Prior to my purchase of a 2010 Honda Civic LX, I owned a 2008 Honda Civic which was also purchased from Hillside Honda. That sale was also a bad experience but nothing compared to what occurred from the purchase of the new vehicle. The series of events listed below have occurred involving my purchase of a 2010 Civic LX from Hillside Honda:
Saturday, January 2, 2010, I was approaching 30,000 miles so I had an appointment with the service department for scheduled maintenance. During this service visit, a battery check was performed and I was told everything was fine with the car. I left feeling secure that what I was told was the truth. My car was parked in front of my home and was not used over the weekend. Monday, January 4, 2010, I attempted to start my car only to find out that it would not start and the battery was dead. I called road-side assistance that checked the car only to find out that nothing was left on but the battery was dead and the reasons were unknown. I could not comprehend how the battery died since the car was serviced on Saturday, so I made an appointment with Hillside Honda service department.
I arrived at the service department at 3pm, and while the 2008 Civic (VIN: 1HGFA165X8L097316) was being checked in the service department, I wandered in to the dealership (as I normally do during my service appointments) to look at the new cars, specifically hybrids. I greeted familiar faces in the dealership specifically, sales manager, Mohammed *** with whom I had dealt with in the purchase of the 2008 Civic. I told him I wanted to look at some hybrid cars due to excessive mileage I rack up during my weekly commute. Rather than handling my inquiries directly, Mohammed found a sales person, Manny, who seemed nice but was not the person I had hoped to handle the potential sale.
Manny answered questions I asked in regards to gas mileage and showed me two hybrids, the Fit and Insight. I asked about the Civic hybrid and he told me that they were discontinued and the dealership did not have any available. Manny asked if I was interested in test driving any of the cars and initially I answered, "No". Manny explained that hybrid cars have a completely different feeling from regular cars and I should experience it for myself if I was serious about purchasing a hybrid. I took his advice and he let me test drive the Fit. During the test drive, Manny explained to me a little more about the difference between hybrids and regular cars but the real feel was what changed my mind and made me glad that Manny insisted I take a test drive. We arrived back at the dealership around 4pm and I went to the service department to see if the 2008 Civic was done being checked.
As I walked towards the department, the service guys there told me they were looking for me because my car had been hit. Of course, I thought they were kidding and I even told them to stop kidding around. A sales manager there (in a white shirt, possibly named Dominick) began walking towards me with a solemn face. The look on his face was clearly not one about to share good news and he began to inform me that my car had indeed been hit. My first thought was how could this happen and I asked him how this happened. The guy in the white shirt quickly told me that the car had been hit by another customer as he attempted to leave the service lot.
They then walked me over to the car which was parked very close to the entrance/exit gate and clearly in a spot that could potentially be hit. The service person told me the police had been called and the customer was waiting in the office. They took no responsibility in the matter although they were still in possession of the car and had parked the car in a path of potential danger and seemed to vanish once informing me the car had been hit. The other customer and I were left alone to wait for the police to arrive, for what seemed to have been two hours or more. While waiting for the police to arrive, I called Mohammed around 5pm and informed him of what happened. He advised me to wait for the police and then come back to the dealership to look at new cars. I did not feel comfortable waiting in the service department with the other driver and went in to the dealership seeking some solace, considering what had happened. As I waited, I could not help but feel overwhelmed with all that had occurred and began crying.
After what seemed like a lifetime, the police arrived and took some information from me and the other customer involved. We then informed our insurance companies, and the other driver took full responsibility for the accident. After meeting with the police, I signed the paperwork to get the keys to my car from the service department. I then went back to the dealership. It was now 7pm. Mohammed was aware of what had happened with the 2008 Civic and directed me once again to the sales rep, Manny. Manny noticed that I was distraught and compassionately asked if everything was alright. I informed of what happened with the 2008 Civic and he told me not to worry, he would get me out of my car and into a brand new 2010 Civic. He seemed sincere and I trusted him. Little did I know that I had fully exposed my vulnerability by informing him of what happened.
Sometime around 7:30 pm, Manny and I were sitting at his desk going over my options for the new car. I was truly interested in the Civic Hybrid but Manny once again told me they were discontinued and not available at the dealership. I then decided to go with the 2010 Civic with the LX-s trim. Manny told me that the differences between the LX and LX-s were not significant and the LX may be a better model for me.
Now, the price war. I had already been at the dealership for four hours not anticipating anything that had occurred and lacking any research or evidence with comparable pricing for the car I wanted. I refused to pay the MSRP sticker price at over $18,000 and offered $16,500. I had purchased the 2008 Civic for $16,800 and thought $16,500 would have been a fair amount. Manny said there was no way he could let the car go for that price and at that point I requested to speak to sales manager Mohammed again. Manny said he would speak to Mohammed and disappeared for a bit. He came back with an amount of $17,000 and told me that there were very low APR's being offered at the time.
I still thought that figure could be negotiated further and told Manny that I was at a disadvantage since I had no way of checking other prices so he said I was getting the best deal out there but offered me his computer to let me check online for myself. The gesture, although it appeared to be unbiased, was completely the opposite. I was limited in both time and places to search and so was unable to make any headway with comparable pricing and had to settle for what was being offered. Hesitantly agreeing to the $17,000 purchase price for the 2010 Civic LX, Manny said he would need to get the trade-in value of the 2008 Civic. He left once again and I was expecting him to come back with a great number. I had originally purchased the car for $23,629.80 with auto-start, active alarm, Lo-Jack and 2.9% APR for 60-months.
I wanted to speak to Mohammed about the trade-in value but noticed he was with another customer sitting directly behind me. I overheard the conversation because the customer was extremely frustrated with Mohammed and he called Mohammed a liar and stated that he was promised one thing and was in fact told something else. The customer became irate and stormed out of the dealership. Mohammed then walked away and began calling the customer inappropriate names. I found it all a bit odd but was more interested in when Manny would be coming back to meet with me.
The less the value trade-in: Manny came back and told me that my 2008 Civic LX with 29,262 miles was only worth $8,500. I was shocked that it was worth so little and shared my disbelief with Manny. He stated that the car could have been worth an additional $1,500 (total $10,000) had I not reported the accident at the dealership. He stated that the accident would now appear on a Carfax and therefore reduced the selling price. I found that tidbit of information alarming since I was not the person that called the police but rather the service person working at Honda. I also found it odd that Manny would prefer the accident to go unreported. I voiced my concern with the $1,500 loss and he advised me once again that it was the best price. In the same position as before, I had very little bargaining power since I had no outside evidence to support my theory. I had to agree to the price that was being offered.
After all that back and forth, it was now time to decide on the color. I told Manny I wanted the Royal Blue and he wrote up all the necessary paper work and told me he would be back. Left alone again, it was now around 9pm. Manny came back and told me that the color I wanted was not in stock and I would have to wait three hours for it to arrive if I truly wanted that color. I did not want to settle for another color and therefore decided to wait the additional time hoping it would not actually be three hours. He seemed surprised that I agreed to wait and said he would need to place the order and left again.
At this point, I got up and walked towards Mohammed and told him what had happened during my discussion with Manny. He seemed unconcerned and I then asked him to give me a better deal. He said Manny knew what he was doing and not to worry. I then told him I was exhausted and hungry and wanted to get a bite to eat since I would have to be waiting for the car to arrive. He said I should wait for Manny to arrive before I leave. I grew tired of waiting and told him to call me when the car was ready. I went to a nearby diner and ate quickly. It was now about 10:30pm and I received a call from Mohammed telling me that I could come back that the car was ready. I quickly ate the rest of my food and left the diner only to arrive back at the dealership and have to wait yet again to meet with the finance person, Patrick O.
It was close to 11pm and I was still waiting to speak with Patrick.
I called Mohammed since I did not see him in the dealership and he informed me that he had left. I personally thought Mohammed leaving was unprofessional since I was interacting with him throughout my entire sale process. He said that I shouldn't have to wait much longer and that Manny would take care of me. I was annoyed at that point, to say the least, but waited yet again. Finally, some time close to 11:30, I met with the ever so busy finance person, Patrick. Beyond exhausted after having been at Hillside Honda for over 8 hours, I was more than ready for a quick transaction.
Patrick was a fast talker and had an accent which made things he was saying a bit difficult to understand. It was way too late to have extra features thrown at a person, much less an exhausted person, like me. I had been through so much already. He began jotting down figures about the Honda Care package convincing me that it was something that I needed. I was hesitant to agree but Patrick assured me that I could cancel it any time and receive a refund. With easy cancellation in mind, I agreed to it thinking I would go home and review the package and cancel the next day if necessary. I knew I wanted to add auto-start and an alarm to the car, however the pricing for these items were not clearly displayed nor explained to me after the sale.
Manny previously mentioned the low APR, 1.9% for 60 months or 0.9% for 36 months which was being offered. I always pay more than the monthly payment, so I obviously wanted the lower APR. I was aware that the lower APR would result in an increased monthly payment but the overall payment would be lower. I explained this to Manny and Patrick and they told me that I was incorrect. They both stated that as long as I pay more than my monthly payment, the APR applied would not affect the total cost. I was skeptical in their logic but it was now so late that I began to second guess my own logic. Through all the fast talk, random figures and skeptical logic, it was finally time for me to sign the dotted line. Eager to get out the place, with it being close to 1am, I signed the paperwork hoping to read all the fine print with a clear mind the next day. With everything signed, I left the finance office and waited yet again. My decision to add auto-start on the car resulted in a longer wait and I was advised that I would need to return the next day to complete the installation and hand over the title for the 2008 Civic along with the spare keys. Manny told me he would not be in, but I should see Mohammed. Annoyed that I would have to return, I agreed and finally took possession of the car at 1:15am on January 5th, 2010.
Tuesday, January 5, 2010: The day after. I was advised to return to the dealership to complete the auto-start installation and with having to make a return trip to the dealership I wanted to check the figures of my sale with comparable pricing online. With a clear mind, I was confident that I was taken advantage of by the sales department, I did some research. I checked the true trade-in value of the 2008 Civic and some other offers on 2010 Civics. My hunch was correct as I discovered from www. Edmunds.com that my trade-in was worth about $12,000 - $15,000 excluding the additional features I had on the car. I printed a copy to take with me to the dealership, hoping they would explain why my car was valued significantly lower. I was also convinced that the APR rate given to me would affect the overall cost, contrary to what Patrick said. I called sales manager Mohammed around 11:40am to check his availability and he advised to come in. Not willing to go alone seeing as it may make me vulnerable, I took my mother. We arrived at the dealership around 2pm and Manny was not in as he had said the night before, so we waited to see Mohammed. Mohammed greeted my mother and me, but looked less than pleased that she had come. He knew my mother from the previous sale and my mother was not the type of person to be taken advantage of in any shape or form and Mohammed remembered this. He had us wait a little longer and then took us into his office. I began telling him my concern with the sale from the previous day, specifically the trade-in value of the 2008 Civic, the sale price of the 2010 Civic, cancelling the Honda Care package and the APR rate. I also requested an itemized list of what had been added to the car. The sale price was $17,000, but the bill showed $19,505.
Mohammed told me that the trade in value was a good deal and at that point, I showed him the Edmunds.com value. He said the Edmunds.com value was incorrect and invalid since the dealership would not have to re-condition the car and re-certify the car and they did not use Edmunds.com to value their cars. He then pulled out a little black book and asked about the mileage on the old car. I told him it was 29,262 and he then began writing on the back of my printed out sheets. He jotted down $11,000 as the worth of the car excluding any additional features. He then began subtracting figures and somehow arrived at the $8,500 price Manny had stated the night before. At that point my mom looked at the print out from Edmunds.com and begin to argue with Mohammed and claimed he was robbing us of the true value. She stated that price given to me for the trade-in was too low and the dealership would probably resell it for double the price. Mohammed then stated I should not have agreed to figure quoted by Manny if I was not happy with the figure and that was nothing wrong with them making a little money.
In utter disbelief that he had just said that, I demanded that he throw in free accessories to compensate for the significant gap in the dealership value given to me and what was being quoted online. He agreed and told me to come back the next day with a list of all that I wanted and he would approve the items. I asked him for a Honda brochure and he said there were none available but I could just look up the items on the Honda website and print it out. With the trade-in value taken care of by the promised accessories, the next item to discuss was the APR. I told Mohammed that I wanted the 0.9% APR for 36 months, but Patrick had insisted and on the 1.9% for 60 months. I explained to him that 1.9 over 60 months would result in an overall higher interest payment than 0.9 over 36 months. He then pulled out a calculator and began showing me figures that made no sense. He said the difference between the two rates would be minimal which I found hard to believe. The savings would be about $800.
Mohammed then told me not to worry because he would throw in all the accessories. He said there was nothing he could do about the APR and it was up to Patrick. He advised me to come back the next day to receive my accessories and the itemized sale list. I told Mohammed that I wanted to cancel the Honda Care package and he attempted to persuade me that it was something I needed. I had similar coverage with Geico and did not need it at all, so I persisted with him cancelling it. He told me that I would not be able to cancel it right away but rather would have to wait to receive something in the mail. I found that hard to believe since I had read the cancellation policy which stated I could cancel anytime within the first 60 days. Mohammed insisted that I needed to wait for some card to come in the mail and said he could not cancel it at this time.
I asked Mohammed where the 2008 Civic was and informed him that my insurance company would be issuing a check for the damage from the other party involved. I told him that Geico would send an adjustor out to assess the damage and would need the car to stay at the dealership until they looked at it. He said he would make sure the car stayed at the dealership and they should call the service department when looking for the car. At that point, I handed over the title and spare keys to the 2008 Civic. We left the dealership around 2pm. At that point, I felt uneasy with what we had just discussed and realized no matter what he threw in, I was taken advantage of. I had lost thousands of dollars from the trade-in, to the sale price of the new vehicle, to the finance rate.
Mohammed had given me his business card in 2008 with his personal cell phone. During the 2008 sale process and the 2010 sale process, we communicated via cell phones and on 1/5/10, he took our business relationship a bit too far. He would always seem a bit flirtatious commenting on how I looked and asking if I had a boyfriend. I never took him seriously but rather directed the conversation back to something related to Honda. On Tuesday 1/5/10, Mohammed and I text messaged each other regarding our discussion earlier at the dealership. I wanted to be sure that he would follow through on his promise and he insisted he would. In one text, Mohammed asked me to go to dinner with him and I politely declined. I did not think it was appropriate for many reasons, mainly the situation that was unresolved with my sale. I explained to him that I didn't think it would be appropriate and he insisted that a simple dinner would not hurt. I then explained that my father (who knew Mohammed as well and was of the same ethnic background) would not approve and Mohammed said I need not tell my father. I found the whole thing disturbing and I stopped responding to his messages.
Wednesday, January 6, 2010: Mohammed had told me the day before to come back to the dealership to receive the accessories. As he said, I went to the Honda website and looked at the available accessories. I selected the items I wanted and printed a copy to show Mohammed as he instructed me to do the day before. I called him on his cell phone around 12:45pm and he advised me that he was not in the office but he would be in the next day. I was annoyed that it had now been three days and felt that I was getting the runaround with him. I explained that I had other things to do than visit Hillside Honda everyday and he said he would have everything straightened out. I advised him that I would not be able to be at the dealership before 6:30pm as I had work and he said that would be fine. Geico called me and informed me that they were unable to get in touch with anyone at the dealership and therefore unable to locate the car. I became worried and Geico said they would try again.
Thursday, January 7, 2010: Now back at work, I sent Mohammed a text message around 9:30am to make sure he would be in. He replied that he would be in but did not notify me of what time he would be leaving. I did not think to ask him since I had told him the day before I would not be available until after 6:30pm. I left work and rushed home to pick up my mother so that I was not alone. We got to dealership around 7pm. As I walked into the dealership, I noticed Mohammed was getting into a car so I shouted out to him. I asked where he was going and reminded him of our meeting. He said he was going to dinner with his boss and I was too late.
I reminded him that I told him I would be coming after 6:30pm and asked why he did not contact me to let me know he was leaving early. He said not to worry he would have someone take care of me and walked my mother and I to the desk and spoke to another sales manager, Frank C. He told Frank that I had a list of accessories and that he should approve it and then Mohammed left. Mohammed did not take a minute to look at our list nor did he even apologize for having to leave. Frank seemed nice but had no knowledge of the sale or anything that happened so I found it very unprofessional that Mohammed would pass us off to him. Frank told us to have a seat and he would be with us in a few minutes. We sat there waiting and feeling neglected. Mohammed had left and we would have to explain the whole situation to Frank. We sat there waiting and a female sales rep must have noticed how upset I was and asked if I needed help. I told her I was to meet with Mohammed but he left and she was shocked. She told me to speak to Peter Petito who was a manager there and then pointed to a gentleman. Frank then came over and walked us to a desk.
I explained to Frank everything that happened from the itemized sale list to the APR and told him that Mohammed said he would compensate for everything by giving me the accessories. Frank seemed skeptical that Mohammed would agree to that and asked to see the list....total $1,008. He said there was no way he could approve any of the items since he was not involved in the sale. I asked Frank about cancelling the Honda Care package and he told me the same thing Mohammed had told me the day before. My mother and I were so angry at that point. We did not understand what the hold-up was since Mohammed told Frank to approve my list. Frank said he would need to speak to Mohammed so I insisted that he call him, and Frank hesitantly called and said Mohammed was not answering. I was skeptical so I called Mohammed myself from the dealership line and explained to him what was going on. Frank excused himself and left me to speak to Mohammed. Mohammed spoke to me hurriedly and ended the call before I could pass the phone to Frank. I called again this time from my mother's cell phone sensing that Mohammed may not pick up if a call from the dealership or my cell phone. He picked up and I asked him what was going on because Frank refused to approve anything and my mom and I were sitting there like fools. He spoke to Frank briefly who told him that he couldn't approve the list and they ended the call.
Frustrated once again, I asked Frank for the itemized sale list and he said it was unavailable because the office was closed and I could either come back to pick it up or have it faxed to me the next day. Furious now, I gave him my number to call me to have the item faxed. Frank excused himself once again and my mother and I were left there sitting, unsure of what we were waiting for or what to do next. Overcome with emotion, I began to cry and a sales rep, Masud noticed. He came over and tried to console me. He was a familiar face from the dealership and offered some advice. He told me that there would be a meeting on Saturday 1/9/10 and if I wanted any type of resolution, my best bet would be to come that day. He also told me not to trust sales manager Mohammed because he was a bad guy. He also pointed out that the day of the sale (1/4/10) Masud tried to help me with the sale but Mohammed did not allow it. I was unaware of that and would have preferred to work with Masud rather than Manny. Masud also advised me that I would be receiving a customer service call from American Honda and I should share my experience.
While Masud spoke to me, my mother had completely lost her patience and began yelling in attempt to get some attention and it worked. Frank and Peter Petito walked toward us and asked us what was wrong. Frank was already aware of what was going on and explained the situation to Peter. He then made a photocopy of the list of accessories and said he would speak to Mohammed. I informed them of the situation with Geico to which Mohammed neglected to share with anyone. Geico was sending an adjustor out to inspect the damage on the 2008 Civic and was unable to neither locate the car nor get in touch with anyone at the dealership. Frank and Peter had not known about this at all and immediately took the old VIN number and searched for the car. They informed the car was getting ready to leave the dealership and I had mentioned it just in time. Frank gave me his card and told me to give Geico his number when they arrived at the dealership. Frank said he would give me a call the next day to fax the itemized sale list. Distressed and angry, we left the dealership around 9pm. Masud walked us out and for the first time in this hellish week I felt some genuine concern from someone at Hillside Honda.
Friday, January 8, 2010: Frank was to call and fax the itemized sale list but I did not receive a call so I called and got his voicemail. I called the dealership only to find out he was not in. As per my conversation with Masud, I was planning to go to the dealership on Saturday so I would just vent my frustration. I realized my experience at Hillside Honda had been miserable and decided to research customer reviews. In my investigation, I discovered they were not accredited with the Better Business Bureau and had a B- rating. Customers went on and on about complaints and to little surprise, sales manager Mohammed was mentioned in a few of them. I printed all the reviews and BBB review and began contemplating filing a complaint.
Geico called me and informed me that they could not get in touch with anyone and would try again. A few hours later, they were finally able to get in touch with someone and sympathized with my experience. The adjustor proclaimed that the staff at the dealership were less than helpful and would try to get me as much as possible for the damage.
Saturday, January 9, 2010: With my mother by my side, we arrived at the dealership bright and early, around 9:30am. We were informed that all the sales reps and managers were in a meeting until 10am. A couple of minutes after 10am, the staff at Hillside Honda began to filter on to the sales floor and we waited. Wanting to speak to Mohammed, he, without surprise, directed us to Frank. Curious as to why Mohammed refused to deal with us, we sat with Frank who apologized for being out the previous day. I asked Frank if they had spoken to Mohammed and he said he was unsure if Peter P. had addressed him. Frank said that in regards to the accessories, he could not give me everything which left me feeling disappointed. With all that I had been through, all he was approved to give me was all-season mats ($117) and a trunk tray ($107); however neither of those items were available that day and I would need to return on Tuesday to pick them up. At that point, I felt so defeated with everything I agreed just so I could start enjoying my new car and start my new year without worry. I asked about the itemized sale list and he said the office was closed on Saturday and he would fax it to me. Needless to say, I have yet to hear back from Frank or receive the piece of paper I've been requesting for days.
Tuesday, January 12, 2010: I contacted Mohammed via text message to see if he was in and did not receive a response. I was told to come in on Tuesday to receive the trunk tray and mats, but since I did not hear from Mohammed, Frank or anyone else at the dealership I decided I would go there the following day. Wednesday, January 13, 2010: I contacted Mohammed via text message around 12pm to find out if he was in the office. He replied that he was in but I should contact Frank regarding the accessories. I thought it did not matter who I dealt with to pick up the items so long as I received them. I told him that Frank told they would be ready and I was coming in later that day to pick them up. I arrived at the dealership around 3:30pm and did not see Frank. I saw Mohammed and Masud on the sales floor and told Mohammed that I was there for the items. He told Masud to handle the situation and Masud gladly greeted me and took the car keys to have the items put in the car. I also reminded Mohammed that I had not yet received the itemized sale list and he said he would have Masud get a copy for me. I waited for about 20 minutes or so and then a service person advised me that my car was ready to go. I can only assume that Masud drove the car to the service area and they put the items in, since I expected Masud to return the car to me. Once the service person told me the car was ready, I exited the dealership, hoping it would be the last I would ever have to deal with them. After leaving, I realized I still had not received the piece of paper I've been requesting for weeks.
My experience at Hillside Honda may seem comedic to some, however it is no exaggeration. All the events did in fact occur and to make matters worse, I am on the email list for Hillside Honda. On January 26th, I received an email letting me know they were having a special and the price of the car I purchased less than a month ago was being sold at $15,354. This email also had a link for their Black Book value so of course I checked the value of the car I had traded in. According to their own evaluation system, my 2008 Civic was worth $11,845 not including my extra features. According to their own email, Hillside Honda had ripped me off and I guess the email was proof.
I finally got that call from American Honda on Thursday 1/28/10. The representative was very sympathetic and gave me the number to contact customer service at American Honda. I called on Wednesday, 2/3/10 and spoke to a representative named Cecily, who had the unpleasant task of typing all that I was telling her. She was in disbelief of all that happened and actually shed some light on my situation. She informed me that the dealership could've adjusted the APR and it was up to their discretion. She said they also lied about cancelling the Honda Care and it could've indeed been cancelled the day after as I had requested. I told them everything and I have been assigned a case number. I'm waiting to hear back and needless to say, Hillside Honda has been attempting to contact me regarding the survey from their corporate headquarters.
Based on my horrible experience at Hillside Honda, I will never shop there again nor recommend them to anyone I care about. There service was dreadful and the majority of the staff was heartless and care very little, if any, about their customers. I will be reporting them to the BBB which may hopefully bring their already low rating down lower. I hope to receive some type of satisfaction from this whole drawn out experience.