
Michael of Livonia, MI on Jan. 28, 2012
Satisfaction Rating: 1/5
I am the owner of a 2004 Ford Free Star minivan and in December 2011, I took the vehicle into my local Ford dealership service center to diagnose what turned out to be a brake problem. The technicians at the dealership told me I needed to have the brake pads replaced on all four wheels, including the rear brake rotors. They also indicated the front rotors needed maintenance as well, but said they could grind them down instead of having to replace them. I was quoted a cost of $650.00 for the repair. Believing this quote to be high, I called around to a couple of other auto repair shops, including the Goodyear Auto Service Center, located at 19424 Middlebelt, Livonia, MI 48152, in order to get comparison quotes.
This is where my problems began with Goodyear Auto Service Center. I spoke with a sales associate at the Goodyear store and he informed me they could do the same repair for $450.00. Elated with the lower quote, I took my vehicle to their store. However, a short time after I dropped off my vehicle, I received a phone call from the same sales associate who said the front brake rotors for my vehicle also had to be replaced, which would increase the repair cost to $550.00. This being still below the Ford dealership quote, I agreed to have this additional repair done. After agreeing to this, the sales associate then suggested they take apart and inspect the brake calipers to ensure there were no issues with them. I then asked how much it would cost in the event calipers needed to be replaced and the sales associate said, it would increase the total cost of the repair to $830.00. I then asked him if it were possible to have the calipers inspected and if an issue was discovered would I have the option to still decline the repair. The sales associate told me this was not possible because he said the store would incur liability if they were to put back in place defective calipers on my vehicle. So it was an all or nothing affair.
Skeptical about this explanation, I told the sales associate I would get back with him regarding a decision on the caliper portion of the repair. Immediately after getting off the phone with the Goodyear sales associate, I contacted the Ford dealership where I had originally taken my vehicle to and specifically asked if their inspection the day before revealed any issues with the brake calipers. They told me there was no problem with the calipers.
Now believing the Goodyear sales associate was simply trying to up-sell me a repair I didn't need, I called the store back and told the same sales associate not to worry about the calipers. So they then proceeded with the repair as originally agreed and I ended up picking up my minivan later the same day.
Everything seemed fine at that point. That is, until about three days ago when my wife, who regularly drives the minivan, began to notice a loud squeaking sound every time she applied the brakes. Consequently, I had my wife take the vehicle back to the Goodyear store in order to see what was wrong with the brakes since obviously the brake repair was still under warranty as they had replaced the brakes not even a month ago.
As it so happened, the same sales associate who I had dealt with happened to be working and assisted my wife. After examining the brakes the sales technician informed my wife that the squeaking sound was result of the fact the rear calipers were frozen. He also told her that he had told me back when I first brought the vehicle in for repair last month that the calipers needed to be replaced, but that I had declined the repair. He then told my wife it would now cost $575.00 in order to have the calipers replaced.
When my wife informed me of this my first thought was the repair quote of $575.00 seemed pretty high, especially when you consider the fact I just paid the store $550.00 for an entire 4-wheel brake job. One would think that this would have been taken into consideration, but obviously wasn't. Second, I was still not convinced the calipers were the problem based on what the Ford dealership had previously told me.
So instead of having the repair done, I, first, re-contacted the Ford dealership and obtained a quote to have the rear calipers replaced. They provided me a quote of only $407.14. I then contacted another auto service shop that I trust and had used on a few occasions before and they provided me a quote of only $312.00. Moreover, I explained the entire situation about the Goodyear Auto Service Center to the owner of this shop and he suggested I bring the minivan in to their facility for an independent brake examination, which is what I did.
As it turns out, this service center diagnosed the problem as not being the rear calipers, like the Goodyear sales associate had told my wife. In fact, the calipers were fine, just like the Ford dealership mechanic had said in the first place. Instead, it was found the squeaking noise was result of low-grade quality brake pads Goodyear had installed as part of the original repair.
More specifically, the brake pad they had used did not exactly fit the rear brake calipers, which I understand is a common problem with low-quality brake pads. In fact, I was told by the shop owner that it was evident the Goodyear mechanic had attempted to hammer the pad into place in an attempt to make it fit properly but was not successful. Hence, the squeaking noise.
Fortunately, the service repair shop owner was gracious enough to replace the low-grade brake pads that Goodyear had incorrectly installed on my vehicle with a better grade pad and now my vehicles brakes are operating quietly. Moreover, he only charged me for labor ($169.00), and threw in the cost of the replacement pads for free out of sympathy for my plight with Goodyear.
As should be obvious by now, I am extremely upset with the service I had received at the Goodyear Auto Service Center and feel I should be reimbursed the $169.00. I had to pay the other auto repair business to fix the original brake repair in which they had performed on my vehicle not even a month ago. In addition, I feel it was very unprofessional and unscrupulous on the part of the Goodyear sales associate to attempt to sell me an unnecessary $575.00 brake caliper repair that had nothing to do with the problem to begin with.
By the way, the owner of the shop who had corrected the repair had informed me that the Goodyear Auto Service Center store I had taken it to had been in trouble with the State of Michigan for charging customers for unnecessary repairs. Bottom Line: Steer clear of Goodyear Auto Service Centers, at least the one in Livonia, Michigan.