I own a 2003 Mitsubishi Eclipse, and this is my story.
On January 17, 2009 at 8am, I took my car to Meineke Car Care Center, #1440 (15510 E Mill Plain Blvd Vancouver, WA) for my 90, 000- mile service. I was told when I dropped my car off that they would need to keep it for the majority of the day, to which I told them would be fine. I left my phone and cell phone numbers with them, so that they could call me when they were ready for me to pick it up.
Just before 5pm, I asked my husband to take me over to the shop, as I had not heard from anyone and was getting concerned. When we arrived, as I was walking towards the shop entrance, the mechanic came walking toward me and said that he had tried to call me. I asked him what number he had tried calling me at, because I had not received any calls from them. The mechanic then said, "We have an issue." I asked him if it was an issue that I did or something that they did. He told me that he's not sure.
We continued walking into the shop where my car was at with the hood opened. The mechanic told me that he has been there for 5 years and has never had anything like this happen. He proceeded to tell me that he had performed the service and that everything had checked out great. He said that he took my car for a test drive after the service (Remember this; it will be important later in my story.) and upon returning to the shop, he left the car running for a minute and then all of a sudden, he heard this loud bang. So he ran over to my car to see what was going on. He said he turned my car off and looked around to see if he could figure out what happened. He then showed me what seems to be metal shavings in an oil content in the engine compartment.
I told the mechanic that I have never had any problems with my car. I kept outstanding records of all of the services I had done on my car and followed my owner's manual from the first day I bought my car (brand-new) and that it was running just fine when I dropped it off. He then said, "Yeah, I know. It ran well while I drove it too."
He then told me that he cannot allow me to take my car because of them not knowing what was wrong with it. He said with the next day being a Sunday and Monday being a holiday, he wouldn't probably get a whole lot done on it until Tuesday morning. I inquire about a rental car, and he said that sometimes they do offer one but that I would need to talk to the owner and manager of the shop.
I would like to point out that while we were there and the mechanic was talking about the car, he was smoking and swearing inside the bay area. He did not came across professional at all. It seemed like this was the "norm" for them.
When I left the shop, I was sick to my stomach. Upon arriving home, I got online and do a search for Meineke Car Care Center and a ton of complaints came up, which made me feel even worse. There was one story very similar to mine, except the guy had just taken his car in for a new thermostat and water pump, and they broke his timing belt as well. $8,000 later for the repairs (which I don't know who paid), but the guy did say not to take your car to any Meineke Car Care Centers. This is just one of the many complaints/stories on the internet.
Tuesday afternoon came, and I have not heard from anybody. When my husband got home from work, I sent him down to Meineke to see if they know anything on my car yet. He spoke to the manager who told him that he has been trying to get in touch with the mechanic all day and has not been able to do so. At that point, they still don't know what was wrong with my car.
My husband called me and told me what the manager has said to him. I told my husband to go back into the shop and asked for the owner's name and number. My husband called me back with the general manager's number. I called him and left a message and asked for him to call me. Wednesday morning came around, and I still have not received a call from the GM or the shop. I call the GM again around 9am and left another message, stating that if I don't hear from somebody by 11am, I am going to seek legal counsel. At 10:30am, the manager of the shop called me and said they know what happened to my car.
He proceeded to tell me that the timing belt broke and my engine is ruined. He then told me that I should have replaced the timing belt at 60, 000 miles. I told him no and that it is supposed to be replaced at 100, 000 miles according to my owner's manual. He said that he called Mitsubishi in Milwaukee and spoke to a Scott in service (which I later found out upon taking my car there that there is nobody by the name of Scott who works there and they had no record of Meineke calling them).
He told me that he has gone ahead and gotten a quote for me on a new engine as well as a used engine. He said that the used one has around 60, 000 miles on it but that he can't be exactly sure how good of an engine it is because of not knowing how hard it was ran. He said that a new engine will be approximately $10, 000 and the used one would be $3, 000. By this time, I was in tears; and all I can think of was how I was going to pay for this. I told him that I need to make some calls and that I would let him know what I would be doing as soon as I can.
I placed a call to the owner at Louie Lube on Mill Plain, as he has done some work for me in the past on my car. (Louie Lube actually did my 60, 000-mile service, and the owner remembered the owner's manual as well stating to change the timing belt at 100, 000 miles.) I explained to him what happened and asked his opinion as to what I should do. He suggested that I have it towed to another shop over off Fourth Plain to have it looked at.
I called that shop and spoke to the owner. He said that he could look at my car but could not guarantee if he could pin-point what they had done over at Meineke. This was critical for me because Meineke was refusing to admit fault. I then called Mitsubishi in Milwaukee and spoke to Jerry whom I had spoken with earlier when I called to ask about the replacement of the timing belt. (Jerry also confirmed that for the year and model of my car, the timing belt would need to be changed at 100, 000 miles.) Jerry told me that if I can have my car towed to Mitsubishi, he would be able to see what Meineke had done and that he could make a precise analysis for me to give to my insurance company.
I called my insurance company to get a tow truck to meet me at Meineke. I called Meineke to let them know that I was going to have my car towed to Mitsubishi and that I would see them shortly. When I arrived at Meineke, I went inside to gather my owner's manual and a discount card that I had purchased for $69.99 from a marketing company that was selling them on behalf of Meineke. The card allowed you so many oil changes for free, discount on labor, and many other services at a discount. The owner's manual and an estimate on a used engine were given to me, but the discount card was not given back to me (not that I was ever planning on coming back to Meineke anyway).
I also wondered if they were going to charge me for the service they had done, as I was not going to say anything. Ryan (the manager) didn't say a word, and I thought that he must know that since they messed up my car it would be hard for them to charge me for the 90, 000-mile service. I then proceeded to the shop area and saw that my car was up in the air. The tow truck driver arrived and told me that my insurance company had authorized the first $75 but that I would be responsible for the other $75. The total charge to tow my car from Vancouver to Milwaukee was $150.
Once my car was on the ground, the tow truck driver looked in my engine compartment and asked the mechanic where my engine was. The mechanic points to a work bench where there were yellow plastic bags. They had dismantled a majority of my engine without my consent verbally or written, and then they put it in bags. I now believe that this was done in an effort to conceal what they had done to damage my car. The tow truck driver places the bags that contained my engine in the trunk of my car. Before I left, the mechanic came over to me and asked if I would call him as soon as I hear from Mitsubishi on what they found with my car because he was just so baffled on what could have happened.
My car arrived at Mitsubishi at around 4:40pm later that day. Jerry (from Mitsubishi) called me and said he cannot believe the condition of my car with the engine literally in bags in the trunk. He said that he was going to take pictures of how the car came in. He said that due to it being so late, he probably wouldn't get a whole lot done until the next day.
At 11:15am the next day, Jerry called and said that he was 100% convinced that Meineke was responsible for the damage. According to him, he said that the timing belt would have easily gone until at least 100, 000 miles and maybe even more. It was obvious that they had done stuff to cover up their tracks. That is why so much of the engine was torn apart.
I had a report as well as a statement from Mitsubishi that confirms their findings. Jerry informed me that all of the fluids, spark plugs, etc. (basically everything that had been on my car when I took it to Meineke and the service they had done) had been removed. This would explain why they did not charge me for the service to begin with. They even drained all of the fluids, etc. from my car! Meineke did not tell me this when I was there to retrieve my car. Jerry said that I have an excellent case, and if he was me, he would get an attorney.
I contacted my insurance company to see if my policy even covered anything like this. They said it would but that I would be responsible for the deductible and some other expenses that pertained to the service that was originally done but then undone. My insurance company covered me for a rental care for one month and then I was on my own to find other transportation. I had made 3 car payments for a car that I didn't have. I was without my car for more than 2 months. It was a very stressful situation and was a huge inconvenience. I missed some work during that time as well due to having no transportation.
Mitsubishi took pictures when my car was brought in as well as the damage that they uncovered while going through the car. I have had no contact with Meineke since I had my car towed. Mitsubishi discovered that while having my car in the shop at Meineke, a mechanic dropped a washer into a cylinder causing the timing belt to break.
I decided to sue Meineke for all of the costs associated with my car as well as rental reimbursement, missed work, etc. On July 14, 2009, Meineke failed to appear in court. So the judge awarded me the entire amount of the claim on default ($3, 873.33). The judge let me know that Meineke has 30 days to either pay me or to challenge the decision by the judge.
On day 30, I got a notice that Meineke was challenging the decision. So it's back to court once again. On September 9, 2009, I was back in court. This time, the owner of Meineke as well as the mechanic who worked on my car appeared to dispute the charges. Because the judge has a few cases in front of us, he asked us to step outside of the court room to try and settle this and see if we can come to some resolution and we both agree. I had brought my mechanic from Mitsubishi along with me, so the four of us step out of the court room to discuss things.
My mechanic from Mitsubishi proceeded to tell the owner of Meineke exactly what happened to my car. Neither the owner nor the mechanic from Meineke disagreed with what the mechanic from Mitsubishi was saying. The owner then proceeded to tell me that he doesn't know how this was going to get resolved because he has no money. We then went back into the court room.
When it was our turn, my mechanic and I spoke first as to the details of the case. Then the judge listened to what the owner and mechanic from Meineke had to say. The owner from Meineke said that he had just learned of the issue with my car a few days ago. His mechanic then said he did do a test drive, yet it was discovered that my odometer never changed from the time it was originally dropped off to Meineke to when I had it towed to Mitsubishi. There was no way my car was driven after the washer was dropped into the cylinder, as the timing belt broke immediately, causing my bar to be un-driveable. The owner announced that he filed bankruptcy, so he didn't know how I wouldl get my money.
The judge reviewed the amount that I was asking for and started deleting some of the amounts such as time lost from work, etc. In the end, I won again and was awarded $2,719.
The judgment was to be paid in 30 days. I never saw my money, so I decided to do a Writ of Garnishment. Again, that was ignored. I contacted several collection agencies in an attempt to get my money again; nothing. Not knowing what to do next, I called the corporate office which I had originally done when I first got the news of my car. Wouldn't you know that they would have nothing on file of me originally calling?
The person I spoke to said that they would not be able to help me and that I should have called them first when the problem originally surfaced. I said that I had but was told that because these stores are franchised, I had to deal with the store directly. I then found the rep who is the Franchise Development Specialist for the NW. At first, he seemed concerned and very apologetic for the runaround that I had been through. But he came back with an email stating simply "Joni, it is out of my hands. Sorry."
Bottom line, don't take your car to Meineke Car Care Center if you don't want your car to be returned to you in pieces with an "I don't give a damn about you" attitude.