
Rich of Mauston, WI on Dec. 25, 2010
For the second time this year, an employee of Baraboo-based Home Instead was found stealing from a former Wisconsin Dells Police chief. Tara ***, 24, of Cazenovia was ticketed for felony theft from a vulnerable adult on Dec. 7 after stealing $1,613.24 from Frank *****'s bank account over 13 different occasions in October, according to the police report. *** was a caregiver employed by Home Instead who was assigned to take care of the 73-year-old Schoeninger at his home from December 2009 until he transferred to an assisted living center in Illinois in late October. Her duties included cooking, housekeeping, personal hygiene and running errands, such as picking up mail.
In February, another employee, Sarah *****, 31, of Mauston, was referred to the Columbia County District Attorney's office for forgery and theft after she wrote $18,000 in checks to herself from ******'s bank account and stole another $4,000 in cash from him. She did so from December 2009 until February. Because of that case, Schoeninger's subsequent caregivers were given Walgreens and Wal-Mart gift cards to make purchases for him, and had no reason to use his ATM card,. Schoeninger's financial power of attorney, Joanne *** ***, told Detective Jed ***** this last month.
****** was given a new ATM card in February because of the previous theft, but neither he nor *** *** ever activated it. According to the Bank of Wisconsin Dells, ******* activated the card in October. ****** told ***** she had never done anything like this before, and said she used the card after finding the PIN on a piece of mail. She used it to withdraw between $100 and $200 from ATMs at Viking Village in Reedsburg, Zinke's Village Market, the Bank of Wisconsin Dells, Kwik Trip in Baraboo and Reedsburg and Kaminski Bros. Chop Shop at Chula Vista Resort. She told ***** she would take the card and return it to ******'s wallet the next day. When questioned about the theft, ******* admitted to using the card without permission and apologized for her actions. She has since taken out a loan and paid full restitution. She said she stole from ****** to pay bills, and said she has a lot of financial problems.
Despite having a car payment and several tens of thousands of dollars worth of student loans, ***** said ******* admitted using none of the stolen money for those debts. Seidl noted that she was wearing a new winter jacket and had what appeared to be a Coach-brand purse. ******* is scheduled to appear in Columbia County Circuit Court on Jan. 26. As for *********, online court records show she was never charged for the forgery and theft in Columbia County. However, the case was prosecuted in Juneau County, likely because she cashed the checks at Oakdale Credit Union in Mauston. She pled guilty to two counts of felony forgery in August, and was sentenced to pay $20,998.34 in restitution. Two other counts of forgery were dismissed, but read in.**** was put on probation for two and a half years, had to submit her DNA, and ordered to undergo mental help therapy and an alcohol assessment. This was posted in Crime and courts on Tuesday, December 21, 2010 3:14 pm.