
Gene of Scottsdale, AZ on May 7, 2003
This first started in March 1999. We wanted an affordable luxury automobile, and we were impressed by our test drive of a 1999 Cadillac Catera, so we ordered a fully equipped ivory white version, with dealer-installed rear spoiler. The car looks somewhat bland, but attractive, but from the day we drove it out of the showroom, there were problems. Rattles, rattles, all over the place, and as soon as some were eliminated, others appeared. But the worst part of it all was the awful quality control. We had half a dozen cooling system failiures, four battery replacements, replacements of an assortment of parts that included the ignition lock, brake light switch (a serious potential safety hazard), oxygen sensor, and gas cap cover. In addition, we suffered from mysterious and annoying driveline noises, spongy brakes, increasingly poor steering wheel response, and a strange vibration from the transmission stick.
Although the local dealers were reasonably accommodating, they could never quite get a handle on the extent of the troubles. As of the day the car was turned in at the end of the lease, and after 24 service visits, the car still shuddered when applying the brakes at 45 miles per hour, and the transmission stick rattled at that speed during breaking and over bumps. The radio still couldn't remember a station when you turn it off, and various and sundry rattles still persisted. Worse, when the dealer fixed a damanged door jamb, they broke a fitting on the inside door handle and tore some of the rubber molding.
This is but a small part of the ills that plagued us with the 1999 Catera. All Cadillac would offer when we repeatedly asked them to buy it back was an insult, an offer of a $2,000 incentive towards purchase of another Cadillac. Fat chance. General Motors, you lost a customer for life with this turkey. May 2003 Update: Before the vehicle was returned to the dealer at the end of the lease, I had it inspected by a certified mechanic and was stunned to discover that the problems were worse than I imagined, with serious defects still present with the brakes, driveline and steering mechanism. In short, the car was unsafe to drive. Note that this mechanic is not in the business of doing repairs himself and thus isn't inflating the severity of the defects to make some money. Actually, he provides consulting services and serves as an expert witness for a local lemon law attorney.
Upon learning that GM Chairman Jack Smith was retiring on May 1st, I wrote a letter to him, not expecting a response. Early in May, someone from the executive office called and said they had reviewed the information but could not grant my request for a few refund because I no longer owned the car. As if that had anything to do with it. Clearly, GM is not capable of satisfying the many disappointed customers who have been inconvenienced with this defective model.