority in Dubai. Further the car has been sparingly used and well maintained.
Recently, the car gave a couple of problems and I had taken it to Gargash for check up and repair. At this point I met the Sr Service Advisor, Mr Sanjay A., who checked the car and told me that he would get back with the problems / estimate for repairs. I had left the car on 14 Jul '09 at 12:00 p.m. At that point, after brief review, Mr Sanjay gave me a work sheet mentioning 3 things: 1 Problem with a/c: for which gas was to be filled and hence would cost around AED 250, i had though confirmed that there was a leakage as the cooling was not low but non-existent, although he said that post this check, the refill after the repair is carried out will be free (though the estimate that I have received today also has an added cost of AED 450 for refrigerant, which I assume is the gas). 2 Car does not start, AED 350 was the cost of diagnosing
3 Car starts and stops, AED 350 was the cost of diagnosing
I asked him to explain the logic for separately checking point 2 and 3 post which I was given a reprint of the work sheet with points 2 and 3 being clubbed and I have to pay approx AED 600 only for diagnostics, which is fine. I received a complete estimate of the work required to be done, today which is 20 Jul '09 once by fax and once by mail, the mail was sent later and the fig's in both the attachments vary a bit, and approx amt is AED 22,000. I would also like to know as to how are these fig's different, they were sent with 2 hrs of each other, and I have not requested for any discounts yet, further, the composition of both of them is also slightly different.
This is also one of the additional points which make one feel that there might be no genuine need of repair required. Considering all of the above (car being manufactured by Mercedes, sold and resold by Gargash, servicing / repairs only done by Gargash, no accident history...), there are only the following three possibilities. 1 Cars / Parts used in the car are substandard (the only reason one buys a Mercedes-Benz and pays a premium for it, because of the quality, in such scenarios, I feel that this car is probably of a much lower standard as compared to many other cheaper cars). 2 Issue at Gargash's end wrt, refurbishing / servicing / repairing (as I am sure, parts / car manufactured by Mercedes and built to last longer than 2-3 yrs, and such multiple issues are not expected at such frequency)
3 Customer is being mis-lead (by the dealer / workshop etc as there is only one dealer and no competition exists..., as we have no clue as to what is the repair needed or what the issue is with the car and are completely at your mercy, this feeling is further strengthened, when I see 2 different quotes with in a span of 2 hrs and when every time the car goes for servicing, critical parts like brake shoes etc... always need a change, this is something nobody can refuse to. These problems are not being faced by me alone, I can get at least 4-5 of my friends / colleagues who face exactly similar problems and a am sure if such issues are highlighted there will be 100's of other who would agree. The problem is that nobody has been complaining and I will not hesitate the first one to do so.
I was willing to do a trade in of this car with a different Mercedes used car, but am scared to do it now, as the other car might also turn out to be similar, or at least maintaining it might be as difficult as I would still need to deal with Gargash. One of my colleagues, who was planning to buy a Mercedes has already dropped the idea, post this episode, and I am sure Mr N. from used car divisions would agree to this, as we had met him for trade in of my car and purchase of a new one for my colleague.
I had purchased a Mercedes and paid a premium for it initially, to get better driving and personal experience / service. But over the years I have been really disappointed considering the frequent issues, maintenance etc. I feel my colleagues / friends who bought Audi's / BMW's or even Honda / Mitsubishi for that matter are much better off. All this while, I have taken my car to Gargash for any servicing /repairs just to make sure that the history is clean and to have a better resale value, but now I realize that it was a completely wrong decision as I have to pay 30-40% of the car's initial purchase value (50% of the current value) as minor repair cost.
This whole episode and the experiences before this as well, make me feel cheated. I too am a sales person and know that everybody is in business to make profits, but this kind of reckless and un necessary way to handle clients is just not right, especially in the long run. I am definitely not getting the car repaired at this cost, and would not be willing to trade-in as well. I might as well get it repaired from outside and sell it off for what is worth.
I am writing this complaint to Mercedes / Gargash as of now and would request a response (if not a solution) at the earliest. As a next step I will be forwarding this complaint to the relevant regulatory body in Dubai and media, so that at least the issue is highlighted, which might make life better for others in my situation.
Post the initial complaint: I had initially been sent two different estimates, by you (one on fax and one on mail). I recently(on 25.07.09 at 11:28 a.m. from +971506542412) received an sms that my car is ready for collection, which i was asked to ignore. I received a call from you yesterday where in clearly told you that i would have to wait till your sales division gets back to me with an offer. I received a call from your office at 10:41 a.m. from extn 209 9777 and a lady told me that my car is ready for collection and you have asked her to call me, i told her of my discussion with you yesterday post which she transferred the line to you, when you mentioned that due to shortage of parking space, i will need to decide immediately.
I have left my car at your work shop for over 2 weeks now and i should be the only asking you to hurry up, i received an estimate only on 20.07.09 and a reworked one on 23.07.09. I had visited your workshop/showroom on 25.07.09 to finalise a trade-in but there was no suitable car available. I was aksed if i was fine with waiting for another 7/10 days and i agreed, so what is the point in pressurizing now. This kind of unprofessional behaviour is totally unacceptable. I am not willing to get the car repaired at such a high cost (even post the discounts) and will not buy just any car for a trade-in. As mentioned earlier, i will like to escalate my initial complaint with the recent issues.
i am being asked to pay AED 21,000 as repair cost which is more than 50% of my cars vaue (gargash has valued it at 40,000 AED), even post discounts offered, i have to pay AED 12,000. car has been lying at their workshop for over 2 weeks and their behavious is completely unprofessional and disturbing