
Patrick of Lake Havasu City, AZ on Sept. 29, 2008
On May 8, 2008 Toyota Poway completely mis-diagnosed our 2005 Toyota Prius electrical problem. (The VSC light had come on). John Capponi, with Toyota Poway, called Lynette (customer wife) and asked her exactly what happened, as he couldnt figure out the problem. After extensively detailing the events, including the fact our grandchild had been playing in the front of the car as Lynette and our daughter were putting things in the car.
Almost two hours later, John called Lynette to say they found some coins in the radio, and the coins had shorted things out. This caused the radio, a/c, smart key, and display not to work. The heater was stuck in the on position. Lynette had John call Patrick (customer husband).
John told Patrick the radio was shorted and needed to be replaced. We couldnt wait three days for the radio to be ordered and arrive as we needed to drive back to Lake Havasu City, AZ. John said hed replace some fuses and disconnect the radio. Patrick asked John if the radio would be the only thing that would not work if we drove it to Havasu. He said yes and we would have no radio on the trip to AZ. Patrick asked if he was leaving the radio out. He said no, it wouldnt look good and wanted to fill the hole. Patrick said to go ahead and wed have our Toyota dealer order the radio when we got back.
We picked up the car after about 3 hours and paid $95. The invoice said:
upon inspection found dome lamp and door lock (remote key) systems shorted out able to trace malfunction to radio unit shorted out replaced blown fuses, repaired electrical but radio in need of replacement customer from Arizona and here on a visit so not enough time to order a replacement radio unit they will be taking car to their regular servicing dealer when they return home (radio model #51807 serial #SH71094).?
When we drove back to the motel to pack up, we noticed the following not working (in addition to the radio which we had expected): the air conditioning, the display, and the heater was on. Lynette called John and told him about these problems. He said, I forgot about the air conditioning? (contradictory to what John told Patrick).
We were ok to make the 6 hour trip back to AZ with the radio not working, but not with the a/c inoperable. We proceeded on our trip to AZ as we had not time to see a different Toyota dealer in the area to see if they could fix the a/c. The entire trip had to be made with the windows down in hot weather and heat blowing on us the entire time. The baby cried almost the entire time because of the noise created with the windows down and the discomfort of the outside heat exacerbated by the heater on which could not be turned off. In short, it was the trip from hell caused solely by the incompetence of Toyota Poway employees John Capponi and mechanic (we believe his name to be) Tran?.
Lynette called Toyota Kingman, AZ the next day (May 9, 2008) to order the radio and told the lady what had happened. Their mechanic was walking by and overheard the conversation. He got on the phone and asked Lynette if she could bring the car in right away. He said he did not want to order a radio for the car if it was unnecessary, and it sounded to him like Toyota Poway mis-diagnosed the problem.
Lynette took it in that day. The mechanic found and fixed the problem in one hour (no questions to Lynette as to what had happened). It cost $103. The mechanic handed Lynette a penny and said this was your problem. It was found in the radio?. He removed it, replaced some fuses (probably the same ones John replaced that probably shorted out again because he didnt remove the penny) and the car was good to go. The Kingman mechanic said the radio was perfectly fine and didnt need to be replaced. Lynette asked why couldnt Poway have fixed it?? The mechanic said theres no reason?.
Lynette called John at Poway Toyota when she got home. She asked John how many coins he had removed from the radio. He said he never removed any coins because they never removed the radio (contradictory to what John told Patrick). Lynette asked him why he hadnt. John said their mechanics dont know how to open up the radio they just remove them and replace them. Lynette then asked John if they were a real Toyota dealership. John said they were. Lynette asked John why Kingman could fix the radio and Poway couldnt, and John said maybe Kingmans mechanics have more experience. Lynette told John she was very dissatisfied with that answer.
The Poway Toyota Customer Relations in Georgia called some days later. Lynette couldnt talk to them on the first call because she was too sick from the drive back from Poway. The second call they asked how the service was on a scale of 0 to 10, 10 being the best. Lynette said a 0. She gave them detailed information about the utter incompetence of Toyota Poway.
It has been some 5 months since this unfortunate occurrence and the general manager of Toyota Poway, Rick Gallagher, has done nothing in an attempt to contact us regarding the deplorable incident of his employees. This is the second submittal to BAR as the first one dated 6/23/08 was never received by BAR.
In short, we were in an unfamiliar city, did not know any mechanics, and relied on the Toyota dealership name. We expected excellence and got incompentence.
We paid $95 for nothing.
The drive home was hell. Windows had to be down when it was above 100 degrees outside and the heater had to be on because of Toyota Poways inability to fix a simple problem. The baby cried almost the entire way home. Everyone got sick for about a week as a result of the utter incompetence of Toyota Poway.
Toyota Poway should pay us the $103 it cost us to have a competent Toyota dealer fix the problem Toyota Poway was incapable of doing. Toyota Poway should also pay us for pain and suffering we experienced as a direct result of their incompetence. It is clear to us that both John and Tran didnt know what they were doing. An investigation of both John and Tran should be conducted to determine if 1) they have met the requirements of both classroom and experience required by the State to work on the jobs they were on, and 2) if John and Tran are found to have met the State requirements, they should both be required to take remedial training to learn, or re-learn, some of the basics they should know. In addition, an investigation of Toyota Poway should be conducted to evaluate their procedures and processes in allowing incompetent staff to work on Toyota products.
A copy of this complaint will be forwarded to Toyota Headquarters.